We Were There by Lanre Bakare review – reimagining Black Britain

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Lanre Bakare's 'We Were There' Explores the Rich History of Black Britain"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Lanre Bakare’s debut book, "We Were There," serves as a vital reexamination of Black Britain, challenging the often narrow narratives that dominate mainstream discussions. Bakare, a Guardian arts and culture correspondent, expands the geographical and cultural scope of Black history, moving beyond the typical London-centric focus. He explores significant cities like Bradford, Cardiff, Birmingham, and Edinburgh, weaving together stories of art, politics, and social movements that reflect the complexities of Black life in the 1970s and 1980s. By starting with northern soul music, an unexpected yet poignant choice, Bakare illustrates the social dynamics of the era, showcasing the cultural spaces where Black communities thrived. This approach allows him to uncover deeper historical contexts, as exemplified by the story of George Lindo, wrongfully imprisoned in 1978, which serves as a critique of the racial injustices entrenched within Britain’s criminal justice system.

Throughout the book, Bakare employs a documentary-style narrative that fluidly transitions between historical events, cultural phenomena, and personal stories, creating a cinematic effect that engages readers. He explores significant events, such as the 1989 murder of Axmed Abuukar Sheekh in Edinburgh, to dismantle the myth that racism is solely an English issue. By highlighting the activism of the Lothian Black Forum, Bakare underscores the importance of recognizing racial violence in Scotland’s history. He also addresses the demonization of Rastafarians during Thatcher's era, linking these narratives to broader societal fears rooted in historical prejudices. Bakare's work not only fills gaps in the historical record but also emphasizes the ongoing impact of past events on contemporary Black culture and activism. By doing so, he repositions Black Britons within the national narrative, affirming their integral role in shaping the cultural landscape of the country. This book is not just a historical account; it is a necessary reflection on resilience and resistance, illustrating that the contributions of Black communities in Britain have always been present, even if often overlooked in mainstream discourse.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The review of "We Were There" by Lanre Bakare highlights the importance of reexamining historical narratives surrounding Black Britain, particularly in the context of a broader societal understanding. Bakare's work aims to expand the conventional portrayal of Black experiences beyond the capital, London, and emphasizes the need for a more comprehensive account of Black life across the UK.

Reframing Historical Narratives

The article underscores Bakare's effort to challenge the simplistic and often reductive mainstream narratives that tend to focus solely on London. By exploring regions like Bradford, Cardiff, Birmingham, and Edinburgh, he emphasizes the diverse experiences of Black communities, suggesting that these stories are integral to understanding the full picture of Black Britain. This approach aims to recalibrate public perception and highlight systemic issues that have persisted over decades.

Cultural Context as a Lens

Bakare employs cultural moments, such as the emergence of northern soul, to delve into deeper historical themes. This method not only enriches the narrative but also serves to connect specific events and individuals, like George Lindo, to broader societal issues, such as racial injustice and the failings of the criminal justice system. This focus on cultural context invites readers to engage with history more dynamically and empathetically.

Addressing Geographic Bias

The book addresses a common misconception that racism is predominantly an "English disease." By examining incidents like the murder of Axmed Abuukar Sheekh in Scotland, Bakare dismantles this narrative and showcases the complexities of racial dynamics across the UK. This angle promotes a more nuanced understanding of racism that transcends geographic boundaries, which can foster greater awareness and dialogue about race relations in all parts of the country.

Potential Societal Impact

The review suggests that Bakare's work may inspire discussions about race, identity, and community, potentially influencing public discourse and policy regarding racial equality and justice. By bringing attention to underrepresented histories, the book could motivate activism and engagement within various communities striving for change.

Target Audience and Community Engagement

This narrative likely resonates with readers who are interested in social justice, history, and cultural studies, particularly those from marginalized communities seeking representation and acknowledgment of their experiences. The book may appeal to activists, educators, and those involved in cultural discourse, aiming to engage a broad audience in a conversation about the complexities of Black identity in Britain.

Market and Economic Considerations

While the review does not directly address market implications, the book's themes may intersect with broader societal movements that can influence economic conditions, particularly in sectors related to social justice and cultural representation. Books that address contemporary social issues often see heightened interest and sales, reflecting a growing consumer awareness around these topics.

Relevance to Current Events

The themes explored in Bakare's book are timely and relevant, especially in the context of ongoing discussions about race and inequality in contemporary society. As these issues remain at the forefront of public consciousness, the book's insights may contribute to ongoing debates and movements advocating for systemic change.

Trustworthiness of the Review

The review appears to be credible, grounded in a thorough analysis of Bakare's work and its implications. It presents a balanced view that recognizes the significance of the contributions made by the author while inviting readers to reflect on the broader societal narratives at play.

The article aims to encourage a rethinking of current perspectives on race and history in the UK, pushing for a more inclusive and representative understanding of Black Britain.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Lanre Bakare’s first book is not just a work of history – it is a necessary and urgent recalibration of the way we think about Black Britain. Too often, mainstream accounts flatten the story, centring it on London, reducing the complexities of life beyond the capital to footnotes. Bakare, a Guardian arts and culture correspondent, challenges this myopia head-on, presenting an expansive, deeply researched work that insists on a broader, richer understanding of Black life. He travels to Bradford, Cardiff, Birmingham and Edinburgh, pulling together art, politics and social movements, with a vision of community life in the 70s and 80s that feels both urgent and long overdue.

Bakare opens with northern soul, an unexpected starting point, since it’s mostly associated with working-class white youth. But in tracing its rise and the spaces where it flourished – clubs, underground venues, dance halls – and giving voice to its Black devotees, he paints a deft portrait of the social tensions of the time.

It’s an approach he deploys throughout the book, using cultural moments to explore deeper historical currents. The story of George Lindo, for example, framed for robbery in 1978, is more than an individual tragedy – it is a devastating indictment of Britain’s racialised criminal justice system. Readers may know Lindo’s name from Linton Kwesi Johnson’s poetry (“Dem frame up George Lindo up in Bradford town / But de Bradford blaks dem a rally round”); Bakare reintroduces him in full detail, making his wrongful imprisonment a stark reminder of historical continuities in abusive policing.

In a chapter on Scotland, Bakare dismantles the fiction that racism was always an “English disease”, focusing on the 1989 murder of Axmed Abuukar Sheekh in Edinburgh by far-right football hooligans. The subsequent activism of the Lothian Black Forum, which pressured authorities to recognise the racial nature of the attack, becomes a pivot point in the country’s anti-racist history. From Handsworth, Birmingham, we get a compelling account of how Rastafarians were demonised in Thatcher’s Britain. Bakare traces the genealogy of these arguments to the 1950s, demonstrating the complicity of both the state and the press in shaping public fear.

One of the book’s strengths is that it reads less like a conventional history and more like a documentary, moving fluidly between historical events, cultural movements and personal narratives. The effect is pleasantly cinematic, as if each chapter is an episode in a larger series about resilience and resistance. The discussion of the first National Black Art Convention – featuring figures such as Marlene Smith,Donald Rodney, Claudette Johnson and Keith Piper – is a case in point. Bakare does not simply recount the event; he embeds it in the broader political and artistic scene, making clear its impact on modern art.

What makes We Were There particularly relevant is the way it draws attention to the past’s ongoing reverberations. A chapter on theReno, Manchester’s legendary nightclub, leads to a discussion of theFifth Pan-African Congress, an event that remains crucial in global Black history but is barely acknowledged in Britain’s national memory. Elsewhere, he draws a direct line from the Black Environmental Network – founded nearly 40 years ago by Julian Agyeman, a British-Ghanaian secondary school teacher from Hull who took his students on field trips to the Lake District – to today’s Black-led environmental justice movements. This is history not as something distant and concluded, but still unfolding.

Bakare’s achievement has been to fill in at least some of the gaps and silences in the historical record, to put Black Britons back where they have always been. They were indeed there: in the countryside, in the nations and regions, in towns and cities, makers of culture and community – even if the popular imagination has tended to edit them out.

Sign up toBookmarks

Discover new books and learn more about your favourite authors with our expert reviews, interviews and news stories. Literary delights delivered direct to you

after newsletter promotion

Jason Allen-Paisant is the author of The Possibility of Tenderness (Hutchinson Heinemann). We Were There: How Black Culture, Resistance and Community Shaped Modern Britain by Lanre Bakare is published by Bodley Head (£22). To support the Guardian and the Observer buy a copy atguardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian