‘The fans just circulate hot air’: how indoor heat is making life unbearable in India’s sweltering cities

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Indoor Heat Poses Serious Health Risks for Low-Income Families in Bengaluru"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.3
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In the sweltering heat of April, Khustabi Begum finds herself struggling to cope with the oppressive indoor temperatures in Rajendra Nagar, a slum in south Bengaluru. As she sits on the steps of her home, she reflects on the difficulties of escaping the heat, noting that even though it is just as hot outside, the situation indoors feels worse. The family's living conditions are cramped, with only one window that is often closed due to ongoing construction work, leaving little room for air circulation. Despite government advisories urging families to remain indoors during peak heat hours, the advice is largely impractical for those living in poorly ventilated homes with unreliable electricity and water supplies. The rising temperatures in Bengaluru, which have increased by approximately 0.5°C since 2009, are exacerbating the health risks associated with indoor heat for low-income families like hers, who have limited access to cooling options and green spaces.

The challenges faced by Begum and her neighbors are indicative of a broader issue affecting many low-income households in Bengaluru. Researchers from the Indian Institute for Human Settlements (IIHS) highlight that indoor heat is often overlooked in heat action plans, particularly in informal settlements. The design of their homes, typically built with heat-trapping materials and lacking adequate ventilation, contributes to extreme indoor temperatures. Women, in particular, bear the brunt of this issue, as they juggle household responsibilities and paid work, often in unventilated kitchens. Health problems related to heat exposure, such as skin infections and dehydration, are prevalent among residents. Calls for more comprehensive strategies to address these challenges include improving housing conditions, ensuring reliable electricity and water access, and raising awareness about the health impacts of indoor heat. As families like Begum's prioritize their children's education over household cooling solutions, the urgency for effective adaptations to rising temperatures grows increasingly critical.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article narrates the challenging experiences of residents in Bengaluru's slums as they cope with increasing indoor heat. It paints a picture of the struggles faced by families living in poorly ventilated homes, highlighting the inadequacies of government heat advisories. The focus on personal stories, like that of Khustabi Begum, adds a human element to the broader issue of climate change and urban living conditions.

Purpose of the Article

The intent appears to be raising awareness about the dire situation that low-income families face due to rising temperatures and inadequate housing conditions. By detailing the personal experiences of individuals like Begum, the article aims to evoke empathy and draw attention to the broader implications of climate change on vulnerable communities.

Public Perception

This piece seeks to generate a sense of urgency regarding climate change and its impact on everyday life, especially for those in informal settlements. It aims to inform the public about the health risks associated with indoor heat, emphasizing that the problem is not just about discomfort but also about the well-being of families.

Hidden Agendas

While the article focuses on the immediate issue of heat in urban areas, it may also subtly critique governmental responses to climate change and urban planning. By showcasing the inadequacies of existing solutions, it could be suggesting a need for more comprehensive policies that address both climate resilience and social equity.

Manipulative Elements

The emotional tone and personal anecdotes employed in the article can be seen as manipulative if interpreted as an attempt to garner sympathy without proposing actionable solutions. The language used evokes a sense of helplessness, which can effectively mobilize public sentiment but may also overlook potential avenues for community-based responses to the heat crisis.

Truthfulness of the Content

The article appears to be credible, drawing on firsthand accounts and data from the Bengaluru Climate Action and Resilience Plan. However, the narrative may selectively emphasize certain aspects of the issue, potentially oversimplifying the complexities of urban climate adaptation.

Social Impact

This information could ignite discussions on urban planning and climate action among policymakers, potentially leading to reforms aimed at improving living conditions in informal settlements. It may also galvanize community organizations to advocate for better infrastructure and access to green spaces.

Target Audience

The article resonates particularly with environmental activists, social justice advocates, and urban planners. It aims to engage a readership that is concerned about climate change and its social implications, encouraging collective action towards more sustainable urban environments.

Economic Considerations

Though the article primarily focuses on social issues, the implications for local economies are significant. Poor living conditions can affect productivity and health, which in turn impacts economic performance. This context may influence investors' perceptions of the region, particularly in sectors related to real estate and public health.

Global Relevance

The article ties into broader discussions on climate change and urbanization, relevant not just to India but globally. It reflects ongoing concerns regarding the impacts of climate change on urban populations, especially in developing countries, making it pertinent to international audiences.

AI Involvement

While it's unclear if AI was used in the article's writing, it is possible that AI tools could have assisted in data analysis or trend identification related to climate impacts. However, the narrative style and personal stories suggest a human touch in the storytelling.

Conclusion on Manipulation

Elements of manipulation may exist, particularly in the emotional framing of the issues at hand. By focusing on personal struggles and invoking feelings of sympathy, the article could be perceived as pushing for a specific response from its audience, whether it be increased awareness, advocacy, or policy change.

The overall reliability of the article is bolstered by its use of data and personal narratives, but it should be acknowledged that the framing can influence readers' perceptions and emotional responses.

Unanalyzed Article Content

At noon, Khustabi Begum is sitting on the steps leading to her three-room home, trying to escape the stifling April heat indoors. But respite is hard to come by in Rajendra Nagar, a slum in south Bengaluru. “It’s just as hot outside, but it feels worse indoors. It’s been really hot for the past five or six days, but at least there’s an occasional breeze outside,” says the 36-year-old.

Inside Begum’s dimly lit living room, ceiling fans whir. One corner is stacked with sacks of onions and just outside their home is a vending cart. “My husband sellserulli, belluli[onions, garlic],” she says.

The couple moved to Bengaluru more than a decade ago, hoping to give their three children a better education. With a nostalgic smile, Begum recalls her green and breezy village in Kishanganj district in Bihar state. “It’s actually hotter in our village, temperature-wise,” she says. “But when it got unbearable, we would go and take a stroll by the river. Here, there’s nowhere to go, just up and down this street.”

While the government’sheat advisoriesurge people to stay indoors between noon and 3pm, it’s pointless advice for most families in Rajendra Nagar. “The fans just circulate hot air,” she says. “We keep drinkingmatke ka paani[chilled water from clay pots] and step outside from time to time, but there’s nothing else to do to escape the heat inside.”

Indoor heat is recognised as aserious health hazardfor vulnerable groups. Among them are low-income families in informal settlements where poorly ventilated homes are built of heat-trapping materials, and have irregular electricity and water supply. Outdoors, there’s little relief on offer because of limited access to green, open spaces.

Bengaluru, a city of lakes and gardens, has seen a steady rise in temperatures in recent years, challenging its longstanding reputation for clement year-round weather. According to theBengaluru Climate Action and Resilience Plan, the city’s average temperature has risen by approximately 0.23C per decade since 1975, with a sharper increase of nearly 0.5C since 2009. In April, Bengaluru recorded temperatures of about 35C (95F).

In Rajendra Nagar and nearby slums such as LR Nagar and Ambedkar Nagar, most homes are built on compact plots of roughly 300 sq ft, and each household typically has five to seven members. There are power cuts several times a week, lasting from a few hours to a few days, and water is available only on alternate days or even every third day. Running fans or cooling the body with “spray bottles, damp cloths [or] ice towels”, as agovernment heat advisory suggests, can be challenging for people in these neighbourhoods.

Begum’s home has one window, facing a quiet side road. However, the municipality recently began road building work and is widening the sewers. “We open the window only during long power cuts,” her daughter Noor Nagina, 14, says. “Otherwise, we have to deal with mosquitoes and dust from all the work.”

Researchers at the Indian Institute for Human Settlements (IIHS), Bengaluru, point out that most heat action plans (HAPs) in India have overlooked indoor heat, especially in low-income and informal settlements. Areview of 10 city-level HAPs, published in the journal Plos Climate, revealed that only two cities – Rajkot and Bhubaneshwar – explicitly acknowledged indoor heat vulnerability.

“Overall, while a few plans highlight indoor heat risks … there is a significant gap in comprehensive, scalable strategies to address these challenges,” says Swati Surampally, one of the review’s authors.

Poor ventilation does not help, says Radha N, who works with Rajendra Nagar-based NGO Swabhimaan. “Most houses in the area have narrow, tunnel-like entrances, with rooms arranged one behind the other in a straight line. This leaves little to no space for air to circulate indoors and as a result, the concrete walls heat up,” she says.

“Children sometimes wake up crying because of the heat, power cuts and the mosquitoes. As a result, their parents, who spend most of the day working outdoors, are unable to get enough rest at night.”

This, she adds, badly affects their ability to function the next day.

Allamelu John, 39, a domestic worker, only cooks early in the morning and late at night in her home to avoid the smoke and heat that builds up in the afternoon. “Our kitchens are small and lack exhaust fans, so it becomes very difficult,” she says.

At night, her family sleeps on a bedsheet spread over acharpai(a traditional woven bed) on the floor, which, she says, is cooler than sleeping on mattresses.

Across the city, in Kattigenahalli in north Bengaluru, Zakia Begum, 28, sits in a one-room shelter with a tarpaulin roof. She is seven months pregnant and the insufferable indoor heat in her previous tin-roofed home was one of the reasons she and her husband moved here.

Sign up toGlobal Dispatch

Get a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development team

after newsletter promotion

Originally from the Cooch Behar district of West Bengal, Zakia has lived in Bengaluru for nine years. Her husband works as a truck driver with a contractor transporting the municipality’s waste. Zakia quit her job as a domestic worker to look after herself during her pregnancy. Their room is part of a cluster of shanties built on open land among scattered heaps of waste.

“This summer feels different; there’s no breeze,” she says as a small table fan whirs beside her. “Sometimes, I sit by the door hoping for some air, but that’s rare now. The only thing I can do is drink lots of water.”

Most families in Zakia’s neighbourhood depend on tankers for water or buing in limited supplies. While Begum washes her face and hands often to stay cool, she knows she must use water carefully.

Migrant women’s experiences of indoor heat have come up inresearchby the IIHS and its partners. The project, Climate Change Local Adaptation Pathways (Claps), found that indoor heat disproportionately affects women, who shoulder paid work and unpaid domestic responsibilities.

“Women face a triple burden: they manage paid work alongside domestic chores, endure prolonged exposure while cooking in unventilated spaces, and often eat last or inadequately, heightening fatigue and health risks. Together, these factors make indoor heat a deeply gendered and under-recognised health challenge,” says Surampally, a senior research associate at IIHS, also working with Claps.

Kavita G, a social health activist who works in Rajendra Nagar, says: “Women often come to us with problems like itching, skin infections and a burning sensation while urinating, especially during periods of extreme heat.” Older people are particularly vulnerable to heat-related illnesses – including severe dehydration and heatstroke.

Researchers at IIHS say responses to extreme heat must address the structural vulnerabilities thatmigrant workers face– in their homes and at work. Surampally emphasises the need for heat-resilient housing through subsidies for cool roofs and improved ventilation; access to reliable electricity and water; enforcement of labour protections such as rest breaks and hydration for outdoor workers; and multilingual campaigns tailored to migrant communities.

“Many migrants compare Bengaluru’s heat to their even hotter native towns and, therefore, underplay its risks,” Surampally says. “This perception, along with limited financial resources, means that the urgency to adapt is low, even when physical discomfort is high.”

After spending on rent, daily expenses and the children’s schooling, Khustabi Begum’s family might be able to save a little in a month when the profits are healthy. But this doesn’t happen often, given the fluctuating prices of vegetables. “We cannot afford a cooler or a fridge because we have to prioritise our children’s education,” she says.

To escape the heat, small children in Rajendra Nagar often roam around naked and Begum laments the unfairness of how her husband and two boys sleep with their shirts off – a comfort not afforded to her and her daughter. “Women do not have that option,” she sighs.

This story first appeared in theMigration Story, India’s first newsroom to focus on the country’s vast migrant population. The reporting was supported by People First Cities which is undertaking a project on rising heat in informal settlements

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian