'A liability', 'the aura' & 'a phenomenon' - the big Lions calls

Head coach Andy Farrell (third from left) and his staff have lots of permutations to mull over The action is over, the auditions are done. Last weekend's European semi-finals were the final chance for British and Irish Lions contenders to sway head coach Andy Farrell their way. On Thursday, the talking finishes too. Back in March, Farrell said he had a list of about 75 potential tourists. When he announces his squad for Australia this summer, he and his coaches will have boiled that group down to about 37 players. The squad has been debated for months and will continue to be after Wales and Lions legend Ieuan Evans reads out the names of the chosen few from 14:00 BST on Thursday at the O2 arena. Here are some of the hottest pre-announcement topics chewed over by BBC Sport's team of pundits. LISTEN: 5 Live Lions' squad announcement preview LISTEN: Rugby Union Weekly on Lions watch LISTEN: Scrum V Lions selection committee Itoje led England Under-20s to an age-grade World Cup triumph in 2014, but otherwise had little experience of captaining until this season Might one of the two horses in the race to captain the Lions have fallen at the final hurdle? Ireland number eightCaelan Doris picked up a shoulder injuryin Leinster's Champions Cup semi-final defeat by Northampton this weekend, putting his touring hopes in danger. Maro Itoje may well have earned the accolade ahead of Doris regardless, but with such uncertainty over his rival for the post now, the way seems even more clear for the second row. The 30-year-old, who had not been either his club or country's regular skipper until the start of this season, would be completing a captaincy clean sweep on his third Lions tour. "I would agree with it going to Maro," former England and British and Irish Lions scrum-half Matt Dawsontold BBC Radio 5 Live. "There are a couple of absolute fundamentals with Lions tour captains - first and foremost they have to be in the team and for me he is, without a shadow of a doubt. "Secondly, he has to be held in that regard, not just by the coaches, but also by his team-mates as well. The players have to look at their captain and think this guy is the man. "Thirdly, for Maro specifically, he has blossomed beautifully this season for England. "He has gone from being a player who was a certainty to be in the team, but was a bit short of the form of his early 20s and a little bit too ill disciplined, to being right in the groove. "The captaincy has given him a new lease of life and he is ready to step into the role for the Lions." Shane Horgan, who toured New Zealand alongside Dawson with the 2005 Lions, agrees. "I think Itoje is the front runner," he said. "You need a different type of charisma to be Lions captain because within your own nation, you can get 20 caps, build relationships with the team, become a senior player and then captain. There is none of that with the Lions. "There are lots of players you won't have a relationship with at all - you have to be 100% respected and a bit of an aura." An Achilles tendon injury restricted Finn Russell's game time on the 2021 tour of South Africa Finn Russell is the man in possession of the British and Irish Lions 10 jersey. Four years ago, he was ushered into the fray early in the deciding third Test against the Springboks and, although the tourists lost, Russell's dexterity and daring stood out. However after a modest Six Nations campaign with Scotland and the appointment of Russell-sceptic Johnny Sexton as one of the Lions coaches, doubt has been cast on whether the 30-year-old could even make the squad. Former Ireland hooker and Scarlets coach Bernard Jackman believes Russell should be straight into the team. "For me, Russell is the starting 10,"he told Scrum V. "I think the stuff around Johnny joining the coaching staff - I think that will be done. "The area Andy Farrell is most comfortable in coaching is attack. "When you think of Ireland's attack going into the last Rugby World Cup in 2023, it was so patterned and intricate. Someone with Russell's instinct, with his passing, running and kicking game, could be unbelievably strong in that. "I would be shocked if he wasn't on the plane. I think it is the job of the coaches to set the team up to bring the best out of him because that would bring the best out of everybody else." Horgan agrees, adding that Russell's Lions credentials have been proven. "Given Scotland have won just one of their past 16 meetings against his Ireland team, it will be hard for Andy Farrell to eliminate some of the doubts he may have about some of their players,"he told 5 Live. "But, I don't think that counts for Finn. If there was ever any doubts about Finn, they were blown out of the water by his performances on the tour in 2021. "He was phenomenal and should have played more." Fin Smith and Sam Prendergast, first-choice fly-halves for England and Ireland respectively, went up against each other in club colours on Saturday Twenty-nine minutes into Northampton's shock win against Leinster in the Champions Cup semi-final on Saturday, Henry Pollock took a short ball off Alex Mitchell, punched a hole and pinned back his ears. The ease with which he rounded Leinster fly-half Sam Prendergast to scorch in for a try set tongues wagging among those on the look-out for Lions. "That must have been the worst performance Prendergast has had this season," said 2009 British and Irish Lion Ugo Monyeon Rugby Union Weekly. "You can forgive missed kicks at goal, but there was a lack of control. "He looked like he was the fly-half playing away, he couldn't impose himself on the game. "No-one missed more tackles in the Six Nations this year and, as well as being ruined by Henry Pollock, he looked non-committal in defence, making tap tackles. "He will become such a focus for an attack." "I don't think you can take Sam, as great as his attacking ability is at the line," agreed former Wales and Lions wing Alex Cuthbert on 5 Live. "His defence is a real liability and Australia coach Joe Schmidt will be clued into that. "His tackle completion is way, way too low to be chosen. "By contrast, I think Northampton fly-half Fin Smith played his way onto the plane. "That game was as close to an international as you can get, in terms of ferocity and physicality, and Fin Smith was at the heart of it, controlling things in one of the best away wins I have ever seen in Europe." Pollock's exuberance has won over a legion of fans Pollock began this season with just one Premiership appearance to his name. His precipitous climb towards the top shows no sign of stopping though. The 20-year-old has scored more tries and beaten more defenders than any other forward in the Champions Cup this season. He has made more tackles and secured more turnovers than any other player full stop. "Previously I thought maybe the Lions had come too soon for him,"said former England scrum-half Danny Care on Rugby Union Weekly. "But watching that win over Leinster, how can you not take him? "He looked better, in every aspect, than one of the best Ireland back rows ever. "He is an 80-minute player. To be at that level mentally and physically, in a Test match-level environment is superb. "I like everything this kid is about. "I'm not sure if he would start, but how good would he be for competition on that tour? "Lob him into a midweek team and if you picked him for Test side, he wouldn't look out of place." "Farrell can't not pick him," agreed Horgan. "Pollock was phenomenal at the weekend. It was as a good a performance as I have seen in a long time. "He doesn't know how to be bad and he will bring crazy enthusiasm and for that reason I think he will be picked." Williams has shone for club side Gloucester since arriving at Kingsholm from Cardiff in the summer Tomos Williams' livewire performances for both Gloucester and Wales have put him in contention for a scrum-half spot, although Scotland's Ben White - who has a ready-made understanding with Finn Russell - could trump him in the expected race to join Ireland's Jamison Gibson-Park and England's Alex Mitchell in the squad. "My instinct says that Ben White would better fit the way that Andy Farrell would want to play and how the Lions could play," says Dawson. "And that connection with Finn Russell could be quite handy. "However it is a valid point that the Lions organisers will want to have a healthy Wales contingent and that might count against White. That factor might edge a toss-of-a-coin decision." "I would be very surprised if Tomos is not on that plane, given both his form and the type of bloke he would be in that environment," said Cuthbert. "Andy Farrell would like him. Tomos is very dry, and very good at being the centre of a changing room, bringing the best out of players around him." Smith suffered an ankle injury on his last outing for Harlequins, a defeat by Leicester at the end of April Marcus Smith was called up for the last British and Lions tour while playing asummer international for England against Canada. While halfway down Allianz Stadium's tunnel, he was told by England support staff that he would be boarding a plane to South Africa, as well as a bus back to south London. The 26-year-old seemed in prime position for a fly-half slot this time around after some virtuoso displays for England in the second half of 2024. However the emergence of namesake Fin and a positional shuffle to full-back during the Six Nations has made predicting Smith's inclusion for 2025 a lot harder. Danny Care, who plays with Smith at Harlequins, backs him. "Scotland full-back Blair Kinghorn is likely to arrive late on the tour from Toulouse so it is a massive string to Marcus Smith's bow being able to play 15," Care said. "If you have two big movers on the wings, be it James Lowe, Tommy Freeman or Duhan Van der Merwe, you need someone who can link and create space for them. "Marcus Smith is the best one-on-one attacker coming from the back. He has been for two or three years. "Added to which I don't think Andy Farrell will forget how well he played at 10 in the autumn. Some players have credit in the bank." However Smith may find that positional specialists are preferred to his versatility. "For all his brilliance as a player, I don't think Marcus Smith is in the top three for fly-halves who get the most out of their backline," said Horgan. "Finn Russell, Fin Smith and Sam Prendergast all get backlines motoring better and I don't think you can have Marcus Smith as a starting full-back. "He will do brilliant things, but I don't think he is a starting full-back."