Words of War review – Maxine Peake leads line as murdered Putin-critic journalist Anna Politkovskaya

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Film 'Words of War' Depicts Life and Assassination of Journalist Anna Politkovskaya"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.2
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The film 'Words of War' presents a dramatized account of the life and assassination of Anna Politkovskaya, a Russian journalist renowned for her fearless reporting on the Chechen war. Played by Maxine Peake, Politkovskaya is depicted as a courageous figure who openly criticized the Kremlin and President Vladimir Putin, particularly highlighting the circumstances surrounding her murder on Putin's birthday, which many view as a chilling statement. Nearly two decades after her death, she is celebrated as a symbol of resistance against autocracy, especially amid the growing threats to journalists globally. The film, however, has received mixed reactions due to its portrayal of Politkovskaya's life, which some critics argue leans too heavily into sentimental tropes typical of journalist-centric narratives. Furthermore, the lack of endorsement from Politkovskaya's family indicates potential contention over how their personal stories were represented, particularly in the characterization of her son, Ilya, who is shown as self-absorbed despite his understandable distress regarding his mother's perilous career choices.

While the film attempts to honor Politkovskaya's legacy, it struggles with execution, particularly in its character development. Critics noted that the supporting characters, including Politkovskaya's husband, portrayed by Jason Isaacs, and a menacing FSB officer played by Ian Hart, are portrayed with greater depth than Politkovskaya herself. The film's aesthetics, characterized by a flat lighting scheme and an overly sentimental score, detract from the dramatic tension, particularly in key scenes, such as the siege at Moscow's Dubrovka theatre, which deserved more dynamic storytelling. Although the film concludes with a poignant homage to Politkovskaya and other journalists who have faced violence, it does not fully capture the intensity of her experiences or the impact of her work. 'Words of War' is available on digital platforms starting June 30, providing viewers with a glimpse into the life of a journalist who became a martyr for press freedom.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

This British-American co-production offers a dramatised portrait ofRussian journalist Anna Politkovskaya(played by Maxine Peake) who was assassinated in 2006. Politkovskaya’s gutsy, impassioned reporting on thesecond Chechen warwas highly critical of the Kremlin, the Russian army and Vladimir Putin personally. (The fact that she was murdered on his birthday was surely no coincidence.) Nineteen years after her death, she remains a folk hero worldwide for resistances to autocracy, especially given the rise in repression everywhere and constant threats to journalists.

Given all that, the film deserves respect for the subject matter, even though this is a pretty basic rendition of Politkovskaya’s story, a little too sticky with hagiographic sentimentality and the cliches of crusading journalist-led movies. It also should be noted that Politkovskaya’s family haven’t given the film their blessing; some of them may not be happy, for instance, with the thinly written characterisations of their fictional counterparts, like her son Ilya (Harry Lawtey) who is made to seem peevish and self-absorbed even when his feelings are understandable. (“I’m not watching you die!” he bellows at one point.)

In fact, the flawed peripheral characters are more interesting than Peake’s Politkovskaya, who spends much of the film with her strong jaw jutting out, projecting nobility despite the over-lacquered blond wig inflicted on her. Her best scenes are those in which she spars withJason Isaacs, who plays her husband, Sasha – a TV journalist clearly proud of his wife but jealous of her success – and with Ian Hart (always a treat when playing the heavy) as a sinister FSB secret policeman who loves history.

The gently swelling strings in the score and flat lighting all serve to underscore the televisual atmosphere – even in what should be the film’s climatic set piece, thedisastrous siege at Moscow’s Dubrovka theatre, a cataclysmic event that deserves more dynamic film-making than the bit of slow-motion and sound dimming offered here. Politkovskaya served as a negotiator between the Russian security forces and the Chechen terrorists; she was later poisoned on a plane headed to Beslan, where a school full of children were also killed by terrorists. Politkovskaya survived that particular assassination attempt but those who know her story will dread the arrival of the final blow. It is to the film’s credit that over the end titles we see a portrait not just of the real Politkovskaya but also some of the 1,500 journalists worldwide who have been murdered in recent years.

Words of War is on digital platforms from 30 June

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian