Good morning. In 2009, I honestly thought it was quite likely that I’d see England win the World Cup in my lifetime. Maybe even by the time I reached the grand old age of 40. In the same year, the Labour government announced HS2, and said that the first phase, from London to Birmingham, would open by 2026. Well, it’s 2025 now, I’m 41, England have just lost 3-1 to Senegal, and yesterday HS2 had its expected completion datepushed back from 2033to … we’ll get back to you on that.
By now, it is almost impossible to keep the endless setbacks to the UK’s flagship major infrastructure project straight in your head. But yesterday’s announcement is genuinely significant. On one hand, it reflects years of catastrophic mismanagement, and an even longer wait for the hotly debated benefits of the line to start to be realised. On the other,Labourwould like you to believe they are taking a more realistic view than their predecessors, and finally getting a grip on costs that have spiralled further and further out of control.
So what’s actually changed – and is this thing ever going to get built? For today’s newsletter, I spoke to Guardian political correspondentKiran Staceyabout the prospects of turning a white elephant into a crown jewel. Here are the headlines.
Middle East| Donald Trump has suggested it would make sense for the US to launch strikes against Iran only if bombing was guaranteed to destroy the Fordow uranium enrichment facility,according to people familiar with the deliberations. The sources said he has held off authorizing strikes to see if Iran is prepared to enter talks.
Protest| Universities in England will no longer be able to enforce blanket bans on student protests undersweeping new guidance from the Office for Students. The regulator also advises administrators not to apply prolonged bans on protest encampments over the Israel-Gaza conflict.
Gaza| Eleven Palestinianswere killed early on Wednesday morningafter Israeli forces opened fire on a crowd waiting for food trucks in central Gaza, civil defence officials said. The deaths bring the toll at food distribution sites in recent days to more than a hundred.
Health| Air pollution in the UK is costing more than £500m a week in ill health, NHS care and productivity losses, andkilling more than 500 people a week, doctors have said. The Royal College of Physicians said that 99% of the population are breathing in “toxic air”.
Air India crash| The sole survivor of the Air India crashhas helped carry his brother’s flower-heaped coffinto a crematorium in the western Indian coastal town of Diu, days after they plummeted into the ground shortly after takeoff.
It’s not possible here to give a comprehensive recap of HS2’s winding road from gleaming futuristic ambition to nightmarish money pit, but we can at least run through the broadest outlines. When it was first announced 16 years ago, the plan was to release capacity on existing commuter lines, drastically reduce journey times, boost the northern economy through better connections to the capital, and shift passengers away from cars and flights.
But – as Nils Pratley sets out inthis column- Peter Mandelson later revealed that the cost estimates even then were “almost entirely speculative”. In the years since, costs have risen and risen, and the completion date has fallen further and further back. (Gwyn Tophamhas a useful timeline here.) In 2021, the north-eastern leg of the line that was to run to Leedswas scrapped; and in 2023, Rishi Sunakscrapped the western legdue to run from Birmingham to Manchester, reallocating some money to regional transport schemes but undermining the case that HS2 would be good value as an investment.
Now, amid widespread consensus that the government’s timeline and budget for what remains of the project were unrealistic, transport secretaryHeidi Alexander(pictured above) has announced that the current schedule is undeliverable. She also said that when the line does open, it may initially have to run at slower speeds than expected to prevent further delays.
But there are still major questions about what happens next, with Alexander saying that she would give an update on costs and deadlines before the end of the year. “This was supposed to be the complete reset moment: here’s the new date, here’s the cost, and we’re going to stick to it,” Kiran Stacey said. “But they aren’t quite there yet.”
Why has the project been delayed again?
Alexander’s announcement yesterday is not really news to anyone watching HS2 closely: “The industry was fully expecting another delay,” Kiran said. In that sense, the announcement does not represent a change so much as a recognition of reality. In 2023, the Infrastructure and Projects Authoritysaid that“Successful delivery of the project appears to be unachievable”.
Last year, the new chief executive of HS2 Ltd, Mark Wild,told MPsthat to have any hope of breaking the cycle of overspending, it would take until at least 2026 to set out a new “baseline programme”, ensuring that parts of the work are efficiently synchronised. The National Audit Officesimilarly concludedthat it was now necessary to “take the time needed to properly reset” in order to “deliver value for money from the programme”. There is also a need to rewrite contracts so that contractors are incentivised to work more quickly.
Another part of the problem has been that successive prime ministers – and, as you will recall, we’ve had quite a few of them – have had their own visions of how HS2 should work. “This is a big shiny thing prime ministers want to put their imprint on,” Kiran said. “Meanwhile, the Treasury has always thought it’s a waste of money. So it has always been vulnerable to political change.”
Why has the cost gone up?
When HS2 was first announced, the cost was expected to be about £37.5bn, in 2009 prices. The most recent estimate put the price at £80bn in 2024 prices; now the government says that a more realistic figure at current prices is £100bn. And remember that that is for a much less ambitious route than was originally planned.
That astonishing shift is partly due to factors beyond the government’s control, and partly due to straightforward mismanagement. “The inflation of the last few years has just made everything harder,” Kiran said. “Sourcing materials is more expensive. But there have also been things that were clearly handled poorly.”
Alexander yesterday sought to blame much of that on mismanagement by previous Conservative governments, saying that billions have been wasted in “constant scope changes, ineffective contracts and bad management”. One striking example is the decision to commission two sets of designs for a new station at Euston, at a cost of more than £250m, only to then scrap them both. And under Boris Johnson, the government continued to sign contracts despite being advised by an independent review not to.
In his evidence to MPs last year, Wild said that construction started “way too early”, without the necessary design and planning approvals in place.
Projects like this are always expensive, of course – but the UK does appear to be particularly bad at them. Labour says this is partly because of onerous planning processes. In 2018, a government study found that high speed rail generally cost about £32m a kilometre around the world; even then, phase one of HS2 was budgeted to come in at about £250m per kilometre. It has roughly doubled since then.
What are the arguments for pressing on?
Almost nobody thinks the current plan is ideal: advocates of HS2 tend to think the project would be far more worthwhile if the northern legs of the line remained intact. But even now, they say, the extent of the work already done means that it would be foolish to simply give up. As delayed as the project is, 75% of tunnelling is complete, and work has started on two-thirds of viaducts and half of bridges.
In a piece for the New Statesman from October,Jonn Elledge notesan industry report saying that building HS2 all the way to London and Crewe would comfortably recoup the costs of doing so, “without considering the value of all the extra journeys, homes or other developments the new line will allow”. As the London business group BusinessLDN argued in an open letter about the last leg of the journey to Euston: “Given costs already incurred, and with existing infrastructure and site teams in place, there will never be a cheaper time to build this tunnel than now.”
The government, meanwhile, says that even without the northern leg, HS2 will create new economic opportunity in the West Midlands, and bolster economic growth.
What are the arguments for abandoning it now?
To HS2’s critics, much of this represents a sunk cost fallacy, Kiran said: “If it’s not working, and not worth the money, you scrap it whether you’ve already spent billions or not.”
Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins, a firm opponent of HS2,makes the casethat despite the money already spent, the funds that could be released by abandoning the project – £25.3bn over the rest of this parliament, up to a quarter of the government’s investment budget – could be better spent elsewhere. “The whole of Whitehall now knows HS2 makes no sense,” he writes. “Hospitals could have soared in number, schools multiplied, prisons renewed. I cannot believe [Rachel] Reeves really thinks Britain needs them less than it needs a new railway to Birmingham.”
“Value for money has always been at the heart of the problem,” Kiran said. “One government economist told me that it would be much more cost-effective to fix every pothole in the country.”
What will the government do?
Sign up toFirst Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
There is little prospect of Labour abandoning HS2 now. “One thing counting in its favour is that it fits the government’s narrative about big infrastructure projects,” Kiran said. “So they’re fully committed. If anything, one day they’d love to re-announce phase two” – and though that would not be likely to happen until the second term of a Labour government, it might at least restore something of the scheme’s original ambition.
In lieu of any economic benefit that voters will feel before the next election, Labour needs to at least be able to show that it has got a grip on the ballooning costs. To that end, it has now appointed formerTransportfor London commissioner Mike Brown as the new chair of HS2, hoping he can help repeat the trick he performed on the Elizabeth line of bringing it in on schedule and on budget. “But this is far from the first reset,” Kiran said. “So I wouldn’t blame readers for being a little bit sceptical.”
The death of Jools Sweeney (pictured above) remains unexplained, but his mother Ellen Roome suspects the viral “blackout challenge”. Tech firms won’t release his data without a court order. Nowshe’s campaigning for grieving familiesto gain access.Aamna
When the residents of a small Swedish town discovered their drinking water contained extremely high levels of “forever chemicals”, they had no idea what it would mean for their future.Marta Zaraska’s long readtells the remarkable story.Archie
Saudi journalist Turki al-Jasser tweeted in 2014 thatArab writerscould be killed under the guise of national security. Last week, he was executed.Stephanie Kirchgaessner’s piececontrasts his death with the killing of Jamal Khashoggi.Aamna
I bow to nobody in my antipathy for Tucker Carlson – and so it’s awkward to acknowledge thathis combative interviewwithTed Cruzis as effective an expose of Republican hawkishness over Iran as you are likely to find. Watch a couple of the clipshereandhere.Archie
Shoulddating appslet users filter matches by height?Leah Harper explores society’s obsession with six-foot men.Aamna
Football |Phil Foden struck early as Manchester City began their Club World Cup campaign with a2-0 victoryover Morocco’s Wydad AC. In Trent Alexander-Arnold’s debut for Real Madrid, his new club drew 1-1 with Al-Hilal.
Football |Chelsea’s Mykhailo Mudryk could face a lengthy ban afterbeing charged by the Football Association with doping offences. Under FA regulations the winger could be banned for as long as four years after providing a positive A sample last year.
Cricket |England havekept faith with the vice-captain, Ollie Pope,for the first Test against India, meaning the rising star Jacob Bethell must wait for his chance.
The lead story in ourGuardianprint edition today is “‘I may do, I may not’: Trump keeps world waiting on US joining war”. “Britain could support US to strike Iran from the air” – that’s theTimes,and theTelegraphhas “Hermer: War on Iran may be illegal”. Thei paperruns with “UK tries to delay Nato 5% pledge, as Trump threatens defiant Iranian leader”. TheMetrofears “ArmagedDon”. A change of topic with theFinancial Times: “US warns Britain over security risk of using Chinese wind turbine supplier”. “Assisted dying law would be a wonderful present for Mum” – that’s Esther Rantzen’s daughter in theExpress. Top story in theMailis “Benefits bill is on course to rocket by £18bn a year”, and theMirrorsplashes on “PIP cuts ‘a catastrophe’”.
What Israel’s new war means for Gaza
As the world’s attention moves to Iran,what are Israeli forces doing in Gaza? Emma Graham-Harrison reports
A bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad
At the start of 2023, Precious Adesina (pictured above) made a resolution: she would experiment with afro-hairstyles. It seemed like a personal style choice, but as she quickly learned, hair is political for many Black women.
As Adesina began seeing more thinkers and influencers proudly wearing their natural hair, she felt empowered to embrace her own.
She’s not alone: there’s a quiet boom in products and stylists catering to Black women choosing natural styles. “Reflecting on how I styled and treated my hair,”she writes in this essay, “has allowed me to unlearn a lifetime of being told that my Blackness made me less beautiful, less equipped for the job, less worthy of a Tinder match.”
And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow.
Quick crossword
Cryptic crossword
Wordiply