A 400-year-old tea and coffee shop faces closure in Amsterdam as tourism stokes price rises

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Historic Amsterdam Tea and Coffee Shop Faces Closure Amid Rising Rents and Overtourism"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 6.7
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In Amsterdam, the historic tea and coffee shop ‘t Zonnetje, operating for nearly 400 years, faces imminent closure due to unsustainable rent increases exacerbated by gentrification and overtourism. The shop, located in a narrow 17th-century building, has been a cherished destination for both locals and tourists, drawing visitors with its rich history and welcoming atmosphere. Owner Marie-Louise Velder, who has run the shop since 1999, announced plans to close by the end of May as she struggles to manage escalating costs. Despite receiving significant support from the community and patrons, Velder's attempts to negotiate rent reductions have been met with limited success, leaving her with no viable options for continuing the business. The shop has been a vital social hub, connecting neighbors and visitors, and its closure is seen as a loss not just for its customers but for the cultural fabric of Amsterdam itself.

The rise in rent has been part of a broader trend affecting traditional businesses in Amsterdam, where the influx of tourists has led to a shift in the local economy. City officials have implemented measures to manage tourism and protect local businesses, but these efforts have had mixed results. Experts argue that more must be done to preserve long-standing establishments like ‘t Zonnetje, which are critical to the city's identity. Velder's personal journey reflects the challenges faced by many small business owners in the face of rising costs and competition from new, less traditional establishments. As her health has begun to suffer under the stress of potential closure, Velder remains hopeful for support from the community to find a way to keep her beloved shop open, emphasizing its unique role in Amsterdam's history and social life. The fate of ‘t Zonnetje serves as a poignant reminder of the delicate balance between tourism and the preservation of local culture in a rapidly changing urban landscape.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article highlights a significant issue affecting a historic tea and coffee shop in Amsterdam, which has been in operation for nearly 400 years. The impending closure of ‘t Zonnetje, owned by Marie-Louise Velder, serves as a microcosm of the broader challenges faced by traditional businesses in cities experiencing rapid gentrification and overtourism.

Purpose of the Publication

This news piece aims to shed light on the struggles of small, long-standing businesses in the face of rising rents and changing urban landscapes. By focusing on the personal story of Velder and the emotional connection that customers have with the shop, the article seeks to evoke empathy and raise awareness about the impact of tourism-driven economic changes on local culture and heritage.

Societal Perception

The narrative is crafted to generate a sense of nostalgia and concern among readers, particularly those who value cultural heritage and local businesses. It aims to foster a community response, encouraging support for the shop and highlighting the broader issues of gentrification and the challenges posed by tourism.

Potential Omissions

While the article focuses on the emotional and cultural dimensions of the closure, it may downplay the economic realities that contribute to such situations, such as the role of local government policies or the broader market dynamics affecting rent prices. This could lead to a one-sided understanding of the issue.

Manipulative Elements

The article uses emotive language and personal anecdotes to engage readers on a deeper level, which may lead to a perceived manipulation of sentiment. While the emotional appeal is valid, it can also serve to direct attention away from systemic issues that contribute to gentrification and rising costs.

Truthfulness of the Report

The report appears to be grounded in truth, as it is based on a real business and a genuine concern voiced by the owner and patrons. However, the emotional framing may skew the reader's perception of the broader economic context.

Community Response

This piece resonates particularly with communities that value local culture, heritage preservation, and small businesses. It may attract the attention of tourists, locals, and activists who are concerned about the future of unique establishments in urban environments.

Economic and Political Implications

The closure of such an iconic business could have ripple effects on local tourism and the economy. If more businesses like ‘t Zonnetje close due to similar pressures, it could lead to a loss of cultural identity in Amsterdam, affecting how the city is perceived by tourists and residents alike.

Stock Market Relevance

While this story may not have direct implications for the stock market, it highlights broader trends in urban economics that could affect real estate investments and tourism-related stocks in Amsterdam. Investors might take note of the increasing pressure on local businesses from rising rents and tourism dynamics.

Geopolitical Context

The article doesn't directly address global power dynamics, but it reflects ongoing trends in cities worldwide as they grapple with the impacts of overtourism and urban development. The issues raised are relevant to discussions about sustainable tourism and urban planning.

AI Usage Speculation

It is unlikely that AI was used in the writing of this article; however, if it were, models focusing on natural language processing might have been employed to create a narrative that engages readers emotionally. The storytelling elements could have been influenced by AI techniques that prioritize human interest angles.

Conclusion on Reliability

In summary, while the article is rooted in factual reporting about a real issue, its emotional framing and focus on individual stories can lead to a somewhat biased perspective. It serves to highlight important societal concerns but may not fully encompass the complexities of the economic landscape at play.

Unanalyzed Article Content

On a recent chilly, drizzly afternoon in Amsterdam’s city center, a steady stream of patrons venture out of the rain and into a narrow 17th-century building on the Haarlemmerdijk, a popular shopping street. A gilded sign shaped like a shining sun hangs above the front door, reflecting the shop’s name, ‘t Zonnetje, which means “little sun” in Dutch. A jingling bell announces every arrival. These days, it’s a mix of tourists and regular customers who come to buy coffee and tea every week or two — just as their predecessors have for nearly 400 years. But this storied institution, beloved by Amsterdam visitors and residents alike, may not be in business much longer. Its longtime owner, Marie-Louise Velder, has plans to close at the end of May because she can no longer stay afloat after years of skyrocketing rent — a notable setback to the preservation of the Dutch capital’s character in the ongoing tide of rising rents and gentrification, partly driven by overtourism. Velder, 76, was born and raised in Amsterdam and has owned the shop since 1999. She told CNN she has received an outpouring of support from customers and friends since the closure was reported by Dutch newspaper Het Parool in mid-April. She said she welcomes the opportunity to share her story with a wider audience in hopes of helping her keep ‘t Zonnetje from shuttering. “I had a lot of phone calls, and so I think perhaps help is coming from above,” Velder, clad in a green hooded fleece, told CNN during an interview at her shop over (what else?) a cup of tea. “That’s what I hope.” Longtime customers have expressed deep sadness over the news. Kate Carlisle, an eight-year resident of Amsterdam and a longtime visitor, first discovered ‘t Zonnetje during a trip to the Dutch capital before moving there. Carlisle had her dog with her, and she was delighted to receive “the biggest welcome” from Velder. Carlisle now visits the shop every couple of weeks to buy coffee (which she says she leaves on her counter “a good half-day just to make the house smell better”), bonding with Velder through the years over their shared love of java and animals. She said ‘t Zonnetje’s closure would be a significant loss for the city. “It is a heritage site, the building itself, the history behind it, the street,” Carlisle told CNN Travel. “So I’m really hoping that something can happen to start to protect this. Otherwise, it’s just going to be like strip malls. And that’s not what Amsterdam is about. That’s not why people come here.” A tea-filled time capsule Walking into ‘t Zonnetje, which is nestled between a flower shop and a clothing store, feels like stepping back in time. Its wooden floors are original, with shelves housing weathered tins of loose-leaf tea and spices. Dispensers of whole coffee beans from countries around the world, including Ethiopia, Portugal and Peru, stand side by side behind the counter, on which a vintage Berkel scale cuts a commanding presence. According to ‘t Zonnetje’s entry on Amsterdam’s tourism website, the building reportedly dates to 1642 (though a book about the shop by a Dutch author and former shop owner that Velder keeps handy puts the date at 1612). The business started with “a bucket of coal, and a bucket of water and herbs,” Velder explained. “And then later on, the tea came … And then later the coffee.” Velder pointed to a building across the street, noting that before its construction, the waters of Amsterdam’s IJsselmeer sea inlet nearly reached the shop centuries ago. “The boats were coming in here, and brought (shipments) here,” she said. Velder purchased the business in 1999 without a contract, “just a handshake,” she says. The first few years presented a steep learning curve, but Velder, determined, said she immersed herself in learning as much as she could about the industry and what customers were looking for. “It took me now at least five, six years until I found out what tea-drinking and coffee-drinking really was, and where I had to look and what to do and what was more important,” Velder said. Eventually, she hit her stride, earning a reputation for high-quality products sourced from around the world. In the past, the shop has offered up to 350 varieties of tea — some made with her own “secret recipe,” Velder said — though she has cut back on placing new orders in light of the planned closure. Currently, 15 types of coffee are available. Over the years, the shop also had an on-site cafe of sorts where patrons could linger over a cup of coffee and conversation. That feature has been closed since the pandemic, Velder said. Even so, employees say ‘t Zonnetje remains a critical part of the true spirit of Amsterdam, a place that serves as a gathering spot for neighbors and visitors while showcasing centuries of history. “It is more than a shop — it also has a very important social role,” explained Nathalie Teton, who has worked at ‘t Zonnetje on and off since 2021. “There were a lot of people also living alone coming here, having a cup of tea and coffee, talking with Marie-Louise. You will hear all the gossip, who is sleeping with who, and also old stories, because there were also a lot of senior people coming in.” “Of course, there are other tea and coffee shops in Amsterdam. But they are more mainstream. This one is really unique.” Trouble brewing Amsterdam, which is amid a yearlong celebration leading up to its 750th anniversary this October, has been struggling for years with how to preserve its unique history as overtourism threatens to irrevocably change the character of the city. Over the past decade, city officials have focused their tourism efforts on stemming the tourist tide and attracting the right kind of visitor to the city: those who come to appreciate Amsterdam’s museums and culture, not partake in its infamous vices. Among those measures: increasing the tourist tax, banning tours in the historic De Wallen neighborhood, banning cruise ships and limiting the opening of shops catering specifically to tourists. However, results have been mixed, and some measures — such as a 2020 ban on vacation rentals in certain neighborhoods — have been struck down by the courts. Meanwhile, centuries-old businesses like ‘t Zonnetje, which have long been entrenched in their local neighborhoods, remain increasingly susceptible to rising rents, as TikTok trendy eateries, generic sweet shops and “coffeehouses” that specialize in marijuana proliferate among the tourist set. In March 2023, US former boxing star Mike Tyson opened his first brick-and-mortar cannabis shop in Amsterdam, just down the street from SoHo House and W Amsterdam. Some experts say city officials have not done enough to protect locally owned, long-established businesses such as ‘t Zonnetje. Dimitris Dalakoglou, an urban anthropologist and professor at Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, told CNN via email that city leadership in Amsterdam and other European cities has long since “abandoned” the “prevention of this urban catastrophe.” He warned Amsterdam is becoming “an empty façade of itself” in a 2018 article and said ‘t Zonnetje’s closure marked another “small death” for the city. “Amsterdam’s real estate is changing fast to the benefit of capitalist profit-making: the banking sector, real estate investors and new richer inhabitants/users of the urban spaces, whilst the previous urban groups are slowly pushed away,” Dalakoglou said. “Almost every urban space’s policy goes towards this direction, even the ones which claim to aim for the opposite goal.” Too-high rent and other struggles Over at ‘t Zonnetje, Velder claims that the building’s landlord has steadily increased the rent, which, circa 2019, was about 18,000 euros (about $20,000) annually. In September 2024, the landlord proposed further increases, doubling the rent to about 6,000 euros (currently about $6,800) per month. Velder took the landlord to court over that proposed increase, according to Het Parool. But even with a judge’s decision to retroactively reduce the rent to about 50,000 euros per year ($56,000), costs of the business — including payroll for four staffers — remain too high to cover with sales bringing in only about 300 euros (about $340) a day, Velder says. Property management company Florès Vastgoedbeheer told CNN via email that the building’s landlord is not currently in the Netherlands and is unavailable for comment. However, the email stated that the “tenant terminated the lease without any notice for her own reasons” and that “the property will become available to rent and suitable candidates can apply in due course to an estate agent to be appointed.” Escalating rent isn’t the only challenge Velder has faced over the years. Velder also has had disputes with a local entrepreneur who she claims offered to help the business while it was in financial trouble. A proposed deal never materialized, and the two eventually ended up in court, according to Het Parool. In an email to CNN, Amsterdam lawyer Maarten Hilberdink, who represented Velder in various cases, described the shop’s potential closure as a “great loss for Amsterdam.” “Marie-Louise has built something very special and it is a great pity that she had to spend her last years as an entrepreneur with legal battles and that this special store is now lost to Amsterdam,” he said. All of these issues have taken a harsh emotional and physical toll on Velder. “I was this morning (seeing) my doctor, and (my blood pressure) was the highest I ever had, 210,” Velder said. “She said, ‘This is impossible. Your blood pressure is so high. It’s sky high.’” A sunny attitude, despite the challenges Despite the assorted challenges she has faced, Velder tries to maintain an upbeat attitude. She laughs easily and often, chatting with her staffers, some of whom refer to her by her nickname of “Loucky,” and customers in Dutch and English (her father was an American from Chicago). She welcomes everyone who comes into the shop — which has a 4.9 star rating on Google and 98 mostly glowing reviews — with equal enthusiasm. However, Velder also expresses deep sorrow over the thought of closing her beloved business. “I love my customers, they are fantastic, and they love me,” she said. “This is my baby.” Her “baby” is now struggling through a very difficult stage — and facing a highly uncertain future. It’s unclear whether or how Amsterdam’s gemeente (municipal government) would or could grant the shop protected status. In an email to CNN, the city’s tourism department said that while it “recognize[s] the significance of such changes in Amsterdam’s streetscape, matters related to the diversity and development of the local retail and hospitality offering fall outside the scope of Amsterdam&Partners.” Longtime customers of ‘t Zonnetje, meanwhile, hope something can be done before another piece of Amsterdam’s history is lost. “It is a jewel that needs protecting and absolutely needs support, and people shouldering in and bellying up and [doing] everything they can do to save it, because it’s one of a kind,” Carlisle said. “Amsterdam doesn’t have much of this anymore.”

Back to Home
Source: CNN