Chinese President Xi Jinping and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin make it look like they're the best of friends. Xi took his place at the right-hand side of Putin, the position of a steadfast ally, as their troops marched together on Red Square as part of Moscow's Victory Day parade. Hours earlier, Xi described the bond between the two countries as "unbreakable" and added that Russia and China should be "friends of steel". This is Xi's 11th visit to Russia since becoming president in 2013 and the two leaders have met on more than 40 occasions. Putin has already announced plans to visit China in the autumn and the two leaders have even, in the past, shared a rare public hug. But there is more to this relationship than meets the eye. "We see a lot of exchanges between the two men and patriotic displays of togetherness," said Mathieu Boulegue, from the Center for European Policy Analysis. "They can be friends on one end or co-operating on one end and then ripping each other apart on others, and actually be competitors in certain aspects of their relationship. "We get wowed by the symbolism. There's a lot of performance around this relationship. But it's interesting to look at the real substance." In truth, President Xi is walking a very fine line. Russia is an important partner for China but Putin's invasion of Ukraine has made him an international pariah in much of the world. Beijing needs to be careful that its friendship with Moscow doesn't isolate other prospective partners, especially as it is fighting an economic war with the United States. China has been courting Europe for several months and stepped up its campaign after Donald Trump became US president. Beijing has been keen to portray itself as a stable alternative global partner in contrast to an unpredictable White House in Washington. There were some signs earlier this week that these diplomatic overtures were working. Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission, and António Costa, the president of the European Council, exchanged messages on Tuesday with President Xi and Chinese Premier Li Qiang to celebrate the 50th anniversary of bilateral relations. The stumbling block of any prospective partnership has been Beijing's close-knit relationship with Moscow and its economic support for Russia. China has not condemned its "old friend" for the invasion and instead calls for an end to the "crisis". If President Xi appears to stand too close to Putin, it could cause friction with Europe at a time when it is looking for friendship. But the Chinese leader has another key message to send. Trump's initial attempts to end the war in Ukraine had him touting his close personal relationship with Putin. It prompted analysts to ask if Washington was trying to drive a wedge between Moscow and Beijing. Xi will want to make it clear to Trump this is not possible. "Together, we must foil all schemes to disrupt or undermine our bonds of amity and trust," Xi wrote in a signed article for Russian media. The Russian and Chinese leaders also described Trump's plans for a "Golden Dome" missile defence shield over the US as "deeply destabilising", and argued that it would weaponise space. Both leaders are keen to present their vision of an alternative world order in the face of what they believe is US hegemony. But Xi will be aware that while China is a superpower – Russia's power is now limited. This is no longer a partnership of equals. The war in Ukraine has weakened Russia's economy and depleted its arsenal and army. Western sanctions have also left Moscow far more reliant on Beijing for economic survival. They have severely weakened the Kremlin on the world stage. "Russia needs China much more than the opposite is true," Boulegue said. Moscow will need to "suck it up", he added. Putin may lean into his friend as they watch the tanks roll through Red Square and they can team up when they need each other. But behind the bold statements, the smiles, handshakes and the occasional hug, there are potential sources of discord and disharmony which could surface in the years to come.
Xi shows he wants to be close to Putin - but not too close
TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:
"Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin Strengthen Ties Amid Complex Geopolitical Landscape"
Bbc News
8.6
TruthLens AI Summary
Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin showcased their close ties during the recent Victory Day parade in Moscow, where Xi positioned himself at Putin's side, symbolizing their alliance. During the event, Xi characterized the relationship between China and Russia as 'unbreakable', emphasizing that both nations should be 'friends of steel'. This visit marks Xi's 11th trip to Russia since he assumed the presidency in 2013, and the two leaders have met over 40 times, highlighting the depth of their diplomatic engagement. While their public displays of camaraderie, including a rare hug, suggest a strong partnership, experts caution that the relationship is complex, with elements of cooperation and competition coexisting. Mathieu Boulegue from the Center for European Policy Analysis notes that while the symbolism is striking, the underlying dynamics are more nuanced and require careful examination.
Xi's delicate balancing act is evident as he seeks to maintain a relationship with Russia while avoiding alienation from other global partners, particularly in light of the ongoing economic tensions with the United States. China has been actively courting European nations to position itself as a stable alternative amid perceived unpredictability from the US. Recent communications between Xi and European leaders marked the 50th anniversary of bilateral relations, though concerns linger regarding China's support for Russia amid the Ukraine conflict. Xi's approach aims to counter any narratives suggesting that the US could exploit divisions between Beijing and Moscow. Despite the appearance of a strong alliance, analysts warn that Russia's diminished global standing post-Ukraine invasion has tilted the partnership dynamics in favor of China, as Russia increasingly relies on Beijing for economic support. The potential for discord exists beneath the surface of their apparent friendship, suggesting that while they may present a united front, challenges could arise as geopolitical tensions evolve.
TruthLens AI Analysis
The article explores the complex relationship between Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, highlighting both the apparent camaraderie and the underlying strategic considerations that characterize their partnership. While the two leaders present a united front, the analysis reveals a more nuanced dynamic, shaped by international perceptions and geopolitical realities.
Diplomatic Balancing Act
Xi Jinping's statements about the "unbreakable" bond with Russia, alongside his public displays of support, suggest a desire to maintain a strong partnership. However, this relationship must be navigated carefully due to the global fallout from Putin's actions, particularly the invasion of Ukraine. China’s need to engage with other world powers, such as Europe and the United States, complicates its alignment with Russia. This diplomatic balancing act is aimed at fostering economic opportunities without alienating potential partners.
Symbolism vs. Substance
The article critiques the performance aspect of the Xi-Putin relationship, indicating that while there are public displays of friendship, the reality may involve competition and differing national interests. Analysts point out that such displays can obscure deeper tensions and competitive elements in their interactions. The emphasis on symbolism may serve to project strength and unity, but it risks oversimplifying a multifaceted geopolitical situation.
Implications for Global Relations
By maintaining a friendship with Russia, China risks being seen as complicit in international isolation efforts against Putin, particularly from Western nations. The article suggests that China's attempts to position itself as a stable global partner contrast sharply with the unpredictability of U.S. foreign policy. This positioning could lead to new diplomatic partnerships or exacerbate existing tensions, particularly as China seeks to engage with Europe more robustly.
Market Reactions
In terms of economic implications, the portrayal of this relationship may influence market perceptions, especially in sectors sensitive to geopolitical developments. Companies engaged in international trade or investments tied to either China or Russia may see fluctuations based on how this relationship is perceived by the international community.
Public Perception and Media Representation
The article aims to shape public perception by emphasizing the complexities of Xi's relationship with Putin. By highlighting the dual aspects of cooperation and competition, it encourages readers to consider the broader implications of this partnership beyond mere friendship. This narrative may resonate with audiences wary of authoritarian partnerships and the potential for geopolitical instability.
Overall, the article presents a well-rounded view of the Xi-Putin relationship, balancing the public display of camaraderie with a critical examination of the underlying strategic calculations. The insights provided suggest that while the friendship appears strong, significant challenges and competitive dynamics exist beneath the surface.