Welsh thatching and ship figurehead carving added to UK crafts red list

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Traditional UK Crafts Face Threat as Heritage Skills Added to Endangered List"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.8
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The traditional crafts of the UK are facing significant challenges, as highlighted by the recent addition of nearly two dozen skills to the 'red list' maintained by the charity Heritage Crafts. This list categorizes crafts that are considered critically endangered or endangered, with the number of critically endangered crafts rising from 62 to 72 in just two years. Among the newly listed critically endangered crafts are Welsh thatching and ship figurehead carving. Welsh thatching, known for its distinctive round appearance, is becoming increasingly similar to English styles, while the skill of carving figureheads for ships is at risk, with no new trainees entering the field. Rising operational costs, a lack of structured training programs, and market pressures are contributing to the decline of these important crafts, according to Mary Lewis, who conducted the research for the report. The report also notes that skills associated with silversmithing are declining, as many of the essential trades are being lost, despite a continued interest in becoming a silversmith.

Despite the grim outlook for many traditional crafts, there are signs of hope with some crafts experiencing a resurgence. Crafts such as hazel basket making and pole lathe bowl turning are gaining renewed interest. Sharif Adams, a practitioner of pole lathe bowl turning, describes the craft as one of humanity's earliest forms of woodworking, emphasizing its connection to nature and community. The technique, which creates uniquely textured bowls, had nearly disappeared by the mid-20th century but has seen a revival thanks to dedicated enthusiasts. Adams has played a part in this revival, sharing his knowledge and participating in events like the Bowl Gathering, which fosters community and well-being through the craft. The contrast between the endangered crafts and the resurgent ones highlights the need for increased support and training to ensure the survival of these valuable skills for future generations.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The recent news highlights the addition of Welsh thatching and ship figurehead carving to the UK's "red list" of endangered crafts. This report indicates a growing concern over the preservation of traditional skills, which are now under threat due to various economic and social factors.

Purpose and Community Perception

The article aims to raise awareness about the declining state of traditional crafts in the UK, emphasizing the importance of preserving cultural heritage. By detailing specific crafts that are endangered, it seeks to evoke a sense of urgency and responsibility within the community to support and revive these skills. The focus on craftsmanship connects with audiences who value cultural identity and tradition, potentially mobilizing grassroots efforts for preservation.

Hidden Narratives

While the article is primarily focused on endangered crafts, it might be glossing over broader issues, such as the economic policies affecting small artisans and craftspeople. The mention of rising operational costs and market pressures hints at larger systemic issues without fully exploring them. This omission could suggest a desire to keep the narrative centered on individual crafts rather than the economic framework that supports or hinders them.

Manipulative Potential

The report could be seen as manipulative if it creates an exaggerated sense of urgency or guilt among readers without providing constructive solutions. The language used focuses on loss and decline, which may foster a sense of helplessness. By not mentioning specific initiatives aimed at resolving these issues, it could leave readers feeling that the situation is dire and requires immediate action, possibly leading to impulsive support for certain causes.

Truthfulness and Reliability

The information presented appears credible, as it cites a reputable charity, Heritage Crafts, which specializes in documenting and preserving traditional skills. However, the framing of the issue—focusing primarily on the negative aspects—might lead to questions about the overall balance of the narrative. While no crafts have gone extinct recently, the article could have provided more context about successful preservation efforts or community initiatives that are already in place.

Societal Impact and Economic Considerations

The report has the potential to influence public sentiment towards traditional crafts, potentially leading to increased support for local artisans. Economically, it could spark interest in niche markets related to these crafts, encouraging consumers to support handmade goods. Politically, it may put pressure on policymakers to consider protective measures for cultural heritage sectors.

Target Audience

This article likely resonates more with communities that value tradition and craftsmanship, including artisans, cultural historians, and local businesses. It may specifically appeal to those involved in or supportive of sustainable practices and local economies, fostering a sense of solidarity among these groups.

