‘We were sinking. I let her go’: how growing numbers of women are risking all to reach Europe by boat

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Tragic Capsizing of Migrant Boat Highlights Rising Female Migration to Europe"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 6.9
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

On May 28, a tragic incident occurred off the coast of El Hierro, one of Spain's Canary Islands, when a boat carrying migrants capsized just meters from the pier. The vessel was carrying four women and three girls among the 145 individuals who had embarked on a perilous 10-day journey from the west coast of Africa. As the boat overturned, rescue teams were deployed, but seven women and girls tragically drowned beneath the wreckage. The images from the scene were chaotic, showing individuals struggling in the water while others attempted to climb onto the submerged vessel. The loss of life served as a stark reminder of the increasing dangers associated with migration to Europe, particularly as more individuals turn to the Atlantic route due to heightened security measures in the Mediterranean. In 2024 alone, over 20,000 migrants arrived on El Hierro, nearly double the island's population, highlighting the severity of the ongoing migration crisis in Europe.

The incident also revealed a growing trend in migration patterns, with women and girls comprising nearly half of the passengers on the capsized boat. According to the Spanish Commission for Refugee Aid, women accounted for approximately 15% of irregular entries to the Canary Islands since 2021. Many of these women are fleeing armed conflicts, gender-based violence, and forced marriages in their home countries, particularly from the Sahel region. For instance, Madeleine, one of the survivors, recounted her harrowing experience of letting go of her niece while trying to stay afloat after the boat capsized. Another survivor, Sira, described the desperate conditions inside the boat and the loss of her four-year-old daughter during the incident. These personal stories underscore not only the dangers of their journey but also the unique challenges faced by women in migration, as they increasingly take on the role of primary decision-makers in their quest for safety and opportunity.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article highlights the tragic drowning of women and girls attempting to reach Europe via perilous boat journeys, particularly to the Canary Islands. This incident underscores the growing presence of women in migration flows, revealing the harsh realities they face, including armed conflict, poverty, and gender-based violence. The story not only draws attention to their struggles but also serves to evoke empathy from readers regarding the plight of migrants.

Purpose of the Article

This report aims to raise awareness about the increasing number of women undertaking dangerous migration routes. By focusing on the emotional aspects of a tragic event, the article seeks to generate public concern and potentially influence policy discussions surrounding migration and refugee crises.

Public Perception

The piece is likely intended to foster a sympathetic understanding of migrants, particularly women, who are portrayed as victims of dire circumstances. This narrative may create a sense of urgency regarding humanitarian aid and the need for supportive policies for migrants.

Omissions and Hidden Aspects

While the article addresses critical issues like gender-based violence and conflict, it may not delve deeply into the systemic causes of migration, such as international policies or the role of specific countries in exacerbating these conditions. By focusing on personal stories, broader geopolitical factors may be sidelined.

Manipulative Elements

The emotional weight of the report could be seen as manipulative, as it may lead readers to feel a specific way about migration without providing a comprehensive view of all perspectives involved. The language used emphasizes tragedy and urgency, potentially shaping public opinion to advocate for more immediate action.

Truthfulness of the Report

The information presented appears credible, backed by statistics and testimonies from relevant organizations like the UN and the Spanish Commission for Refugee Aid. However, the framing of the narrative may selectively highlight certain aspects over others, which can affect the overall perception of the truth.

Social Narrative

The article contributes to a narrative that positions women and children as particularly vulnerable within the broader migration discourse. This choice of focus may resonate with feminist and humanitarian groups advocating for women's rights and protections in migration contexts.

Comparative Analysis

When compared to other reports on migration, this article stands out for its emphasis on gender issues. Many migration narratives focus on economic factors or political asylum without giving sufficient attention to the unique challenges faced by women.

Potential Socioeconomic and Political Impact

This story could influence public sentiment, leading to increased advocacy for immigrant rights and potentially affecting political policies regarding asylum and border control. It may also incite discussions on the need for gender-sensitive approaches in migration policy.

Support Base

The narrative likely attracts support from humanitarian organizations, feminist groups, and those concerned with human rights. It aims to engage audiences who are sympathetic to the plight of migrants, especially women.

Market Impact

While the article may not have direct implications for stock markets, it could influence sectors related to humanitarian aid, immigration services, and even insurance companies dealing with migration risks. Public sentiment about migration can also impact broader economic policies.

