The anti-Benítez: how Giráldez unleashed Celta’s youth and spirit | Sid Lowe

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Claudio Giráldez Transforms Celta Vigo's Performance and Team Spirit"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.1
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Claudio Giráldez has revitalized Celta Vigo since taking the helm, transforming the team's culture and performance. Following a dismal season under Rafa Benítez, where the team was perilously close to relegation, Giráldez's arrival marked a significant turnaround. He inherited a squad that had struggled in previous seasons, often finishing in the lower half of the La Liga table, and managed to instill a sense of joy and belonging among the players. The recent 3-0 victory over Villarreal not only secured them a position in the European qualification spots but also embodied the spirit of the club's youth and community. This match was a testament to Giráldez's coaching philosophy, emphasizing the importance of playing style and youth involvement, as evidenced by the fact that the majority of players on the pitch were products of Celta's own academy.

Giráldez's background as a lifelong Celta fan and a coach who has risen through the ranks has allowed him to connect deeply with the players. His approach encourages creativity and enjoyment of the game, which had been stifled under the previous management. With minimal financial investment in new players, Giráldez has relied heavily on the talents developed within the club, fostering a strong sense of identity and pride among the squad. Key players like Borja Iglesias and Iago Aspas have thrived under his leadership, as they appreciate his support and faith in their abilities. The atmosphere at Estadio de Balaídos has transformed, with fans and players alike celebrating a renewed sense of hope and excitement for the future, as they aim for a return to European competition, something that has not been achieved for several years. Giráldez's success is not just measured in wins but also in the happiness and unity he has brought back to Celta Vigo, making football enjoyable again for everyone involved.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article highlights the transformative impact that Claudio Giráldez has had on Celta Vigo, illustrating a renewed sense of joy and unity among players and fans following a successful match. It offers a narrative of recovery and optimism for the team's future, contrasting sharply with the previous management under Rafa Benítez.

Emotional Connection with the Team

The piece emphasizes the emotional bond formed between the players and the fans, capturing the celebratory atmosphere at Estadio de Balaídos after their victory over Villarreal. This connection is crucial, as it showcases football not merely as a game but as a communal experience that enhances the identity of the players and supporters alike.

Shift in Management Philosophy

Giráldez's appointment is presented as an unexpected yet fortuitous change for Celta Vigo. His previous success with the B team and the sudden necessity for a new direction in management post-Benítez illustrates a pivotal moment for the club. The article suggests that this change was not only necessary but also a chance to embrace a more vibrant and engaging style of play, which resonates well with the team's history and aspirations.

Contrasting Leadership Styles

The article draws a stark contrast between Giráldez and his predecessor, Benítez, highlighting the latter's disappointing tenure. The use of phrases like “sacked in March 2024” and “one place and two points off the relegation zone” underscores the challenges faced under Benítez, while simultaneously celebrating Giráldez’s positive influence.

Public Sentiment and Image

There is an evident intention to foster a positive public sentiment towards Celta Vigo following Giráldez's appointment. This narrative aims to galvanize support from fans and potentially attract new followers by painting the club’s future in a hopeful light. It seems to deliberately downplay the difficulties experienced under the previous management.

Potential Manipulation and Bias

While the article is largely positive, it may gloss over the complexities and challenges that Giráldez may face moving forward. The focus on the joyous moments and the community spirit might lead readers to overlook the potential for setbacks or the intricacies involved in maintaining team morale and performance.

Reliability and Trustworthiness

The overall reliability of the article seems high, as it reports on observable events and sentiments following a specific match. However, the potential for bias is present due to its overwhelmingly positive tone regarding Giráldez's impact without addressing possible future challenges.

In conclusion, the article serves as a means to boost the morale of Celta Vigo's fans, highlighting the positive changes brought by Giráldez. It seeks to create an encouraging narrative around the team’s revival while strategically underplaying the previous management’s shortcomings.

Unanalyzed Article Content

“Claudio has changed my life,” Borja Iglesias said and all around him, as they jumped and sang and smiled and hugged, his teammates felt the same; he has changed all of their lives. At the end of Celta Vigo’s victory over Villarreal on Wednesday, players and staff crouched low before fans and for the first time a hush fell over the Estadio de Balaídos. All together now, the chant started slowly, quietly, whispered, but the pace quickened and the volume grew bit by bit until they burst to their feet, belted out their name and bounced off each other, footballers fell into the net laughing and one thought emerged above any other:how much fun they were having.

This is the way football’s supposed to be: enjoying, belonging. This is the way it has been since Claudio Giráldez came along: good even when it has been bad and getting better all the time. The last time Celta played Villarreal they were beaten 4-3 with a 100th-minute winner, a game of seven goals that could have been 17 after which Iglesias said: “If we’re going to lose, let it be like this.” Eight months on Celta beat them back, a 3-0 victory lifting them into a European place where they have not finished for a decade and embodying all they want to be. Iglesias was a ball boy back then and it was “cool”, he said, but not quite like this, grateful for the days he has been given.

Giráldez had been thinking the unthinkable, ready to walk, when Celta offered him the manager’s job last March. Born and raised 10 miles away and a success as B team coach, he had even won the derby against Deportivo de La Coruña, but taking the first team was not the plan. It was expensive too – Celta had signed Rafa Benítez for three years on €3m each – but this was an emergency. As it turned out, it was also an opportunity. They had thought it a coup to get the Champions League winner in for their centenary season yet he did not complete it, sacked in March 2024, one place and two points off the relegation zonehaving won just five times in 28, the worst win percentage in 80 years. So they called Giráldez and he matched that in a third of the games.

Celta climbed to safety swiftly. A year on, having spent zero euros on new signings and Iglesias one of only three players joining them last summer, they are seventh. The final Champions League place, held by the Villarreal team they beat, is within reach. At Balaídos, they believe it is possible, there is hope – and that is a success in itself, the point of it all. It is not just that Celta could return to continental competition for the first time since thatOld Trafford semi-final in 2017. It is thatrelegation,more realthan Europe in a time when they finished 13th, 13th, 17th, 17th, 8th, 11th, 13th and 13th, and a fate from whichIago Aspas too often had to rescue them, has been left behind. It is the way they have done it, who they have done it with and what it all means, how it feels. And it feels good,theirs.

Born in O Porriño in Pontevedra province, a town of 20,562 people, Giráldez was a Celta fan who said the world stopped when the ball was at the feet of Aleksandr Mostovoi. Nephew of the former Celta and Real Valladolid centre-back José “Pepe” Lemos, he could play a bit too. Spotted representing Porriño at the Vigo Cup, he left for Real Madrid at 13, arriving the same year Zinedine Zidane did, but home pulled, more than a playing career. He regretted that and regretted the time away too, which he felt even more keenly when his father died. He did not hit the gym, did not look after his diet, did not do the things others did, all the essential extras. Instead, he trusted everything to his left foot and his brain; both were good but not enough.

While he trained with Sergio Ramos and Arjen Robben, joining first-team sessions, Giráldez only played one game for Castilla, the B team – and that was against Celta in Segunda B, Group I. Aspas played against him that day in September 2007;Michu scored. He had a year at Atlético Madrid’s academy, but went back to Galicia: Pontevedra, Ourense, Coruxo. And then Porriño Industrial, where he did everything from coaching to ticketing to chasing sponsors. He also sold insurance.

“I tell my players now not to be the donkey I was,” he says. But there was something about him that was always more coach more than player anyway. The way he tells it, he learned to read and write with Don Balón magazine, Marca guidebooks and football stickers. He was, he said, a bit of afriki: an anorak, a geek. He played PC Futbol, Spain’s Championship Manager with Michael Robinson on the box. He played at coach in his teams too, noting lineups, formations and drills, a collective view which partly got in the way of his individual development. He argued with coaches and admits he could be “unbearable” and a “pain in the arse”. He got two degrees – sports science and journalism – and never quite made playing his everything. He got his coaching badge at 19.

He coached inTercerain Vigo, took Celta’s under-19s in 2021 and the second team the year after. When he reached the first team last season after eight years coaching in the academy, he was the second youngest manager inPrimera,behind Iñigo Pérez. He was younger than Aspas, his centre-forward and theclub’s best ever player. “It seems like I’m young but I’ve been around 20 years,” he says. The time at Madrid and Atlético shaped him, especially working under Abraham García, Fernando Torres’s mentor. But hisideas also came from Johan Cruyff. Above all they came from Celta, where he watchedEduardo Berizzo and Luis Enrique, had longconversations with Eduardo “El Chacho” Coudet, and saw what the kids could do.

On his first night in charge, Celta won 2-1 at the Ramón Sánchez Pizjuán Stadium. “This is the way we have to play,” Aspas said after. “Even if we lose, we have to play the way we know.” Aspas and his teammates got bored and increasingly irritable under Benítez, something irremediably broken. Fans had too, the identification lost. For the first time in 15 years, under Benítez, Celta fielded an XI without a single academy player. Giráldez was a liberation. He changed everything.

The new coach trusted them, believed in them and had inculcated a footballing ideal already. He was closer to them but demanding. Hugo Sotelo says they have a love-hate relationship and Iglesias’s claim that Giráldez changed his life, calling him “the best coach I’ve ever had”, was about support too and the warmth was shared: “Borja is a man whodignifies this sport,” the coach said. As for the kids, he knew they could play, so they played. The only problem, he said, was the music in the dressing room.

Sign up toFootball Daily

Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football

after newsletter promotion

It was time to enjoy this. Always watch Celta, even when they lose.They were beaten 4-3 by Barcelonaon Saturday and drew 2-2 with them earlier this season, as they did with Real Betis and Girona. They lost 3-2 at Osasuna. They scored 17 in four Copa del Rey games before getting knocked out 5-2 after extra time at the Bernabéu. Only two La Liga teams have conceded more; only four have scored more. They were beaten at home by Madrid and Atlético but out-shot both.“Celta play, Madrid win,” as one headline put it. Although it took a while, although they lost two in a row before this midweek – that 4-3 at Barcelona and 2-0 against Espanyol – those were their only defeats in 10, the control and assuredness increasing. Giráldez rightly said: “Survival was the objective. No one expected us to be fighting for Europe; this is something to be enjoyed.”

Something very real too after 3-0 victory over Villarreal. It was helped by a red card but beyond the points or the place in the table, the whole thing was a portrait of what Celta are, a picture of happiness. Of the 16 players Giráldez used, 10 are under 25, 11 played in the academy, and eight are Galicians, seven from the province. There was a goal each for three generations of youth-team products and Galicians: the 20-year-old Fer López got the first, the 32-year-old Iglesias – the heart of theCelta B Panda Team from where his nickname camebefore embarking on a career that has brought him back eight years later – got the second and departed to a standing ovation, embracing the 37-year-old Aspas and holding Giráldez in a long hug. And Aspas almost added an outrageous third immediately before scoring a penalty in the final minutes, the evening complete.

At the end, as the seagulls flew across from the Atlantic, someone handed Iglesias a Polaroid picture of his goal and 19,324 people put their arms around one another and sang. “I was at the academy when they were in Europe and the atmosphere was cool but I don’t think I’ve ever seen a communion like this,” Iglesias said. “We have to look after it, enjoy it and live it intensely.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian