The Haves and Have-Yachts by Evan Osnos review – inside the world of the ultrarich

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Evan Osnos Examines Superyachts and Wealth Inequality in 'The Haves and Have-Yachts'"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.4
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In his insightful analysis, Evan Osnos explores the extravagant world of superyachts and the stark inequalities that accompany their ownership. The term 'length overall' (LOA), which refers to the size of these vessels, serves as a metaphor for the wealth and status of their owners. For instance, Jeff Bezos's $485 million yacht, Koru, illustrates this phenomenon, as its towering height led to a notable incident where it could not pass under Rotterdam’s Koningshaven Bridge. This situation not only highlights the absurdity of wealth but also draws a parallel between the challenges faced by ordinary individuals, such as the author’s own experience with a refrigerator delivery. Osnos emphasizes that while superyachts can produce as much greenhouse gas as 1,500 cars, the demand for such luxury items continues to surge, reflecting a dramatic increase in the number of billionaires in the United States from 66 in 1990 to over 700 in 2023. This growth starkly contrasts with the mere 20% increase in median hourly wages during the same period, underscoring the spiraling inequality present in society today.

Osnos also delves into the political implications of this wealth disparity, noting how figures like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have gained prominence alongside their rising net worths. He suggests that the super-rich are increasingly retreating into their luxurious floating retreats, distancing themselves from societal issues. The extravagant amenities found on modern superyachts, such as IMAX theaters and onboard pathogen testing equipment, reflect a desire among the ultra-wealthy to escape the realities faced by the average person, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, Osnos references Thorstein Veblen’s concept of 'conspicuous consumption,' highlighting how these ostentatious expenditures serve to reinforce social status. Despite the financial pitfalls associated with yacht ownership, which can lead to significant depreciation, the allure of such possessions remains strong, suggesting that for many, the act of owning a superyacht is less about investment and more about the display of wealth and privilege.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article provides an insightful commentary on the growing divide between the ultra-wealthy and the average citizen, using the superyacht industry as a lens to examine broader social and economic inequalities. By highlighting extreme wealth represented by figures like Jeff Bezos, the piece suggests a troubling trend of increasing disparity not just in wealth, but also in political influence and environmental impact.

Wealth Disparity and Societal Impact

The statistics presented indicate a stark contrast in the growth of billionaires and the median hourly wage in the U.S. While the number of billionaires has surged dramatically, wages have seen modest increases. This disparity raises concerns about economic equity and suggests that wealth concentration is leading to greater social stratification. The reference to superyachts and their environmental impact serves to underscore the excesses of the ultra-rich, drawing attention to the prioritization of luxury over sustainability.

Political Implications

The article also touches on the political implications of wealth concentration. The mention of influential figures like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg during Trump’s oath of office signifies the intertwining of wealth and political power. This suggests a shift towards a plutocracy, where the interests of the wealthy overshadow those of the general populace. It raises questions about the future of democracy and governance in a society where economic power translates directly into political clout.

Public Perception and Awareness

Through the lens of humor and personal anecdotes, the writer creates a relatable narrative that encourages readers to reflect on their own experiences with wealth and privilege. The juxtaposition of Bezos’s yacht with the author’s refrigerator problem serves to humanize the discussion, making the complexities of wealth accessible to a broader audience. This approach could be seen as a strategy to engage readers in a conversation about inequality, prompting them to consider the implications of such disparities in their own lives.

Potential Hidden Agendas

While the article raises valid points about inequality, it may also inadvertently downplay the complexities of wealth creation and the potential benefits that wealth concentration can bring, such as innovation and economic growth. By focusing heavily on the negative aspects, there could be a risk of fostering resentment toward the wealthy, rather than promoting a balanced discussion about wealth distribution and its societal effects.

Trustworthiness and Manipulation

The article appears to be grounded in factual data and anecdotal evidence, which lends credibility to its arguments. However, the tone and focus on the negative aspects of wealth might suggest a bias aimed at provoking a specific emotional response from the reader. This could lead to a perception of manipulation, as the framing of issues might overshadow more nuanced discussions.

The analysis of this piece reveals a complex interplay between wealth, power, and societal values. It highlights the urgent need for dialogue about economic inequality and its implications while also prompting readers to consider their own positions within this framework. Ultimately, the article serves as both a critique of the ultra-wealthy and a call to action for greater awareness of the societal consequences of extreme wealth.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Nothing says so much about a superyacht or its owner, writes Evan Osnos, as its LOA. The initials stand for “length over all” – or what one aficionado he interviewed calls “phallic sizing”. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, before he got the idea of sending celebrities like Katy Perry into space, commissioned a $485m yacht called Koru. With its towering masts, the 127 metre-long boat proved too tall to pass beneath Rotterdam’s famous Koningshaven Bridge, and while its manufacturers suggested dismantling the bridge, rather than the yacht, the heroes of that particular story – the Dutch – refused.

I had a similar problem recently. Delivery people couldn’t remove our old fridge because we had, in the interim, narrowed the hall with an understairs cupboard. In that moment, I identified with Bezos. True, as Osnos reports, one well-stocked diesel yacht can produce as much greenhouse gas as 1,500 passenger cars, while my broken fridge produces none, but the parallel remains.

In this droll and timely analysis of extreme wealth, New Yorker staff writer Osnos notes that superyacht demand is outstripping supply. In some countries you have to wait for bread, water or inoculations; in others for giant sea-going vessels. In 1990, there were 66 US billionaires; by2023there were over 700, an increase of more than 1,000%. In the same period, the number of US yachts measuring longer than 76 metres has gone from “less than 10 to more than 170”. Median US hourly wages, in contrast, have risen by just 20%. Maths is not my strong suit, but this suggests inequality is spiralling.

There’s also a spiralling inequality in political power. Trump postures as a president for blue-collar Americans, but the people who shared the stage when he took his oath of office on 20 January tell another story. In that symbolic moment Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Bezos and Sergey Brin showed their influence was rising with their net worth. “The world watched America embrace plutocracy without shame or pretence,” writes Osnos.

Meanwhile, shame and pretence are in plentiful supply elsewhere. One yacht owner tells Osnos: “No one today – except for assholes and ridiculous people – lives on land in what you would call a deep and broad luxe life. Yes, people have nice houses and all of that, but it’s unlikely that the ratio of staff to them is what it is on a boat. Boats are the last place that I think you can get away with it.”

In other words, the modern versions of Hearst Castle and Blenheim Palace are discreetly mobile, able to whisk themselves out of sight at a moment’s notice. It dovetails nicely with a political agenda best articulated by Peter Thiel. The venture capitalist, Osnos reports, gave start-up capital to the Seasteading Institute, which seeks to create floating mini-states – part of his libertarian project to “escape from politics in all its forms”. And, presumably, to “get away with it”.

In any event, it’s not just how big your superyacht is, but what you put inside it. The latest fashions include Imax theatres, ski rooms where guests can suit up for a helicopter trip to a mountaintop, and hospital equipment that enables onboard pathogen tests. That last detail is key: Covid accelerated the desire of the super-rich to get away by any means necessary from, with due respect, plebs like you and me.

The have-yachts seem to be following the Thorstein Veblen playbook. When the economist wrote The Theory of the Leisure Class in 1899, he argued that the power of “conspicuous consumption” involved revelling in showy wastefulness. You’ll be wanting a personal submarine for your yacht, not to mention eel and stingray leather for its upholstery. Osnos lists what can be delivered to your watery fastness: Zabar’s bagels, rare melons from Hokkaido, Dom Pérignon, sex workers. Ocado needs to up its game.

Sign up toInside Saturday

The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend.

after newsletter promotion

There’s just one problem. Superyachts are a terrible asset class in that they lose value faster than you can say bonfire of the vanities. “Owning a superyacht is like owning a stack of 10 Van Goghs,” argued the Financial Times, “only you are holding them over your head as you tread water, trying to keep them dry.” But then again, as Veblen understood, maybe that’s part of the point?

The Haves and Have-Yachts: Dispatches on the Ultrarich by Evan Osnos is published by Simon & Schuster (£22). To support the Guardian, order your copy atguardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian