Women and babies could die due to midwife cuts at Sydney’s RPA hospital, staff warn

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Concerns Rise Over Midwife Staffing Cuts at Sydney's RPA Hospital"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.5
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Midwives at the Royal Prince Alfred (RPA) hospital in Sydney have raised alarming concerns regarding recent staffing cuts that could jeopardize the safety of women and newborns during childbirth. The New South Wales Nurses and Midwives’ Association (NSWNMA) reported that 20 full-time equivalent midwifery positions will be removed from the maternity unit, including five from the midwifery group practice program, effective immediately. This reduction will significantly decrease the number of midwives available for each shift, with only six midwives scheduled for day, afternoon, and night shifts, down from eight to ten. The union has highlighted that this staffing change compromises the one-to-one care model during active labor and the two-to-one support during delivery, which are considered essential for safe childbirth practices. Union leaders and midwives at RPA have expressed that the current staffing conditions are already strained, and this decision will exacerbate the risks, potentially leading to dire consequences for mothers and babies alike.

In addition to the cuts to midwifery positions, the maternity ward will also see a reduction of nine beds, causing concerns that women will be discharged sooner than necessary. Midwives have voiced their frustrations, stating that the changes feel like a slap in the face, given their already overwhelming workloads. Many midwives are contemplating leaving their positions for better opportunities in other states with improved pay and staffing ratios. Health Minister Ryan Park defended the cuts, asserting that no midwives would lose their jobs and that staff would be redeployed due to a slight drop in birth rates at RPA. However, the NSWNMA has emphasized the need for a review of the current staffing model, advocating for better staffing ratios to ensure the safety and well-being of mothers and babies, particularly in the context of the Aboriginal midwifery group practice, which is designed to provide culturally safe care for Indigenous women. The community has rallied in support of the midwives, recognizing their crucial role in ensuring safe and healthy childbirth experiences.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Midwives at one of Sydney’s largest hospitals have warned women and babies could die in light of cuts to the number of midwives staff deployed across the birth and delivery unit.

Hospital staff say 20 full-time equivalent roles have been removed from across the women and babies service at Royal Prince Alfred (RPA) hospital in Camperdown, including five from the midwifery group practice (MGP), effective from Tuesday.

TheNew South WalesNurses and Midwives’ Association (NSWNMA) said that while no jobs will be lost, vacant positions that are currently advertised will now not be filled and fewer casual staff will be brought in.

The changes will mean fewer midwives will be rostered on to each shift in the labour ward and birth centre to assist mothers giving birth at RPA.

“So currently in the birth unit, you would have eight midwives on a day shift, 10 midwives on an afternoon and eight on the night [shift],” the NSWNMA president, O’Bray Smith, said. “With the new changes, you will have six midwives [on each of the three shifts]. This is not safe.”

The union said nine beds in the maternity ward would also be cut, with Smith warning this would mean “women will be pushed out faster than they already are”.

Speaking at a rally outside RPA on Tuesday, Smith said reducing the number of midwives assisting women during birth will mean that not all women will receive the one-to-one care during active labour and two-to-one care during delivery, which is considered safe practice.

“Midwives are already at breaking point,” Smith said. “They know that women aren’t getting the care they deserve in NSW. This is really going to make things a lot worse. Every single shift, a mother or a baby could die as a result of not having enough staff. This is about saving lives, having safe staffing. The midwives are absolutely terrified of what could happen here.”

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email

Jessica Rendell, a midwife at RPA since 2021, the staffing changes were “a slap in the face”.

“It’s just really unsafe having such limited [number of] midwives,” she said, speaking to Guardian Australia in her capacity as an NSWNMA member. “It’s such a joke that they’re cutting our staffing and numbers. It’s not like we’re sitting around doing nothing. We are run off our feet every single day.

“If you ask any of the girls working today, have they had a break? Have they eaten? And they probably haven’t … We’re exhausted, honestly we’ve had enough. The government is making it so hard to enjoy coming back to work every day, because it’s just so stressful coming into work and knowing that you might not be able to help your woman in an emergency.”

Rendell said she knew a number of midwives who were looking to leave positions in NSWHealthfor jobs in other states where the pay is higher and staff-to-patient ratios are better.

The NSW health minister, Ryan Park, told reporters on Tuesday: “I want to make it clear, no one in RPA is losing their jobs.” He said midwives were being “redeployed in other parts of maternity services” due to “a slight reduction in birthrates at RPA”.

Park added that the state government used a model called Birthrate Plus to determine the level of staffing in birthing and maternity services, a model that he said had been endorsed by the NSWNMA.

The union previously endorsed the Birthrate Plus model, but has for a number of years called for its review and the implementation of 1:3 staff ratios.

Sign up toBreaking News Australia

Get the most important news as it breaks

after newsletter promotion

The NSWNMA has raised concerns about the reduction in the number of midwives who will work across the MGP program, which allows a woman to see the same midwife throughout her pregnancy, during delivery and postnatal follow-up care.

The number of midwives assigned to MGP will drop by at least five, the union said, despite a huge demand for the service and the fact that the recent NSW birth trauma inquiry recommended “the NSW government invest in and expand midwifery continuity of care models, including midwifery group practice”.

The Aboriginal MGP, a dedicated program to assist Indigenous women to give birth in culturally safe ways and to improve outcomes for Indigenous women and their babies, will also be merged with the general MGP program.

The two dedicated Aboriginal MGP midwives say they anticipate being asked to pick up extra patients from the general service, diverting their focus from Indigenous women.

“It’s been integrated. It’s no longer a protected Indigenous space,” , one of the Aboriginal MGP midwives, Paige Austin, said, speaking to Guardian Australia in her capacity as a NSWNMA member. “Those women lose us, and they lose our time and everything that we give to them extra on top of MGP.”

News of the staffing changes was shared on the mothers’ group that Charlotte Wesley and Bridget Dominic are part of, and they both turned out in the rain on Tuesday to show support for the RPA midwives who had assisted them to deliver their babies – George and Roonui – just three months ago.

“The midwives showed up for us so we really want to show up for them,” Dominic said.

“I do think that these cuts could lead to deaths of mothers and babies. But further than that, we shouldn’t just be aiming for alive mothers and babies; we want happy and healthy [mothers and] babies who contribute to happy healthy communities.”

RPA was contacted for comment.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian