In March, just before the UK locked down, Ispeculated about the challenges Covid-19 might pose to people undergoing cancer treatment. Now, with apprehension building as we dive headfirst into the second wave of Covid-19, I reflect on my past seven months as an oncologist. There is no doubt that 2020 has made life for those living with cancer even harder. It’s also become tougher for those of us who work in cancer care.We’ve had to adapt our communication skills. For some patients, the shift to phone consultations is a welcome change. For others, a phone call removes the small talk part of consultations, where doctors and patients get to know each other. A physical examination tells us more about our patients than the physical findings alone. The silences we so often employ in face to face conversations, generally intuitively without conscious thought, are awkward on the telephone. Video consultations are better, but do not equate to real life. We would never normally start difficult, life-changing conversations with the words: “Can you hear me?”Treating dying people in hospices during Covid-19 is breaking meRead moreLearning to communicate behind a mask, without touch, has been hideous. It’s hard to describe how difficult it is to tell someone their treatment has stopped working, standing two metres away with facial expressions hidden. I hadn’t appreciated just how important non-verbal cues are until they were taken away. Asking difficult and important questions has become harder, so much so that I’ve sometimes subconsciously avoided them.One day in the summer, the specialist nurse I work with and I had to tell a teenager and his parents his treatment had stopped working and there were no more options. There is never an easy way to do this, but we did our best to deliver this impossible news compassionately, in the quiet room on the teenage young adolescent ward, albeit behind masks.Some time later, his mother and I went to the roof terrace to talk more. I suggested that maybe, since we were outside, we could take off our masks. For the first time in months, I felt we could speak like humans; I could express properly, from my heart, how much I wished I could have done more to help her son. As she stood up to leave we hugged. For me, this hug said more than any words ever could. This is what oncology used to be like. This is the oncology I yearn for.One of the things I’ve found hardest has been watching people go through cancer treatment on their own, without the support of friends and families. Imagine spending three months in hospital undergoing intensive chemotherapy without your wife and children being allowed to visit. Imagine getting the phone call that your husband has become so overwhelmed by cancer that doctors have had to put a tube into his airway to help him breathe, but not be able to visit.Imagine being in your early 20s, knowing you have just a few months to live, and making the difficult decision to try chemotherapy in the hope that it will extend your life just enough for you to spend some weekends with friends when lockdown ends. And then discovering the chemotherapy hasn’t worked, and you’ve spent your final few months in and out of hospital, alone, without the opportunity to do the things that made you happy.Imagine being so scared of coronavirus that, even though you’ve finished your treatment, you’re terrified to leave your house to take your children to the park. Or being told that you might die, but not being allowed visitors until you’re days from death. Imagine, in your 30s, going to a hospice as a bridge to dying at home and not being allowed visitors even there.Imagine watching this heartache week in, week out.Early on in the pandemic, we were asked to prioritise cancer treatments from priority one (curative treatment) to priority six (non-curative treatment with a small chance of palliation or temporary tumour control). So far I’ve been lucky. Where I work, we were never so limited by capacity that we had to use this categorisation to prioritise treatments.I may have had to advise against some treatments we would usually recommend. That’s because we now consider the risks outweigh the benefits. But I never had to tell a patient I was not able to offer treatment because we didn’t have the resources to provide it. Some colleagues elsewhere were not as fortunate. As we enter Covid round two, this is again a real fear for all of us, particularly as increasing numbers of us have to isolate.TheNHSdoes not have the spare staff capacity to deal with excessive absences. I dread the day that I have to tell a patient I can’t offer them a treatment because there are not enough pharmacists to make it, or enough chemotherapy nurses to deliver it. I hope this day never comes.The NHS has learned from Covid round one. We know more and we’re better equipped. But we’re also tired. The three-month reprieve in the summer has allowed us to recharge our emotional batteries somewhat, but we are far from 100%. If we started round one fresh, motivated and full of adrenaline, we enter round two tired, perhaps even jaded.We’ve only just finished one marathon. We’re not yet ready to run another. But we will get through this. People always do. Day in, day out, our patients show us the extraordinary psychological strength of humans thrown into adversity.Lucy Gossage is an oncologistIf you would like to contribute to ourBlood, sweat and tears seriesabout experiences in healthcare during the coronavirus outbreak, get in touch by emailingsarah.johnson@theguardian.com
Watching my cancer patients go through treatment alone is heartbreaking
TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:
"Oncologists Reflect on the Emotional Impact of Covid-19 on Cancer Care"
TruthLens AI Summary
As the UK faces the ongoing challenges of the Covid-19 pandemic, oncologists are experiencing a profound shift in how they care for cancer patients. The transition to remote consultations has altered the dynamic of doctor-patient interactions, with some patients welcoming phone calls while others miss the essential personal connection that comes from in-person visits. The author reflects on the emotional toll of delivering difficult news, such as informing a young patient that their treatment options have been exhausted, while also grappling with the limitations imposed by physical distancing and the use of masks. These changes have made it increasingly difficult to convey empathy and compassion, leading to a sense of isolation for both patients and healthcare providers. The absence of non-verbal cues, which are critical in conveying understanding and support, has made these conversations more challenging than ever before.
The author poignantly illustrates the heart-wrenching experiences faced by cancer patients during this time, emphasizing the loneliness that comes with undergoing treatment without the support of loved ones. Many patients have had to navigate their illnesses in solitude, enduring procedures and hospital stays without family visits, which has exacerbated their emotional distress. The narrative highlights specific scenarios, such as a young adult weighing the decision to pursue chemotherapy in the hopes of extending their life for cherished moments with friends, only to face the reality of treatment failure. As the healthcare system braces for a potential second wave of Covid-19, there is concern over resource availability and the possibility of having to prioritize treatments based on capacity, which adds another layer of anxiety for both patients and healthcare providers. Despite the fatigue and emotional strain, the author expresses a resilient commitment to supporting patients and acknowledges the extraordinary strength displayed by those facing adversity during these unprecedented times.
TruthLens AI Analysis
The article presents a poignant reflection on the challenges faced by both cancer patients and healthcare professionals during the Covid-19 pandemic. As an oncologist, the author shares personal experiences that highlight the emotional and practical difficulties encountered in delivering care amidst restrictions.
Impact on Communication
The shift to remote consultations due to Covid-19 has altered the dynamics of doctor-patient interactions. While some patients may appreciate the convenience of phone consultations, many miss the personal touch that in-person visits provide. The article emphasizes the importance of non-verbal cues in communication, which have been severely limited by mask-wearing and social distancing. This change has not only affected the delivery of difficult news but has also created an emotional barrier that complicates the relationship between healthcare providers and patients.
Emotional Toll on Healthcare Providers
The narrative reveals the profound emotional strain that oncologists experience when they have to convey bad news to patients and their families. The author describes a specific instance involving a teenager, illustrating the heart-wrenching nature of these conversations and the challenges posed by the current health crisis. The mention of compassion in difficult moments seeks to evoke empathy from readers, shedding light on the mental burden faced by healthcare workers.
Community and Societal Implications
This article aims to foster awareness about the struggles of cancer patients during the pandemic, potentially galvanizing public support for increased resources in healthcare. By sharing these personal insights, the author seeks to instill a sense of urgency regarding the need for continued support and understanding from society towards those affected by cancer, especially during such trying times.
Manipulative Aspects
While the article is grounded in genuine experiences, it could be interpreted as having a manipulative edge in its emotional appeal. The language used evokes strong feelings of compassion and sadness, which may prompt readers to advocate for cancer patients or question the adequacy of healthcare during the pandemic. This emotional framing serves to emphasize the plight of patients but could also be seen as a call to action for systemic changes within the healthcare framework.
Overall Reliability
The credibility of the article hinges on the personal experiences shared by the author, who is a medical professional. While it reflects real challenges, the emotional tone may skew perceptions. Nevertheless, it effectively raises awareness about significant issues in cancer care during the Covid-19 pandemic. The underlying message stresses the importance of empathy and understanding in healthcare, particularly in the face of unprecedented challenges, thereby establishing a connection with readers who may be unaware of these struggles.