Indian town’s abandoned European-style mansions are a throwback to its opulent past

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Sidhpur's Historic Mansions Reflect the Cultural Heritage of the Dawoodi Bohra Community"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.4
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Sidhpur, a historic town in Gujarat, India, showcases a unique blend of European architectural styles through its opulent mansions known as 'havelis.' Located on a quiet street called Paris Galli, these grand structures exhibit a range of pastel colors and intricate design elements that reflect the prosperity of the Dawoodi Bohra community, which has roots dating back to the 11th century. This community, originally from Egypt, flourished in Sidhpur, constructing these elaborate homes during the first half of the 20th century as a testament to their wealth and success in trade. The mansions, featuring Neoclassical, Art Deco, and Baroque influences, stand as a reminder of an era when the local maharaja encouraged European architectural styles, resulting in a uniform yet diverse streetscape. The architectural features, such as gabled roofs, ornate windows, and decorative carvings, are not only aesthetically pleasing but also culturally significant, blending local Gujarati traditions with global influences brought back by the Bohra merchants from their travels across the world.

However, the once-thriving community and its architectural legacy face imminent threats due to neglect and urbanization. Official records indicate that from approximately 1,400 havelis in the 1970s, less than 400 are currently inhabited, with many falling into disrepair or being demolished for modern developments. The decline of the community, exacerbated by migration and lack of heritage protection laws, underscores the urgent need for conservation efforts. Local architect Zoyab A. Kadi has taken the initiative to document and preserve Sidhpur's architectural heritage through the Sidhpur Heritage Collective, which aims to raise awareness and garner support for restoration projects. The group highlights the importance of not only saving the physical structures but also promoting the rich cultural narrative and community traditions that the havelis represent. Without significant public support and funding, the unique architectural identity of Sidhpur may be lost forever, leaving behind a melancholic reminder of its glorious past.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article sheds light on Sidhpur, a historical town in Gujarat, India, renowned for its abandoned mansions that evoke a sense of its opulent past. It highlights the unique architectural blend of European styles and the rich cultural history of the Dawoodi Bohra community. The narrative captures both the beauty and the neglect of these once-stately homes, inviting readers to reflect on the town's history and its current state.

Cultural Significance and Historical Context

The article emphasizes the cultural heritage of Sidhpur, showcasing the influence of the Dawoodi Bohra community, which has roots dating back to the 11th century. This community's trading connections with Europe are noted as a possible reason for the European-style architecture seen in the town. By focusing on these historical aspects, the article aims to instill a sense of pride and appreciation for local heritage among readers, especially those interested in architecture and culture.

Tourism and Economic Implications

There is an underlying suggestion that Sidhpur, despite its historical significance, remains relatively unknown to travelers and architecture enthusiasts. The article could be aiming to stir interest in the town as a potential tourist destination. This could, in turn, have economic implications for the local community, encouraging investment and revitalization efforts for the area.

Community and Identity

The description of the Dawoodi Bohra community and their distinctive attire adds to the article's depth, portraying a vibrant cultural identity that is rooted in history. This aspect might resonate particularly with members of the community or those interested in cultural diversity and heritage.

Hidden Agendas and Media Representation

While the article does not appear to have overt hidden agendas, there may be an intent to draw attention to the need for preservation of historical sites, thereby encouraging local and governmental action. The portrayal of the mansions as symbols of lost glory could evoke nostalgia and a call to action for their restoration.

Reliability and Manipulative Aspects

The information presented seems factual, drawing from historical context and architectural details. However, the romanticized depiction of the town can be seen as somewhat manipulative, as it may lead readers to idealize a place that is currently in decline. The choice of language and imagery could influence public perception, making it seem more appealing than it might be in reality.

In a broader context, the article may not significantly impact global markets or political dynamics but could foster local interest in heritage tourism, potentially benefiting sectors related to travel and culture.

The potential use of artificial intelligence in the crafting of this article is plausible, particularly in organizing the narrative and ensuring it aligns with popular themes of cultural exploration and historical preservation. However, without explicit indicators of AI involvement, this remains speculative.

The piece serves to articulate the beauty of Sidhpur while subtly urging readers to consider the implications of neglecting such historical sites. The overall reliability of the article is high, given the factual basis and historical context provided. However, the potential for nostalgia-driven manipulation exists, depending on how such narratives are consumed.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The dusty highway leading to Sidhpur, in western India’s Gujarat state, winds through arid landscapes past roadside eateries and herds of lumbering camel, offering little hint of what the historic town holds. In the heart of Sidhpur lies a street lined with stately three- and four-story mansions, known as “havelis,” in a fading palette of rainbow pastel shades, from teal and baby pink to pistachio green. Known locally as Paris Galli, or Paris Street, it transports visitors to a European city with grand Neoclassical architecture and a harmonious melange of Art Deco, Baroque and hybrid Indian styles. Sidhpur is less than three hours’ drive from Gujarat’s capital Ahmedabad, but it remains under the radar of travelers and architecture enthusiasts. On the day of my visit, the neighborhood around Paris Galli appeared largely deserted, except for occasional passersby in the distinctive colored hijabs and gold and white caps worn by the Dawoodi Bohras, a Shia Muslim sect that first settled in this part of western India in the 11th century. The Bohras are a close-knit trading community that originated in Egypt and later traveled around North Africa, the Middle East and South Asia to trade in spices, gems and perfumes. The sect’s seat was later moved from Yemen to Sidhpur, where its followers showcased their prosperity and wealth by building hundreds of opulent residences in the first half of the 20th century. These housing clusters were called Bohrawads or Vohrawads, and the mansions’ owners tried to outdo one another with chandeliers, Belgian glass and antique furniture, or by hosting grand dinners. The community’s close trading connections with Europe may have influenced its architectural sensibilities. The region’s maharaja at the time, Sayajirao Gaekwad III, was also known to be fond of European architecture. He laid out strict planning rules, inspired by Scottish urban planner Patrick Geddes (who lived in India between 1914 and 1924), that resulted in strikingly uniform streetscapes, according to Sidhpur-born architect Zoyab A. Kadi. “The Bohras extended their help to other communities during a famine in the early 1900s, and (in return) the Maharaja of Baroda gifted them a tract of land, as they were facing a housing shortage,” he said. “It was on this land that they started building these magnificent edifices, which had to adhere to strict town planning rules.” Found mostly in Najampura district, where Paris Galli is located, the long, narrow mansions are made mainly of wood (the material’s flexibility is an advantage in earthquake-prone regions) in addition to plaster and brick. The designs feature gabled roofs, pilasters and columns, carved doors and ornate overhanging “jharokha” windows that protrude from the front of each mansion. The main living floor is located above street level over a basement; stepped plinths, or “otlas,” act like porches and were traditionally used as social spaces; whimsical monograms, featuring family initials or surnames in English, are often displayed on the buildings’ facades. “The courtyard houses, built in rows or sequence, exhibit rhythm with diversity,” said Ahmedabad-based conservation architect, Ashish Trambadia, over the phone. “While each house has a unique color scheme, unique stucco art and grill work; the precise alignment of plinths, roof lines and floor lines gave the streets a unique character.” Unique design India-based photographer Sebastian Cortés documented the town and its people in his series “Sidhpur: Time Present Time Past.” The images present a certain melancholy, from the faded glory of the mansions’ interiors to the women pictured gazing out of windows as they carry out household chores. “I was inspired by the mercantile communities of India… who displayed their wealth most aesthetically,” said New York-born Cortés in a phone interview. “This was inverse colonialism: The Bohras traveled around the world to countries like Burma (Myanmar), Thailand, Yemen and Ethiopia, and brought back various influences and then blended it with their own customs and traditions, using local artisans to create magic.” Kadi has also helped bring international attention to the houses by authoring three books about the town: “Sidhpur and Its Dawoodi Bohra Houses,” “The Vohrawaads of Sidhpur” and “The Birth and Death of a Style.” “At casual glance, the streetscape looks European, but if you look closely there’s the Gujarati tradition of using wood as a building material, and the capitals (crowns of columns or pilasters) are neither Corinthian or Doric but hybrid — a product of various influences,” said Kadi, who now runs an architectural firm in Chennai. “Many of the houses were designed to give women privacy, as most of the men were abroad working hard and making money. (The homes are) also suited to the local weather, in terms of design and materials used.” The houses’ names, like Zainab Mansion and Kagalwala Manor, often reference the people who once lived there. There are showstoppers, like the Zaveri house (also known as the House with 365 Windows) which is now stained black with grit, its grand pilasters and geometric facade carvings in dire need of restoration, and the Teen Khuniya (or Three-Cornered House), with its distinctive triangular layout. According to local resident and tour guide Insiya Bangalorewalla, the homes were typically divided into five linear sections: the “dehli” (a service area), the “chowk” (a central courtyard kitchen and bathroom, open to the sky for light and, today, ventilation fitted with grilles), the outer “pursaal” (a multipurpose room for living and dining), the inner “pursaal” (the coolest room, used as a bedroom) and the orda (the best room in the house, well-furnished and used by the head of the family). “From the street you can’t see into the house thanks to a veil called the ‘furtaal,’ which protected the privacy of the women,” added Bangalorewalla on a tour through Najampura. The homes’ interiors were often a visual feast decorated with geometric tiles, friezes, Persian carpets, dark mahogany and rosewood furniture, painted Belgian mirrors, antique corner pieces, family memorabilia and a special marble recess meant for storing water (water has an important status in Islam, and is used to cleanse or purify the home). “Sidhpur’s architecture is very unique,” said Kadi, “as the buildings inspired by Western ideas and elements have been crafted by Hindu architects (but) are suited to an Islamic way of life.” Disappearing heritage Official town figures suggest that, in the 1970s, there were at least 1,400 of the mansions across Sidhpur. But after India gained independence from Britain in 1947, many of Sidhpur’s residents migrated overseas, or to larger Indian cities like Mumbai and Ahmedabad, leaving the houses’ upkeep to caretakers or relatives. Today, many are boarded up, lying forlorn and derelict or caught in legal tangles between former owners’ descendants; others have been demolished to make way for modern developments, with the antiques and timber sold off by owners. The official data suggests that fewer than 400 of Sidhpur’s havelis are currently inhabited. To help conserve the disappearing mansions, Kadi, along with others from Sidhpur, co-founded the Sidhpur Heritage Collective in 2024. The group is working to document the town’s architecture, as well as holding workshops and guided tours. “Unfortunately, there are no heritage laws in India that prevent demolition of (privately owned) houses,” said Kadi. “We also have no funds or body helping us in this project. Even converting these houses into homestays and Airbnbs has not yet taken off. “(Sidhpur) has a lot to offer besides just these mansions, from a rich food culture to temples and mosques. I can only hope that we manage to save the town’s architecture before it’s destroyed forever. This needs public will and funding.”

Back to Home
Source: CNN