Which football managers have followed legends with instant success? | The Knowledge

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Successors to Legendary Football Managers Achieve Immediate Victories"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.8
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Arne Slot's remarkable ascent to potentially winning the Premier League in his first season as Liverpool's manager highlights a notable trend in football where successors to legendary figures achieve immediate success. Historically, Liverpool has seen managers like Matt McQueen, Joe Fagan, and Kenny Dalglish clinch the league title in their debut seasons, but Slot's success is particularly striking given he was new to English football and took over from the charismatic Jürgen Klopp. Achieving the title with several games to spare is a testament to his leadership and the team's performance. Meanwhile, in the Women’s Super League, Chelsea under Sonia Bompastor, who succeeded Emma Hayes, has also shown strong potential for a domestic treble, indicating that managerial transitions can yield positive results across different leagues and genders in football.

The article also explores other instances of managers who have thrived immediately after taking the reins from legendary predecessors. For example, Ștefan Kovács succeeded the iconic Rinus Michels at Ajax and won the Eredivisie, KNVB Cup, and European Cup in his first season. Similarly, Pep Guardiola took over from Frank Rijkaard at Barcelona and led the team to a historic treble in his debut season. The text also recalls Luis Carniglia's near-treble achievement at Real Madrid following José Villalonga’s departure, and Tony Barton’s success at Aston Villa shortly after replacing Ron Saunders. These examples illustrate that while succeeding a legendary manager can be daunting, several have managed to rise to the occasion and secure significant victories, thus cementing their legacy in the annals of football history.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article explores the instances where football managers have achieved immediate success after taking over from legendary figures. It highlights the case of Arne Slot, who is poised to win the Premier League in his first season with Liverpool, following Jürgen Klopp. This scenario is not entirely uncommon for Liverpool, yet Slot's unique position as a newcomer adds a layer of intrigue to his potential achievement.

Contextual Significance of Managerial Successions

The article discusses historical precedents of managers achieving success after replacing revered figures, such as Rinus Michels at Ajax and the immediate triumphs of various Liverpool managers. This context serves to emphasize that while the pressure is significant for new managers, instances of immediate success provide a refreshing narrative in the world of football. The mention of Sonia Bompastor at Chelsea further illustrates that this phenomenon extends beyond men's football, showcasing a broader trend of successful transitions in leadership.

Public Perception and Community Impact

By framing Slot’s potential success as remarkable, the article aims to create a sense of excitement and optimism among Liverpool fans and the broader football community. The focus on success in the face of high expectations can inspire hope and foster a positive atmosphere surrounding the club. The narrative also subtly reinforces the idea that Liverpool is a club capable of nurturing talent and achieving greatness, thus solidifying its place in the football hierarchy.

Potential Omissions or Underlying Issues

While the article presents a celebratory view of managerial successes, it may downplay the challenges and pressures that come with succeeding a legendary figure. The expectations placed on new managers can be overwhelming, and the narrative could benefit from acknowledging the potential for failure or the complexities involved in such transitions.

Manipulation and Reliability

The language used in the article is generally positive, aiming to uplift rather than to critique. However, this could be seen as somewhat manipulative if it glosses over the difficulties faced by managers stepping into such significant roles. Despite this, the article largely presents factual historical data regarding managerial successes, making it reliable in that context.

Connections to Broader Trends

There are connections to broader trends in sports management and the pressures inherent in high-stakes football environments. The focus on managerial success can influence public sentiment and possibly affect club investments and player morale. While this article does not directly address economic or political implications, the success of a football club can indirectly affect its financial standing and marketability.

Community Support Base

This article is likely to resonate with football fans, particularly those who support Liverpool and Chelsea, as well as broader audiences interested in sports narratives. It aims to engage those who appreciate stories of triumph and leadership in competitive environments.

Market Influence

The potential success of a club under new management can have implications for stock prices in associated companies. For instance, Liverpool's success might positively influence merchandise sales, ticket prices, and sponsorship deals. Therefore, the news surrounding managerial changes can be significant for stakeholders in the sports market.

In conclusion, while the article presents a positive outlook on managerial successions, it also reflects the complexities and pressures associated with these transitions. The overall reliability of the information is strong, given its historical context and factual basis. However, the celebratory tone may overlook certain challenges inherent in such roles.

Unanalyzed Article Content

“Arne Slot is going to win the Premier League in his first season after taking over from Jürgen Klopp,”writes Hannah Mitchell.“What examples are there of managers who have had instant success after succeeding a legendary manager?”

It’s not unusual for a new Liverpool manager to win the league in their first season. Matt McQueen (1922-23), Joe Fagan (1983-84) and Kenny Dalglish (1985-86) all did so, – but they were established figures at the club, whether in the boardroom, the boot room or the dressing-room. Arne Slot was new to English football, never mind Liverpool, and was succeeding one of the most charismatic figures in the club’s history. In that context, winning the Premier League with (potentially) four or five games remaining is a remarkable achievement.

Slot is not the only newcomer who looks set to win an English top-flight title. In the Women’s Super League, Chelsea have adjusted seamlessly to life underSonia Bompastor, who succeeded Emma Hayes in the summer, and may well do the domestic treble. The 4-1 defeat in Barcelona makes it unlikely Chelsea will win the lot this season, but that has happened in the past.

“Managers don’t come much more legendary than Rinus Michels, who guided Ajax to four national titles, three domestic cups, and a European Cup triumph, all the while revolutionising the game with his team’s Total Football,” writes Kári Tulinius. “Ștefan Kovácstherefore had big boots to fill, and did so by winning the Eredivisie, KNVB Cup and European Cup in his inaugural season, adding the European Supercup and Intercontinental Cup to his tally the following winter, and then defending the European Cup and national titles. Follow-up acts don’t come much more impressive than that.”

Ajax won five and drew four of their first nine games under Kovacs. Then they really hit form: for the rest of the 1971-72 season their record in all competitions was P39 W37 D1 L1.

Frank Rijkaard might not qualify as a legendary Barcelona manager – but he did win the Champions League and two La Liga titles soPep Guardiolahad plenty to live up to when he took over in 2008. In his first season, Barcelona became the first Spanish side to do the Treble, all the while playing football from the distant future.

Another newcomer almost achieved the same feat 51 years earlier. “After the legendary José Villalonga left Real Madrid in 1957,Luis Carnigliawas appointed,” writes Ben Janeson. “He took Real Madrid the closest they’ve ever come to a European treble, winning the European Cup and La Liga and being runners-up in the Copa del Generalísimo.”

Aston Villa’s European Cup triumph of 1982 came less than four months afterTony Bartonhad replaced Ron Saunders, who left the club in February after a disagreement with the board.Joe Shawwon the league title with Arsenal after taking over in January 1934 when the great Herbert Chapman died suddenly. And whenFabio Capelloreplaced Arrigo Sacchi in 1991, Milan won Serie A without losing a game.

“It’s fairly common nowadays for a footballer to miss a match because their partner is in labour, but I’m guessing this is a newish development in the game. Who was the first professional player to miss a match in order to be present at the birth of their child? And how long did it take for this to become common?”asks Magda.

The first person who comes to mind is QPR’s Martin Allen in March 1989. He flew home before an away game at Newcastle after learning his wife had gone into labour, and made it in time to see the birth of his son, George. Allen was fined two weeks’ wages by QPR player-manager Trevor Francis. It become a huge story and was even discussed in parliament. In time Francis regretted his actions, but his relationship with Allen never recovered. Allen moved to West Ham in the summer.

“The Serie A titlecould be decided by a playoff, with Inter and Napoli level on points with five games to go. Has this ever happened before?”wonders Tom Mortimer.

There has only been one playoff to decide the Scudetto. In 1963-64, Bologna and the defending champions, Inter, finished with 54 points (two for a win in those days) from 34 games. Bologna had a superior goal difference but that wasn’t used as a tiebreaker. Instead the two teams met in a one-off game in Rome on 7 June, a week after the end of the regular season.

Inter, who won their first European Cup at the end of May, were in blistering form and had won at Bologna at the end of March. At that stage it looked like they would win the title with ease – Bologna had been deducted three points when five of their players failed a drug test after a game against Torino. Bologna appealed successfully on the grounds the urine samples were not handled properly and got the points back, which meant they finished level with Inter.

Then, in the week of the title playoff, Bologna’s president, Renato Dall’Arra, died suddenly during a federation meeting. But Bologna won their seventh title thanks to two goals in the last 15 minutes: the great Giacinto Facchetti deflected Romano Fogli’s free-kick into his own net before Harald Nielsen, the league’s top scorer, finished expertly to make it 2-0.

In last week’s Knowledgewe looked at the first player to have a red card rescinded. “The red card system was introduced into the English game in 1976,” writes Terry Woods, “so your article on the first English player to have one rescinded in 1969 is not valid.”

We should have said that Northampton Town’s Frank Large was the first player we could find who had his suspension quashed after being sent off in an association football contest. But we didn’t, and now we’ve been shown a red card.

“Giorgos Giakoumakis has finished as the Eredivisie’s top scorer (by some margin) yet his team, VVV-Venlo, have been relegated,”wrote Willem Cleven in 2021.“Has any Golden Boot winner suffered such an ignominious fate before?”

They certainly had. “Southampton’s Mick Channon managed that feat,” wrote Andy Grace. “The famous windmill celebration was seen 21 times in 1973-74 and he topped the Division One scoring charts, despite the club getting relegated that same season.”

Dirk Maas pointed out that just a couple of years later, in the 1975-76 La Liga season, Enrique Castro González (better known as ‘Quini’) suffered the same fate at Sporting Gijón. He stuck around to fire them straight back up to La Liga the next season, though, when they even qualified for the Uefa Cup. Dirk also found that Thomas Dalgaard went down with Viborg FF in the 2013-14 Danish Super Liga while scoring 18 goals in 33 games.

It’s happened in Italy, too. “Igor Protti was the only Serie A player to have suffered this fate,” offered Jörg Michner. “In 1995-96 he scored 24 goals and becamecapocannonierealongside Lazio legend Giuseppe Signori, but his Bari side got relegated anyway.”

“National League South side Dorking are currently in sixth place with one match to play, yet can still win the title providing other results go their way. What is the lowest position any team has come from on the last day to win a title?” asks Mark Mills.

“Dorking beat beat Hampton and Richmond Borough 4-0 on Friday, with their captain Charlie Carter completing his hat-trick in the seventh minute of their game. Is that the fastest hat-trick from the start of the game?”

“Cardiff sacked Omer Riza with only three league games remaining,” notes James Robinson. “Has a manager ever been sacked so close to the end of the season?” Norwich may havejust helped to answer that, but perhaps someone else can beat it?

“Which player has the most Premier League appearances without ever having played a competitive match outside England?” wonders Will Fry. “Including European club competitions, senior and under-21 internationals.”

Mail uswith your questions and answers

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian