It has not happened very often. Just once in the past 20 years, to be precise. Winning a single trophy is hard enough but English clubs hoisting aloft both theChampions Cupand Challenge Cup in the same season would be a proper rarity. Other than the Covid-afflicted year of 2020 when Exeter Chiefs and Bristol Bears prevailed in mostly empty stadiums, the last time there was a Premiership double was in May 2004.
Back then Wasps and Harlequins were the happy couple, beating Toulouse and Montferrand respectively. This week also features two Anglo-French finals withNorthamptonfacing Bordeaux-Bègles in the main event and Bath tackling Lyon in Friday night’samusebouche.A measure of the challenge facing the English duo is that French clubs have hoovered up seven of the past eight available trophies, with South Africa collecting the other.
That Gallic trend could continue if Bordeaux uncork their glorious attacking game and Lyon bely their modest 11th position in the Top 14 table. But given the depth of forward resources at Bath’s disposal and Northampton’s outstanding display in theirsemi-final win over Leinster, the two clubs can at least dream of a return to the distant days when English rugby was officially first among equals.
To which some will rightly reply that the degree of correlation between Champions Cup pedigree and international success can fluctuate. True enough, but there are some persuasive past case studies. When, for example, was the English national team at its strongest in the professional era? Probably between 2001 and the 2003 World Cup. And which nation collected seven out of eight European trophies around that same period? You’ve guessed it.
So while there remains a way to travel – and nothing can be remotely guaranteed in Cardiff – the tender green shoots of an English recovery are discernible. Steve Borthwick’s squad to tour Argentina this year, even without a battalion of Lions, will feature some exciting young talent by anyone’s standards. And when you buy a ticket to a club match at the moment, you are liable to receive better value for your money than you have in ages.
It might be a stretch to suggest English rugby is quietly reinventing itself – Northampton’s Henry Pollock is not the shy retiring type – but a tad more confidence and a touch less introspection are discernible. On their day Saints,Bath, Bristol, Gloucester and Harlequins can all leave eye-catching vapour trails while Leicester, Sale and Saracens, in their slightly contrasting ways, are no slouches.
What no one yet knows, however, is whether this is just a brief phase. Are Bath and Saints mere outliers? Will the financial muscle of the French clubs tip the balance? In that context the looming Cardiff finals feel important in terms of transforming perceptions as well as English self-belief. No one is suggesting Bordeaux and Lyon would not be worthy champions but an opportunity exists for thePremiershipto send an overdue message to the rest of Europe and South Africa.
There is certainly no shortage of motivation for Northampton as they seek to emulate the 2000 heroics of Pat Lam and co against Munster at Twickenham. These latter-day Saints are the defending English champions and, while their league form has been mixed, few if any teams have ever won away in Pretoria, Limerick and Dublin in the same season.
Bath’s last Champions Cup title was even longer ago (though they did win the Challenge Cup at Worcester’s expense in 2008) but the hope is that good things will come to those who wait. Domestically Bath have been way ahead of the regular season pack, to the point where their supporters will be gutted should they fail to win the Premiership title.
For all the ability of Scotland’s Finn Russell and their South African contingent – has there been a more consistently impactful bench player this season than the underrated Francois van Wyk? – the steady improvement of Ted Hill, Guy Pepper, Will Muir, Max Ojomoh and Ciaran Donoghue has also helped enormously
That English quintet must all now be in the frame to tour Argentina and the US this summer (although Donoghue is qualified for Ireland as well). As with Saints, their development is a credit to those coaching and mentoring them. How interesting, in that regard, that the league’s most upwardly mobile teams all have something in common coaching-wise. Did you know that Phil Dowson, Johann van Graan, Lee Blackett, Sam Vesty, Alex Sanderson, George Skivington – not to mention Leicester’s new incoming coach, Geoff Parling – are all aged between 41 and 45? And all bar Van Graan are English …
Sign up toThe Breakdown
The latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewed
after newsletter promotion
It hints at a coaching sweet spot in the modern game: influential voices from a younger generation with both an instinctive grasp of a fast-changing sport and a proactive relationship with today’s players. The current England head coach, Steve Borthwick, at 45, is from the same bracket and the extra freedom with which England have sought to play further reflects shifting attitudes.
It makes for an increasingly virtuous circle: club and international players seeking to pursue similar objectives, a hugely promising clutch of emerging age-group internationals, more licence for decision-makers to play what they see. None of this is rocket science but, like a gum-shielded Rip Van Winkle, English rugby finally seems to be awakening from its tactical slumber.
Eyes wide open, hearts full, expectations high. No wonder there is a buzz surrounding this weekend. Only two of England’s premier clubs, Saracens and Exeter, have claimed the Champions Cup since Wasps’ last triumph in 2007. Successfully update that statistic and a wider English renaissance may dawn sooner than people think.
This is an extract taken from our weekly rugby union email, the Breakdown. To sign up, justvisit this pageand follow the instructions.