Market Implications

In terms of financial markets, the article could affect stocks related to crafts and artisanal goods, particularly businesses that specialize in traditional techniques. Companies that produce handmade or custom items may see a rise in consumer interest following this report, as awareness grows about the importance of preserving such skills.

Global Context

While the report is focused on UK crafts, it reflects a broader global trend of valuing artisanal skills in the face of industrialization. This aligns with contemporary discussions about sustainability and the preservation of cultural heritage, making it relevant in today's global economic landscape.

Artificial Intelligence Involvement

There is no clear indication that artificial intelligence was used in the writing of this article. However, if AI were involved, it might have influenced the tone or structure to ensure clarity and engagement. The choice of language and the framing of the narrative could reflect algorithms designed to optimize reader engagement.

In conclusion, the article successfully brings attention to the plight of endangered crafts while also hinting at broader economic issues that may not be fully explored. The reliability of the information is solid, but it could benefit from a more balanced perspective that includes positive efforts in the field.

Unanalyzed Article Content

For many centuries the cities, towns and villages of the UK were enlivened and enriched by the sights and sounds of craftspeople creating beautiful – and useful – objects.

But almost two dozen crafts, from Welsh thatching to ship figurehead carving, have been added to an alreadybulging “red list” of skillsconsidered under threat.

According to the list, from the charityHeritageCrafts, the number on the “critically endangered” list has risen from 62 to 72 in the last two years, while the “endangered” list has gone from 84 to 93.

But there is a glimmer of hope, with no new crafts becoming extinct since the last time the list was published two years ago, and there are some “resurgent” crafts, including hazel basket making and side saddle making.

Mary Lewis, who led the research, said rising operational costs, a lack of structured training and mounting market pressures were placing unsustainable strain on many crafts that depend on expert hand skills.

She said that trades such as cut-crystal glassmaking, pewter working and organ building were becoming vulnerable.

Among the new critically endangered crafts is Welsh vernacular thatching. The report says many thatched roofs in Wales are becoming “more similar to English styles of thatch”. The Welsh style is different, with a rounder outside appearance.

Another craft added to the critically endangered list is the carving of figureheads for ships. A few “master carvers” remain but the report says there are no trainees.

Some of the skills needed in silversmithing are also vanishing, the report says, with “silver allied trades” added to the endangered category.

Jackie Tear, the managing director ofBritish Silverwarein Sheffield, which makes objects ranging from cutlery to trophies, said people were keen to be silversmiths. “But the issue is all the associated skill sets and trades that go with it are lost or being lost.”

For example, Tear said, the number of people skilled in buffing – removing lines created in the manufacturing process to create a smooth surface – could be counted on one hand.

Sign up toThe Guide

Get our weekly pop culture email, free in your inbox every Friday

after newsletter promotion

Tear said: “There are lots of apprenticeship schemes at colleges but none of them are actually teaching the crafts. They’re learning how to use a lathe but they’re not learning how to use it for something like our industry because it’s a very niche.”

Among the resurgent crafts is pole lathe bowl turning. One practitioner,Sharif Adams, said: “A pole lathe is one of the earliest sort of machines that humanity ever used. The Vikings used them to turn their cups and bowls.”

“As the bowl spins, the tool leaves a very fine groove, which is similar in some ways to the sort of texture on thrown pottery. And they don’t shine in the same way as machined bowls. They look more earthy, more rustic.” The technique produces a beautifully textured bowl.

By the mid-20th century pole lathe bowl turning had died out but a small number of enthusiasts revived it. “I took photographs of lathes and built one and then connected through the green wood working forums with a few other people trying to do the same thing,” Adams said.

He passes on his knowledge and there is an annual festival called theBowl Gathering. “It’s a really lovely thing to do. There’s so many emotional and physical wellbeing benefits from woodturning in this way. It connects you with nature and connects you with community of lovely people.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian