X-ray reveals ancient Greek author of charred first century BC Vesuvius scroll

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Ancient Greek Philosopher Philodemus Identified in Charred Herculaneum Scroll"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.2
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Recent advancements in imaging technology have led to the identification of a charred scroll from Herculaneum as a work by the ancient Greek philosopher Philodemus. This scroll, which was discovered in a Roman villa buried under ash from the eruption of Mount Vesuvius nearly 2,000 years ago, was examined through X-ray imaging that allowed researchers to virtually unwrap it. For the first time, the title of the scroll, 'On Vices,' along with its author, has been revealed. Philodemus, an Epicurean philosopher, wrote this multi-volume work in the first century BC, and the scroll is now part of a collection housed at the Bodleian Libraries in Oxford. The findings mark a significant milestone in the ongoing efforts to recover and read the ancient texts that were lost in the eruption, with researchers previously unsure if the scroll contained any writing at all.

The scroll, designated as PHerc. 172, was scanned at the Diamond synchrotron facility in Oxfordshire, where researchers were able to detect traces of ink, including the ancient Greek word for 'disgust.' This discovery is part of a broader initiative called the Vesuvius Challenge, which aims to develop innovative techniques for reading the fragile scrolls. The challenge has already yielded impressive results, with teams using artificial intelligence to decipher ancient Greek letters from other scrolls. As technology continues to advance, researchers are optimistic about the potential to read more of these scrolls, with a total of 38 additional scrolls scheduled for scanning in the near future. Experts anticipate that the pace of discoveries will accelerate, providing new insights into the literary and philosophical landscape of ancient Rome and its influences.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The discovery of a charred scroll from the ruins of Herculaneum offers a fascinating glimpse into the past, revealing the work of the ancient Greek philosopher Philodemus. The use of advanced imaging technology to uncover the scroll's contents signifies a significant leap in our ability to read ancient texts that have been damaged over time. Analyzing the implications of this news sheds light on its societal, cultural, and technological significance.

Historical Context and Technological Advances

This scroll, identified as part of a multi-volume work titled "On Vices," is a remarkable find that not only enriches our understanding of Epicurean philosophy but also highlights the intersection of history and technology. The application of X-ray imaging to read the scroll without unrolling it demonstrates a groundbreaking approach in archaeology and textual studies. This innovation may inspire further advancements in the field, encouraging more research into other damaged artifacts.

Public Perception and Cultural Impact

The article aims to foster a sense of wonder and curiosity about ancient civilizations and their intellectual contributions. By showcasing the successful application of modern technology to uncover ancient texts, it encourages public engagement with history and the sciences. This narrative may resonate particularly with academic communities, historians, and those interested in archaeology and philosophy.

Potential Concealment of Information

While the article focuses on a significant archaeological find, it does not delve into the broader implications of such discoveries, such as the potential political or economic motivations behind the excavation and preservation of ancient artifacts. There may be an underlying narrative that seeks to divert attention from ongoing contemporary issues in archaeology, such as the repatriation of artifacts or the ethics of archaeological practices.

Manipulative Elements and Trustworthiness

The manipulative potential of this article lies in its framing of the discovery as a triumph of modern science and human curiosity. However, it is essential to consider whether this portrayal oversimplifies the complexities involved in archaeological research and the ethical dilemmas faced by scholars today. The article appears credible, grounded in verifiable advances in technology and historical context, but its narrative may gloss over contentious issues within the field.

Connections to Broader Themes in Society

This article fits into a larger discourse about the preservation of cultural heritage and the role of technology in enhancing our understanding of history. It may also provoke discussions regarding funding for archaeological research and the prioritization of resources in academia.

Support from Specific Groups

Individuals interested in philosophy, history, and archaeology are likely to find this news compelling. The article may garner support from academic circles that advocate for the preservation of cultural heritage and the promotion of interdisciplinary research.

Impact on Financial Markets

While this discovery may not have immediate implications for financial markets, it could influence sectors related to cultural tourism, educational institutions specializing in archaeology, or technology companies involved in imaging and scanning technologies. The stock of companies developing innovative imaging solutions might see increased interest as a result of this breakthrough.

Global Power Dynamics

There is no direct correlation to current geopolitical issues, but the discovery emphasizes the importance of cultural heritage in understanding historical narratives. It could spark discussions about the significance of ancient civilizations in shaping modern societies.

Artificial Intelligence Considerations

Although the article does not explicitly mention the use of artificial intelligence in the analysis of the scroll, the mention of AI software in previous discoveries suggests a trend towards integrating AI in archaeological research. The interpretation of the data could have been enhanced by AI algorithms, which can assist in deciphering ancient texts and patterns.

In conclusion, while the news surrounding the scroll's discovery is rooted in factual developments, it also invites speculation regarding broader societal implications and the ethical considerations in the field of archaeology. The story serves to highlight the exciting possibilities that arise when technology meets history, while also reminding readers of the complexities that come with such advancements.

Unanalyzed Article Content

A charred scroll recovered from a Roman villa that was buried under ash when Mount Vesuvius erupted nearly 2,000 years ago has been identified as the influential work of an ancient Greek philosopher.

Researchers discovered the title and author on the Herculaneum scroll after X-raying the carbonised papyrus and virtually unwrapping it on a computer, the first time such crucial details have been gleaned from the approach.

Traces of ink lettering visible in the X-ray images revealed the text to be part of a multi-volume work, On Vices, written by the Epicurean philosopher Philodemus in the first century BC. The scroll is one of three from Herculaneum housed at the Bodleian Libraries inOxford.

“It’s the first scroll where the ink could just be seen on the scan,” said Dr Michael McOsker, a papyrologist at University College London, who is collaborating with researchers in Oxford to read the text. “Nobody knew what it was about. We didn’t even know if it had writing on.”

The scroll is one of hundreds found in the library of a luxury Roman villa thought to have been owned by Julius Caesar’s father-in-law. The villa was buried under ash and pumice when Herculaneum, near Naples, was destroyed along with Pompeii in the eruption of AD79.

Excavations in the 18th century recovered many of the ancient scrolls, most of which are held at the National Library of Naples. But the documents are so badly burnt that they crumble when researchers try to unroll them and the ink is unreadable on the carbonised papyrus.

The latest work builds on earlier breakthroughs from the Vesuvius Challenge, a global competitionlaunched in 2023, which offers prizes for progress in reading the scrolls from 3D X-rays. Last year, a team of computer-savvy studentsshared the $700,000 (£527,350) grand prizefor developing artificial intelligence software that enabled them to read 2,000 ancient Greek letters from another scroll.

The scroll from the Bodleian, named PHerc. 172, was scanned last July at Diamond, the UK’s national synchrotron facility in Oxfordshire. Unusually, some ink was visible in the X-ray images, with researchers spottingthe ancient Greek word for “disgust”at least twice in the document.

Further work by Sean Johnson at the Vesuvius Challenge, and separately by Marcel Roth and Micha Nowak at the University of Würzburg, found the title and author of the text in the innermost section of the scroll, earning them the challenge’s $60,000 (£45,200) first title prize.

Alongside “On Vices” and “Philodemus”, a book number on the scroll may be an alpha, suggesting it could be the first instalment of the work. On Vices contains at least 10 books with others covering topics such as arrogance, greed, flattery and household management.

Before long, experts should know far more about the scrolls. Eighteen were scanned at Diamond in March and 20 more will be imaged at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility in Grenoble this week.

“We’re seeing evidence of ink in many of the new scrolls we’ve scanned but we haven’t converted that into coherent text yet,” said Dr Brent Seales, a computer scientist at the University of Kentucky, who co-founded the Vesuvius Challenge. “That’s our current bottleneck: converting the massive scan data into organised sections that are properly segmented, virtually flattened, and enhanced so that the evidence of ink can then be interpreted as actual text.”

McOsker said: “The pace is ramping up very quickly … All of the technological progress that’s been made on this has been in the last three to five years and on the timescales of classicists, that’s unbelievable. Everything we’re getting from the Herculaneum library is new to us.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian