'No food when I gave birth': Malnutrition rises in Gaza as Israeli blockade enters third month

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Malnutrition Crisis Deepens in Gaza Amid Ongoing Israeli Blockade"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 6.0
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In Gaza's Nasser hospital, five-month-old Siwar Ashour exemplifies the devastating impact of the ongoing Israeli blockade, which has now persisted for three months. Siwar exhibits alarming signs of malnutrition, weighing only 2kg, far below the healthy weight for her age. Her mother, Najwa, reveals the dire circumstances under which Siwar was born, with a lack of food and nutrients preventing her from breastfeeding effectively. The hospital has managed to provide some formula milk, but the supply is critically low, and Najwa is uncertain about how to sustain her daughter once they leave the hospital. Siwar's doctor, Ziad al-Majaida, emphasizes the severity of the situation, noting that many children are suffering due to the blockade, which has halted the import of essential supplies, including food and medical care. Without immediate intervention, Siwar's condition could deteriorate further, putting her life at risk.

The humanitarian crisis in Gaza is exacerbated by skyrocketing food prices and the closure of charity kitchens that once provided meals to thousands. The World Food Programme has reported the shutdown of numerous bakeries and kitchens due to supply shortages, leaving families without adequate nutrition. Looting by both criminal gangs and desperate civilians has intensified the crisis, with aid organizations struggling to meet the rising demand. As the Israeli government continues its military operations in Gaza, it has been accused of imposing a collective punishment on the civilian population. The United Nations has condemned the blockade, calling for the urgent provision of humanitarian aid, while Israeli officials deny the existence of a food crisis. Amidst the chaos, accusations against Hamas for hoarding food and failing to distribute aid have surfaced, indicating a complex interplay of local governance and humanitarian needs. The situation remains precarious, with reports suggesting that without an immediate solution, the humanitarian situation could lead to further suffering and instability in the region.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The report presents a distressing account of malnutrition in Gaza, particularly highlighting the case of a five-month-old girl, Siwar Ashour, who is suffering from severe health issues due to a lack of essential food supplies as a result of the Israeli blockade. It emphasizes the human cost of the ongoing conflict by focusing on the plight of vulnerable populations, such as infants and their mothers.

Intent Behind the Article

This article appears designed to evoke empathy and raise awareness about the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. By illustrating the personal story of Siwar and her mother, Najwa, it aims to humanize the broader issue of malnutrition resulting from geopolitical conflicts. The choice of words and the vivid descriptions of Siwar's condition serve to elicit a strong emotional response from the reader, potentially mobilizing public opinion against the blockade and the conditions in Gaza.

Public Perception

The narrative is likely to foster a sense of compassion and urgency among readers, who may perceive the situation in Gaza as dire and in need of immediate international intervention. The depiction of a fragile infant suffering from malnutrition is likely to resonate with many, thereby shaping public sentiment toward support for humanitarian aid efforts.

Concealed Aspects

While the article focuses on the immediate crisis of malnutrition, it may not delve into the broader geopolitical context or the complexities surrounding the blockade. The emphasis on individual suffering might overshadow discussions about the political factors contributing to the blockade and the ongoing conflict, potentially simplifying a multifaceted issue.

Reliability of the Report

The report appears to be credible and grounded in specific observations and testimonies from individuals directly affected by the crisis. However, the lack of independent verification due to restrictions on journalists may raise questions about the completeness of the narrative. While the emotional weight of the story is compelling, it is important to consider the potential for bias given the context of the conflict.

Connections to Other Reports

When compared to other reports on the humanitarian situation in conflict zones, this article shares similarities in its focus on personal stories to highlight larger issues. It is part of a broader media narrative that seeks to draw attention to the human impact of war, often connecting to discussions on international humanitarian law and human rights.

Potential Societal Impact

The report could galvanize public support for humanitarian initiatives, potentially influencing policymakers to take action. It may also contribute to increased scrutiny of the blockade and calls for international intervention, impacting diplomatic relations and humanitarian funding.

Target Audience

The article is likely aimed at a global audience, particularly those sympathetic to humanitarian causes. Activist groups, human rights advocates, and individuals concerned with international relations may find this story compelling, as it aligns with their interests in social justice and humanitarian aid.

Financial Market Implications

While the report may not have direct implications for stock markets, it could influence public sentiment towards companies involved in humanitarian aid or those operating in conflict zones. Increased awareness of the crisis may encourage investment in humanitarian solutions or affect the operations of businesses in the region.

Geopolitical Relevance

This report is relevant to current global discussions about humanitarian crises and international relations, particularly in the context of Middle Eastern geopolitics. It highlights issues that resonate with ongoing debates about human rights and the responsibilities of nations in conflict situations.

Artificial Intelligence Influence

It is unlikely that artificial intelligence played a significant role in the creation of this article. However, if AI were to be involved, it might have been used for data analysis or trend monitoring, potentially shaping the narrative by emphasizing emotional and impactful stories. The article’s focus on a specific case rather than a broader overview suggests a human touch in the storytelling.

The overall reliability of the report rests on its emotional engagement and personal narratives, though it should be read with an understanding of the complex realities behind the situation in Gaza. This complexity underscores the importance of seeking a comprehensive understanding of humanitarian crises that considers multiple perspectives.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Sometimes in war it is the smallest sound that can make the loudest statement. In Gaza's Nasser hospital, a five-month-old girl struggles to cry. Siwar Ashour is hoarse. Her voice has been robbed of the energy to fully communicate her distress. She cannot absorb regular formula milk and doctors say the Israeli blockadenow in its third month means supplies of the food she needs are scarce. Siwar sounds as if the weight of the war is pressing down on her lungs. Her mother Najwa, 23, is changing Siwar's nappy. She weighs just over 2kg (4lb 6oz). A baby girl of five months should be around or over 6kg. "There was no food when I gave birth to her," says Najwa. "If I wanted to feed myself so I could breastfeed her, I had no nutrients to make my health better... She now only drinks formula milk, and we don't know how we'll be able to provide it for her." Israel has banned international journalists from entering Gaza to report independently. A local BBC colleague filmed the unmistakable signs of advanced malnutrition on Siwar's body. The head that seems far too big for her frame. The stick-like arms and legs. The ribs pressing against her skin when she tries to cry. The large brown eyes that follow her mother's every small movement. Najwa worries about what will happen when she must leave the hospital. "The hospital provided with great difficulty some milk for her, they searched all of the hospitals but they could only find it in one. They told me that they will give me one bottle when we leave, but it is barely enough for four days. Her father is blind and he can't provide a bottle of milk for her, and even if we found it, it would be expensive, and he doesn't work." According to Siwar's doctor, Ziad al-Majaida, it was her second stay in the hospital. She was back because of the shortage of milk formula. "Nothing enters through the borders, no milk, food or anything. This leads to big problems here for the kids. This baby needs a specific type of milk. It was available before, but because of the border closure, the stocks have run out for a while now." The hospital is trying to find more supplies but Siwar is weak and suffering from constant diarrhoea. "If she stays like this, her life will be in danger, but if her milk or treatment were provided, then her state would improve," says Dr Majaida. Since the beginning of the year, according to the UN, about 10,000 cases of acute malnutrition among children have been identified. Food prices have rocketed by as much as 1,400%. Charity kitchens, which have helped hundreds of thousands of Gazans, are shutting as food supplies run out. Twenty-five bakeries supported by the World Food Programme have been forced to close. In the southern city of Khan Younis, where Nasser hospital is located, our journalist visited a kitchen run by Shabab Gaza (Gaza Youth), which delivers food directly to families. Enough for a meal a day per family. The head of the charity, Mohammad Abu Rjileh, 29, said three of their four kitchens had closed due to lack of supplies. Looting by criminal gangs, and by desperate civilians has deepened the supply crisis. "Many of the organisations that support us had their warehouses looted. Instead of having enough ingredients to cook 10,000 meals daily - ingredients that were expected to last us an additional week or 10 days - we now have enough for only one or two days. If no immediate solution is implemented and the borders are not opened as soon as possible, we will be forced to stop cooking." Israel cut off all humanitarian aid and other supplies from entering Gaza on 2 March, and resumed its military offensive two weeks later, saying it was putting pressure on Hamas to release the 59 hostages the group is still holding in Gaza, up to 24 of whom are still thought to be alive. The United Nations has said the Israeli blockade constitutes "a cruel collective punishment" on civilians. The UN's humanitarian director, former British diplomat Tom Fletcher, said that international law was unequivocal. "As the occupying power, Israel must allow humanitarian support in... Aid, and the civilian lives it saves, should never be a bargaining chip," he warned. I put this point to Boaz Bismuth, a leading member of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud party. He denies there is an aid crisis caused by the blockade. "There is food in Gaza... Israel wouldn't do such a restriction if the population didn't have food. I mean, I know my country perfectly well," he said. I put it to Bismuth that he was denying the evidence of people's eyes, that children were starving. "There are not starving children. I repeat again." He said that there had been allegations months ago of famine, ethnic cleansing and genocide in Gaza "which was crap". "Nothing has really changed because we're Israel, and we obey not only international law, but also humanitarian law." "What we want is our hostages back and Hamas out of Gaza. The war can be over in exactly 30 seconds." Israel has long accused Hamas of hijacking aid, which Hamas denies. The president of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, based in the occupied West Bank, recently claimed most of the looting was being done by gangs associated with Hamas. He also called the movement "sons of dogs" and demanded the release of Israeli hostages. Hamas responded by saying Abbas "repeatedly and suspiciously lays the blame for the crimes of the occupation [Israel] and its ongoing aggression on our people". Without being able to enter Gaza and report independently, it is difficult to investigate the unfolding events. Violent criminal gangs have been heavily implicated in stealing aid. Hamas is threatening violence against groups and individuals it accuses of theft. Two people were shot outside an Unrwa warehouse but it is not clear who killed them. A local activist who was present blamed Hamas. "Hamas is hoarding food, depriving the hungry population of food, and selling food at very high prices. The population protested and demanded that the food be distributed or they would take it by force. Hamas fired live ammunition at the hungry," said Moumen al-Natour, a lawyer and protest leader. All of this is happening in the context of a growing hunger and the breakdown in order that has accompanied the war and blockade. The Israeli cabinet has approved anescalation of the military offensive in Gaza. It says it aims to destroy Hamas - a goal that has proved elusive for the last 19 months of war. There are also reports that Israel plans to use private security companies to oversee the distribution of aid in Gaza, although no date for this has been made public. The United Nations and major aid agencies have described this as a politicisation of aid with which they will refuse to co-operate. With additional reporting by Alice Doyard and Nik Millard

Back to Home
Source: Bbc News