Geopolitical Relevance

The situation highlighted in the article reflects ongoing geopolitical tensions, particularly in regions affected by conflict. It connects to current global discussions on migration, refugee rights, and humanitarian responses, making it relevant to today's political landscape.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

It is possible that AI tools were utilized in the creation of this article, particularly in data gathering and analysis of trends regarding migrant demographics. AI models might have contributed to framing the narrative to emphasize emotional impact, potentially steering the reader's perspective.

The overall reliability of the article is grounded in the factual basis of the events described and the use of credible sources, though the emotional framing may lead to a more selective interpretation of the broader issues at play.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The four women and three girls were just metres from the pier in the port of La Restinga in El Hierro, one of Spain’s Canary Islands, when they drowned on 28 May. Rescue teams had begun disembarking the first people early that morning when the vessel capsized.

Photos and videos of thechaotic scenesshow the boat partially submerged and completely overturned, with several people struggling to swim around it and others trying to climb on to the wrecked boat. Underneath, about 15 women and girls were trapped and fighting to get to the surface. Seven would not make it.

After a 10-day journey from the west coast ofAfrica, 145 people who had been on the boat made it ashore, but the seven women and children were buried in three cemeteries on El Hierro.

The deaths shocked an island that has quickly become ahotspot of Europe’s migration crisis. As the EU seeks to crack down on routes across the Mediterranean, more people have resorted to crossing the Atlantic to reach the Canary Islands – one of the mostdangerous crossingsinto Europe. More than 20,000 migrants arrived in El Hierro in 2024, according to theRed Cross– almost double the island’s population.

The incident also shone a light on the large numbers of women and girls now attempting the long and dangerous migration route from Africa – they made up almost half of the passengers on the capsized boat.

Since 2021, nearly 15% of irregular entries to the Canary Islands have been women, according to data collected by the Spanish Commission for Refugee Aid (Cear). Most of them are coming from the Sahel region, according to the UN’s refugee agency, which saysescalating conflictshave forcibly displaced millions of people from Burkina Faso, Niger and Mali.

Human rights groups say increasing numbers of women are now visible on migration routes from Africa, driven by the familiar issues of armed conflicts and poverty, but also unique problems such as escaping gender-based violence and forced marriage. “Women are becoming the main actors in their own migration process, whereas in the past it was usually the men who migrated first and the women joined later,” says Juan Carlos Lorenzo, a coordinator at Cear.

Madeleine*, who was travelling with her five-year-old niece on the capsized boat, has told the Guardian she decided to leave after her husband abandoned her. She was criticised by his family when she began looking for work. “They were saying I was seeing other men, which wasn’t true. I couldn’t take it any more and made the decision.”

At the time she was looking after her niece and decided it would be better for her to come too. “When her mother died, the family wanted to take the girl to undergo genital mutilation, but I refused to accept it. When I said no, they started to fight a lot against me. I couldn’t leave my niece there, so I brought her with me.”

Madeleine says she was on the deck of the boat when it capsized. Both of them fell into the water, where Madeleine says she initially tried to hold her niece tightly, but had to let go because she couldn’t keep her own head above water. “I started screaming and crying. I had the girl in my arms, but we were both sinking. I let her go.” Ultimately, both were rescued.

Sign up toGlobal Dispatch

Get a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development team

after newsletter promotion

The little girl was taken alone to a hospital in Tenerife after swallowing too much water, says Madeleine, who was separated from her while she was identified at the police camp where migrants are detained and processed in El Hierro. They were reunited three days later.

Other women from the boat were wary of going into details about why they had left Africa. Sira*, who was one of the women trapped under the boat when it capsized, says she left Guinea to help her family and give her two daughters aged four and seven more opportunities. She says she travelled inside enclosed compartments within the boat, typically used to store fish but repurposed for women and children during the voyage. When the boat capsized, she says, many women were struggling to breathe.

“Inside, there was a lot of water. We held on to ropes to lift our heads and breathe. My daughters were on the upper part of the boat; they were no longer with me at the bottom because [the rescue teams] had asked to disembark the children first. They fell into the water, but I stayed inside,” says Sira.

Sira’s four-year-old daughter was one of the children who drowned.

Initially, the rescue teams focused on helping those who had fallen into the sea, unable to see the people still trapped beneath the boat, as shown in footage broadcast by several television channels at the time. But after the boat flipped over again, several local residents jumped in to assist, pulling one person after another to safety. Among the arms that reached out to be rescued were Sira’s. “That’s when they rescued me,” she says.

  • Names have been changed. Sira and her surviving daughterare now living in a shelter after being transferred to the neighbouring island of Tenerife

Gabriela Sánchez is a reporter forelDiario.es

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian