‘We sometimes milked 3,000 snails a day!’: the dying art of milking molluscs

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Indigenous Mixtecs Preserve Ancient Tradition of Snail Dyeing Amidst Environmental Threats"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.5
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In Chachacual Bay, 81-year-old Mauro Habacuc Avendaño Luis, affectionately known as Habacuc, and his son Rafael, 42, embody the last vestiges of an ancient tradition practiced by the Indigenous Mixtec people. They are tintoreros, or 'dyers', who extract a rare dye ink from the purpura snail, Plicopurpura columellaris, a method that has been in use for over 1,500 years. This artisanal practice involves milking the snails for ink, which is used to dye yarn for clothing. Habacuc recalls a time when they could harvest up to 3,000 snails a day, but due to environmental changes and over-exploitation, their ability to find these snails has drastically decreased. The men depend on low tides to reach the rocky crevices where the snails cling, often risking their safety in the process. The ink extracted from the snails is unique, turning yarn into vibrant hues that are said to last indefinitely, a testament to the resilience of their cultural heritage despite modern challenges.

However, the tradition is under threat from various factors, including poaching, habitat destruction, and climate change. The Mexican government has implemented protections for the purpura snail, restricting milking rights to the Mixtecs, yet challenges persist. Rapid coastal development and increased tourism have led to more poachers, undermining conservation efforts. The recent earthquake that altered the coastal landscape has also raised concerns about the future of the snail's habitat. Habacuc and Rafael continue their work not just for economic reasons, but as a means of preserving their culture and the ancient practices of their ancestors. With only 14 men in their community still engaging in this tradition, the urgency to educate surrounding fishing communities about the significance of the purpura snail and prevent its extinction is more critical than ever. The Mixtecs remain dedicated to protecting this sacred species and its associated dyeing practice, as they believe that their survival is intertwined with the health of the purpura snail population.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article highlights the traditional practice of milking snails for dye production, focusing on the lives of two Indigenous Mixtec men in Mexico. It illustrates not only the rarity of this craft but also its cultural significance and the environmental context in which it exists. The narrative evokes a sense of nostalgia and urgency regarding the preservation of such unique cultural practices.

Cultural Significance and Preservation

This report seeks to shed light on an ancient technique that has persisted for over 1,500 years. By focusing on the lives of Habacuc and Rafael, the article emphasizes the importance of preserving cultural heritage and the skills that come with it. The mention of their Indigenous identity and the traditional method of dyeing yarn connects readers to a broader narrative about cultural survival in the face of modern challenges.

Creating Awareness and Urgency

The article aims to create an awareness of the declining art of mollusk milking, fostering a sense of urgency regarding its preservation. By detailing the dangers involved in collecting these snails and the intimate relationship between the men and their environment, it evokes empathy and a desire to support such artisanal practices. This awareness could lead to increased interest in sustainable practices and the protection of endangered crafts.

Potential Hidden Agendas

While the piece primarily focuses on cultural heritage, there could be underlying messages about environmental conservation and the economic importance of supporting traditional crafts. It may subtly encourage readers to reflect on their consumption habits and the impact of industrialization on Indigenous practices. However, there is little indication of any explicit agendas that are being obscured from the public.

Trustworthiness and Manipulation

The article appears to be credible, providing personal stories and historical context that enhance its authenticity. However, it could lean towards romanticizing the subject by emphasizing the dangers and artistry without addressing the full spectrum of challenges faced by the community, such as economic viability and climate change. This could be interpreted as a manipulation of the narrative to evoke a specific emotional response.

Comparative Analysis

When compared to other reports on Indigenous practices or environmental issues, this piece serves as a reminder of the interconnectedness of culture and ecology. It draws parallels to broader discussions on sustainability and the impacts of globalization on traditional ways of life. The article contributes to a growing discourse on the importance of preserving cultural identities in the face of modernity.

Impact on Society and Economy

The narrative could have societal implications by encouraging tourism or support for Indigenous crafts, potentially benefiting local economies. It may also inspire advocacy for policies that protect traditional practices and the environments that sustain them. However, it remains to be seen how significant these impacts will be.

Target Audience

The article likely resonates with readers interested in culture, sustainability, and Indigenous rights. It appeals to those who value artisanal practices and are concerned about environmental degradation, aiming to foster a community of support around these issues.

Market Implications

While this specific article may not directly influence stock markets or global economies, it reflects a growing trend towards valuing sustainable and ethical practices. Companies involved in eco-friendly goods or supporting Indigenous rights could see increased interest from consumers who are inspired by such narratives.

Global Context

Within the broader context of global discussions on sustainability, cultural heritage, and environmental conservation, this report fits into ongoing conversations about the importance of protecting traditional practices. It resonates with contemporary issues related to climate change and biodiversity loss, making it relevant to today's global agenda.

There is no clear indication that artificial intelligence was used in the composition of this article, as it exhibits a human touch in storytelling and personal anecdotes that AI may struggle to replicate. The narrative style is rich with emotion and personal experience, suggesting a human author rather than an AI-generated text.

In conclusion, the article is a well-crafted piece that highlights the significance of an ancient craft while evoking a sense of urgency for its preservation. Its authenticity and emotional resonance contribute to its reliability, despite potential biases in its portrayal of the challenges faced by the community.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The site for the camp is well chosen. Mangrove trees provide shade from the sun; from their hammocks, the two men can look out over the yellow sand of Chachacual Bay. Rocks rise at both ends of the beach, breakers crashing against them. Next to the camp, turtles have left their tracks in the sand. “They often come at night and keep us company,” says Mauro Habacuc Avendaño Luis, 81, known to everyone as Habacuc.

While Habacuc lights a campfire to make coffee, his son Rafael, 42, sets up a small tent for the night. Rain is forecast. “We’ve been camping in the same spot for many years,” says Habacuc. “From here, we roam the coast in search of the purpura snail.”

The two men, members of the Indigenous Mexican Mixtec people, aretintoreros, which means “dyers”. Their work on the Pacific coast is extraordinary: they are the last people to extract dye ink from a rare species of snail,Plicopurpura colummelaris, which belongs to the rock snail family. “It is one of the oldest methods still practised today for dyeing yarn for clothing,”says Mexican ethnologist Marta Turok. “The coastal Mixtecs in Oaxaca have been using it for at least 1,500 years.” The Mixtecs call the colourtixinda.

As the sun slowly sinks below the horizon, Habacuc and Rafael set out to search for the purpura snails and “milk” them – as they call the process of extracting the ink. Their work depends on the tides. “We can only reach the snails at low tide because they live in the zone where the surf hits the rocks,” says Habacuc.

The men climb from boulder to boulder, looking for the crevices where snails cling to the rocks, which are often covered in algae and extremely slippery. “One wrong step can cost you your life,” says Rafael. “We have lost relatives who have fallen and been swept away by the waves.”

They quickly find the first specimens about half a metre above the water level. Their shells are dark green to black, with small, knotty spirals and grooves on the surface. It takes strength and skill to detach them. “I have to pull the snail up decisively, tipping it sideways,” says Rafael. “If you hesitate, it clings even more tightly.”

After detaching a large female snail from the rock, he presses on its foot with his finger. The snail first excretes a small amount of urine, which he tips aside. Only then does it secrete a few drops of a milky substance, the actual ink. This contains neurotoxins, which the purpura snail uses to paralyse smaller snails and other marine invertebrates, which it then eats. The substance is harmless to humans.

Rafael lets the ink seep into a bundle of cotton thread wrapped around his left hand and puts the snail back in a protected place so that it can reattach itself to the rocks. After a few minutes, the snail secretion reacts with the oxygen in the air and the yarn turns yellow and, a little later, green. But it needs the sun’s UV light to achieve the brilliant violet colour which lies somewhere between lavender and amethyst.

“If the day is gloomy, the yarn stays green or blue,” says Habacuc. “You have to moisten it again and put it in the sun, then it turns purple, even if a year has passed since it was dyed.” It is said that the snail purple will never fade and cannot be washed out. “The clothes will disintegrate, but their colour will last for ever,” says Habacuc, pointing to his white shirt with its purple work stains. “If you rub purple-dyed yarn, it immediately smells of seaweed and the sea.”

Habacuc is the head Mixtec dyer in the small town of Pinotepa de Don Luis, the only place inMexicowhere the purpura tradition has survived. He learned how to milk snails from his uncle when he was 14. “I’ve been doing this for 67 years now, and you can see it in my feet.” He points to his toes, which are curled inward from clinging to the rocks. “Back then, we could walk from our village to the coast, 40km [25 miles] away, to milk snails.”

Plicopurpura columellariswas once native to the entire Pacific coast of Central America, from Baja California in the north to Colombia in the south. “We sometimes milked 3,000 snails in one day and dyed seven to eight large cotton strands with the ink,” Habacuc says. But that was a long time ago. The animals have long disappeared from the beaches of his youth. They are now found only in Huatulco national park, with its many inaccessible cliffs and wild coves. Even there, the tintoreros rarely find more than 100 snails a day. “The cost of travel and food is higher than my profit from selling the yarn,” says Habacuc. “The only reason we continue dyeing is the desire to preserve our traditions and culture.”

The decline of the snails began in the early 1980s, when Japanese companies discovered the ink and used it to dye fine kimonos. They hired fishers on the coast of Oaxaca to milk the snails – but they threw them into the water after milking them or left them lying in the sun. “They tried to milk the snails almost every day – and killed them,” says Habacuc. “The mollusc needs a lunar cycle to regenerate.”

The snail population declined dramatically within five years. The Mixtecs, with the support of ethnologists and biologists, raised the alarm. The Mexican government banned the Japanese companies and in 1994, declaredPurpura columellarisa protected species. Since then, only Mixtecs from Pinotepa de Don Luis have been allowed to milk them.

But new threats arrived, as the once remote coastal region experienced rapid development. Roads, hotels and restaurants were built. Thousands of tourists flock to the beaches and beautiful bays every year – and they demand seafood. “Again and again, we encounter poachers who seize every opportunity to make a few pesos. They don’t care about the extinction of a species,” says Habacuc. “The government talks about protection, but it doesn’t even monitor the beaches in Huatulco national park.”

Since anearthquake in 2020, the species’ future has been even more uncertain. During the tremor, the Pacific plate pushed a little further beneath the Mexican mainland, raising the coast near Huatulco by about half a metre. Some once-inaccessible rocky coastal stretches have since become within easy reach of poachers and tourists. Many coral beds were also elevated. Some are slowly dying, and with them millions of small species that are part of the purpura snail’s food chain.

The Mixtecs are the snail’s most important protectors. Their presence in the national park deters poachers, and they follow strict rules so as not to harm the purpura population. For example, not milking snails smaller than 3cm, banning milking during breeding season, and allowing the snails to regenerate for three to four weeks between milkings.

It is already dark when Habacuc and Rafael return to camp. They cook the beans they brought with them and warm tortillas around the campfire. “We always come for seven to eight days, dyeing during low tide and resting during high tide,” says Habacuc. “When our tortillas run out, we return home.” The dyed yarn is distributed among the town’s weavers. There are still about 60 women working as weavers in Pinotepa de Don Luis.

“The purpura snail and the purple tixinda dye are sacred to us,” says 79-year-old Socorro Paulina Lopez, Habacuc’s wife. She taught her daughter and two daughters-in-law how to weave. “We absolutely must preserve this tradition,” she says.

There are only 14 men left in Pinotepa de Don Luis who continue the dye-gathering tradition.

“We need more educational work so that the fishing communities understand how important the snail is to us and stop poaching,” says Habacuc. “We’re running out of time.”

Find moreage of extinction coverage here, and follow the biodiversity reportersPhoebe WestonandPatrick Greenfieldin the Guardian app for more nature coverage

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian