The Book of Records by Madeleine Thien review – a dazzling fable of migration

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Madeleine Thien's The Book of Records Explores Migration and Memory"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.3
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In her fourth novel, The Book of Records, Madeleine Thien crafts a mesmerizing narrative that intertwines themes of migration, memory, and the passage of time. Set in a near-future world, the story unfolds in a vast migrant compound known as 'the Sea,' where Lina and her father, Wui Shin, find refuge after escaping the devastation of the flooded Pearl River Delta. The Sea is not just a physical space but a metaphorical one, embodying the complexities of human experience and history. Through the lens of the Great Lives of Voyagers series, which Lina carries with her, the novel explores the interconnectedness of individual stories with broader historical narratives. The compound's design reflects the fluidity of time, as different sections resonate with distinct decades, illustrating Wui Shin's assertion that 'the buildings of the Sea are made of time.' This setting serves as a backdrop for Lina's journey, where she grapples with her identity and the legacies of those who came before her, including influential figures like Hannah Arendt and Baruch Spinoza, whose lives are echoed in her new neighbors' stories.

As the narrative unfolds, Thien delves into deeper philosophical inquiries about knowledge and existence, employing a rich tapestry of characters who embody various cultural and historical perspectives. The residents of the Sea, including avatars of famous thinkers, engage in profound discussions about freedom, identity, and the significance of history, making the 12th floor of the Sea a hub of intellectual exploration. Yet, The Book of Records transcends mere intellectualism, presenting a vibrant array of subplots and characters who breathe life into the story. Thien's writing is both serious and playful, capturing the tension between stasis and movement, as the characters navigate their quests for safety and belonging. Ultimately, the novel is anchored by a powerful belief in the necessity of mutual aid and connection, as Thien weaves a narrative that not only honors the past but also emphasizes the importance of supporting one another in the face of adversity.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article presents a review of Madeleine Thien's novel "The Book of Records," which explores themes of migration, memory, and the passage of time through the metaphor of the sea. The narrative unfolds in a near-future setting where a migrant compound, referred to as "the Sea," becomes a central character in the story. The review captures the essence of Thien’s storytelling while highlighting its deeper philosophical underpinnings.

Purpose of the Publication

The review aims to engage readers with the novel's thematic depth, particularly its exploration of migration and the human experience. By framing the story within a larger philosophical context, the publication seeks to spark discussions about the implications of migration in contemporary society and the importance of historical memory. The intent is to promote awareness and empathy towards the plight of migrants.

Perception in the Community

This review likely aims to foster a sense of understanding and compassion towards migrants, emphasizing the shared human experiences that transcend borders. It encourages readers to reflect on their own histories and the narratives that shape their identities, thus creating a more inclusive perception of migration as a universal theme.

Information Omission

While the review focuses on the novel's themes, it does not delve into specific political or socioeconomic factors influencing migration today. This could be seen as a deliberate choice to keep the focus on the literary aspects rather than engage in a potentially divisive political discourse.

Manipulative Aspects

The review does not overtly manipulate the audience but rather invites them to consider the complexities of migration through a narrative lens. However, the framing of the sea as a repository of memory may romanticize the migrant experience, potentially glossing over the harsh realities faced by many.

Truthfulness of the Content

The review accurately reflects the themes and motifs within Thien’s novel. It presents a thoughtful interpretation of the text, focusing on its literary merits and philosophical questions, which adds to its credibility.

Societal Implications

The themes discussed in the review resonate deeply in today’s context, where migration is a pressing global issue. By highlighting these themes, the article could contribute to broader societal discussions about immigration policies, humanitarian efforts, and the importance of cultural narratives.

Target Audience

The review is likely aimed at readers interested in literature that addresses social issues, particularly those related to migration and identity. It may also appeal to literary scholars and critics, as well as general readers seeking meaningful narratives.

Market Impact

While the review itself may not directly influence stock markets, the themes raised could have an indirect effect on industries related to publishing, education, and social services. Books that tackle contemporary issues often see increased interest, potentially impacting sales and market trends.

Global Power Dynamics

The novel's exploration of migration reflects current global dynamics, where displacement and the search for belonging are increasingly relevant. This aspect brings the narrative into alignment with contemporary discussions about refugees and migrants in various geopolitical contexts.

AI Influence

It is unlikely that AI was involved in the writing of this review, as it exhibits a nuanced understanding of literary themes and human experiences that typically require a human touch. Any AI models that could generate such content would need to be highly advanced in literary analysis and emotional intelligence.

The review stands as a thoughtful engagement with Thien's work, encouraging readers to reflect on the significance of migration and memory within the human experience. Its credibility is bolstered by its focus on literary analysis and its relevance to contemporary social issues.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The sea takes many forms in fiction. It was an adventure playground in Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island and a rowdy neighbour in Daphne du Maurier’s Jamaica Inn. It played the wine-dark seducer in Homer’s Odyssey and the snot-green tormentor in Joyce’s Ulysses. But while its colour can change and its humour may vary, its fictional properties remain reassuringly stable. The sea is our unconscious, a repository of memory, the beginning and end of all things. It’s what Jules Verne described as the “Living Infinite”.

In Madeleine Thien’s rapturous fourth novel, The Book of Records, “the Sea” is the name given to a gargantuan migrant compound, sprawled on the shoreline a decade or two in the future. Lina and her ailing father, Wui Shin, occupy an apartment on the labyrinthine 12th floor, from where they can watch the refugee boats pull in and depart. The pair have fled the flooded Pearl River Delta, leaving behind Lina’s mother, brother and aunt but carrying three volumes from an epic biographical series entitled The Great Lives of Voyagers. These tattered instalments cover the respective histories of the German-Jewish philosopher Hannah Arendt, the Chinese poet Du Fu and the Portuguese-Jewish scholar Baruch Spinoza. They provide both a link to the past and a sextant to navigate by. The world exists in endless flux, Lina is told, and yet here in the Sea nothing ever goes missing. Its chambers fill and empty like locks on a canal. Different portions of the compound appear to correspond with different decades. “The buildings of the Sea are made of time,” Wui Shin explains.

Naturally this near-future migrant fable is also by extension a novel of ideas. It’s about the ways in which experience and knowledge are handed down or slip free, to the point where we inherit and inhabit the lives of those who have gone before. Wui Shin once worked as a “cyberspace engineer” for a state-controlled tech firm, restricting access to the Chinese internet. His daughter’s story, though, plays out as an unfettered open inquiry, cross-referencing the laws of physics with the writings of Kafka, Proust and Italo Calvino. Thien – who was born in Canada to Chinese parents – is fascinated by the relationship of memory to history and by the cross-pollination of separate cultures and writers. Intriguingly, her 2016 Booker-shortlisted novelDo Not Say We Have Nothingcontains a close cousin of Lina’s Great Lives series: the fragment from a book of historical records which has been copied by hand and smuggled out of China. The Sea recycles its wares, just as novelists do. Each standalone story is like a beaker dipped and drawn from a wider body of work.

Lina will go on to spend many years in the Sea, but as the book begins, the girl has no sooner settled into her apartment than the doors slide open to reveal her neighbours. The refugees gather around the new arrival like Dorothy’s companions in The Wizard of Oz. They breezily introduce themselves as Jupiter, Bento and Blucher, but they are also the avatars of Du Fu, Spinoza and Arendt. It is through their stories that we learn how Spinoza was labelled a heretic in 17th-century Amsterdam and Arendt went to ground in Nazi-occupied France. “You do know a lot about Du Fu,” Lina tells Jupiter at one point. “What am I,” Jupiter replies, “other than the things I know?”

The 12th floor of the Sea is a rarefied realm. Conversations constantly circle back to the big subjects: history and language; freedom and identity. And yet The Book of Records offers more than an intellectual talking shop. Its cramped apartment is the springboard from which the story glides out through various vibrant subplots, each furnished with a cast of vivid bit-players, some of whom (the blond visa clerk with the runny nose; the apprentice lens grinder with the bandaged hand) are described and dispensed with in a deft line or two. Lina’s three migrants are essentially ghosts themselves, passing through history in the blink of an eye. But their respective quests are made to feel urgent and ongoing, and we thrill to their adventures as though they are happening in real time. Arendt and her husband eventually cross the Pyrenees on foot, stumbling on the narrow mountain path, watching out for border guards. They dream of a safe Atlantic passage and a fresh start in New York, “a place in the future where the past can meet”.

The Book of Records is a rich and beautiful novel. It’s serious but playful; a study of limbo and stasis that nonetheless speaks of great movement and change. If this turbulent, mercurial tale has an anchor, it is its belief that “in order to extend life and preserve civilisation, we are obliged to rescue one another”. Thien explains in the acknowledgments that she has lifted this quote from The Book of Mountains and Rivers, a 2012 essay collection by the Chinese writer Yu Qiuyu. She hands it on from Arendt to Blucher to Lina in the Sea, as though it’s a baton or a lifeline that connects all the world’s great voyagers.

Sign up toInside Saturday

The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend.

after newsletter promotion

The Book of Records by Madeleine Thien is published by Granta (£20). To support the Guardian and the Observer buy a copy atguardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian