‘Space travel is queer’: the unstoppable film-maker skewering Bezos and Musk’s macho fantasies

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Nelly Ben Hayoun-Stépanian Challenges Space Exploration Norms in New Film Doppelgängers³"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Nelly Ben Hayoun-Stépanian is a multi-talented artist and activist whose work challenges traditional power structures in the realm of space exploration. In her vibrant office, which is a converted tube carriage atop a nightclub, she draws inspiration from historical figures like Marie Curie and Hannah Arendt. Her innovative projects, such as the International Space Orchestra, which she co-founded in 2012, and the University of the Underground, reflect her commitment to redefining the narrative surrounding space and education. Ben Hayoun-Stépanian's latest film, Doppelgängers³, showcases her belief that current space exploration efforts, often driven by billionaires like Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos, perpetuate colonial and exploitative legacies. Through her work, she advocates for a more inclusive and diverse vision of the cosmos, arguing that space should not be viewed as a luxury but as a critical experiment for society's potential future.

Doppelgängers³, which explores themes of intergenerational trauma and the future of space, features a unique format where Ben Hayoun-Stépanian embarks on an “analogue mission” with her doppelgangers, Lucia and Myriam, to simulate a space journey. The film includes interviews with experts from various fields, highlighting the importance of diverse perspectives in shaping the future of space travel. Ben Hayoun-Stépanian emphasizes that the current discourse around space is lacking originality and inclusivity, as it primarily reflects the views of the wealthy elite. By intertwining humor with profound insights, she hopes to inspire audiences to rethink the possibilities of space exploration, advocating for a vision that is less patriarchal and more representative of various identities and experiences. With her dynamic approach, she aims to demonstrate that space is a shared frontier that requires collaboration and innovation from all sectors of society.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article presents an intriguing perspective on space travel through the lens of artist and activist Nelly Ben Hayoun-Stépanian. It critiques the traditional, often hyper-masculine narratives associated with figures like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk, while also promoting a more inclusive and creative dialogue about space exploration.

Purpose of the Article

The intent behind this article appears to be multifaceted. It seeks to highlight the work of Ben Hayoun-Stépanian as a counter-narrative to the dominant, corporate-driven visions of space travel. By positioning her as a creative force who challenges conventional power structures, the article advocates for a more diverse and imaginative approach to science and technology. It aims to inspire readers to think beyond the typical representations of space exploration, suggesting that art and creativity can play a crucial role in this field.

Public Perception and Messaging

The article aims to foster a perception of space travel that is more inclusive and less tied to traditional notions of masculinity. It portrays Ben Hayoun-Stépanian as a visionary who emphasizes collaboration, creativity, and the democratization of science. This suggests a deliberate effort to reshape the narrative around space exploration, making it more accessible and relevant to a broader audience, particularly marginalized communities.

Omissions and Hidden Agendas

While the piece celebrates creativity in science, it could be perceived as downplaying the technological and practical challenges associated with space exploration. There may be an implicit agenda to divert attention from the commercial motivations of space billionaires by focusing instead on artistic endeavors. This could lead to a skewed understanding of the complexities involved in actual space missions.

Manipulativeness and Credibility

The article carries a moderate level of manipulativeness, primarily through its emphatic tone and selective focus on certain aspects of space travel. By framing Ben Hayoun-Stépanian's work as a direct challenge to the established norms set by figures like Bezos and Musk, it encourages a specific emotional response from the audience. However, the credibility of the article is upheld by the reputable nature of its subject and the innovative projects she has undertaken.

Comparison with Other Coverage

In juxtaposition with other articles on space exploration, this one stands out by emphasizing artistic and cultural dimensions rather than purely technological advancements. It aligns more closely with narratives that advocate for social change and inclusivity, contrasting with the often profit-driven discussions surrounding the space industry.

Impact on Society and Economy

The article could potentially inspire movements advocating for a more inclusive approach to technology and science, which may result in greater public interest and investment in creative projects related to space. This could lead to shifts in how funds are allocated within the space sector, emphasizing innovation that prioritizes societal benefits over purely commercial outcomes.

Target Audience

The piece seems to resonate more with individuals who identify with progressive values, including artists, activists, and those interested in the intersection of science and culture. It likely aims to engage communities that feel alienated by the current narratives around space exploration.

Market Implications

While the article may not have a direct impact on stock markets, it highlights the growing interest in alternative approaches to space travel, which could influence future investments in related sectors. Companies that prioritize creativity and inclusivity in their endeavors may experience a rise in public support and funding.

Global Context and Relevance

In the context of today's discussions about equity and inclusivity, this article addresses pertinent issues that resonate widely. It contributes to ongoing dialogues about who gets to participate in and benefit from advancements in science and technology.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

It’s conceivable that AI tools might have been employed in crafting this article, particularly in generating engaging narratives or structuring the content. However, any such influence would likely be subtle, aiming to enhance readability and coherence without overtly altering the message.

Manipulative Elements

The language used in the article, with its emphasis on creativity and challenge against established norms, serves to inspire and motivate. However, this could also be construed as manipulative if it oversimplifies the complexities of space exploration and the motivations of key players in the industry.

The article is largely credible, drawing on the real achievements of Ben Hayoun-Stépanian and her contributions to the discussion around space travel. While it does introduce a more artistic perspective, it does so without straying too far from the truth of her work and its implications for broader societal conversations.

Unanalyzed Article Content

‘She’s a great inspiration,” says Nelly Ben Hayoun-Stépanian, picking up a photo she keeps in her wildly decorated office of the scientist Marie Curie, the first woman to win a Nobel prize and also the first person to win one twice. “I pick people that really inspire me. Partners in crime. When a project is difficult, I think, ‘What would Marie Curie have done? What wouldHannah Arendthave done?’ Hahaha.”

She talks mile-a-minute, finishing sentences with a laugh as she speaks to me in her office, which could well be the best one in London: an old, graffiti-covered tube carriage plonked on top of the roof of a Shoreditch nightclub, with views over the city. Its interior is loud and colourful: posters and flyers plaster the walls, while the floor is a trippy swirl of purples and pinks. And, propped up on her desk, is that photo of Curie.

Having done projects for Nasa, Porsche, Lego and Nike,Ben Hayoun-Stépanian’s role is artist, activist and creative directorall rolled into one. Not that she cares for labels: at a push, she will describe herself as a “designer of experiences”. In March, she installed a “cosmic playground” in London’s West End, placing asteroid-shaped rocks in Piccadilly Circus as well as giant inflatable fluorescent cats (not any old cats, but Schrödinger’s cats, for students of quantum physics). She has also sent heartbeats into space, bouncing them off the moon.

Ben Hayoun-Stépanian is fascinated by space and in 2012 co-founded an orchestra of scientists at Nasa. The InternationalSpaceOrchestra has performed with Sigur Rós, Beck and Damon Albarn. The idea behind it is typical of her mantra of “challenging power structures” and inspiring people to think differently. “The orchestra created a counterculture in Nasa. You have the head of Nasa playing the gong and a new astronaut playing percussion. They can speak about what went wrong in the space programme. Suddenly, they are having a conversation about why we are doing what we are doing.”

And don’t get her started on the education system. In 2017, frustrated with the status quo, she set up the University of the Underground. It’s a non-tuition-fee-paying university run from the basements of nightclubs (past lecturers include Pussy Riot and Noam Chomsky). She has also directed five feature films – the latest, Doppelgängers³, is being shown next week as part of the London incarnation of the SXSW (South by Southwest) festival. It may be difficult to pin down exactly what she does, but she does a lot.

Films do loom large, though. Ben Hayoun-Stépanian’s tube carriage is also an Aladdin’s cave of props from her films and projects. There’s a giant foam strawberry on one shelf, a comedy oversized telephone on another. And is that Barbie above the desk? “Yeah! That is me!” The Barbie is indeed a mini Ben Hayoun-Stépanian, wearing her trademark boilersuit and red lipstick. The toy manufacturer Mattel made her the doll after she consulted on itsI Can Be range of Barbieswhich gave the toys proper jobs. “This waswaybefore Barbie was considered cool,waybefore the Barbie film. These big companies – sometimes it’s hard for them to agitate from within. So they invite people like me. My whole work is also about representation, making sure voices are being heard.”

Ben Hayoun-Stépanian is entertaining company. But we are meant to be talking about Doppelgängers³, which explores the future of space. After working in the space industry, she has come to believe that we have learned nothing from history, that humans may be doomed to repeat the mistakes we made on Earth in space: the same old western exploitation, the same old colonialism. Take the billionaire space race. Elon Musk’s mission is to populate Mars with a human colony, while Jeff Bezos wants to move heavy polluting industries to space. “These two, their visions are getting the most media space. But I find they are problematic. And I find they are lacking originality.”

If space exploration is now the preserve of the 1%, Doppelgängers³ imagines a new vision: less heteronormative, less patriarchal. It’s a film pinging with so many ideas, I don’t know where to start, I say. She nods vigorously. “It’s polyphonic. That’s really the way my brain functions. It’s the way I do things. The idea that you could compartmentalise knowledge just doesn’t make sense to me. You can’t dissociate biology from physics or from literature or culture. All are parts of the same ecosystem, which is the cosmos!”

She adds: “Space, to me, is not a luxury. It’s not entertainment. It is a critical experiment – the ultimate test of what kinds of societies we are capable of imagining.”

Her film is very funny, funnier than it sounds on paper. Ben Hayoun-Stépanian travels the world talking to experts: she interviews pioneering astronomer Jill Tarter, a neurogeneticist, an economist, a transgender activist and a quantum physicist. Some conversations reach Louis Theroux heights of randomness. When she visits the political theorist Uday Singh Mehta, he rolls her up like a burrito in a massive rug on the floor. Nothing is scripted. “I don’t want to come with a preconceived idea of how things are going to go,” she explains. Besides, she can always tell when it’s time to leave: “I know when someone is going to throw me out.”

The film gets its name from the two doppelgangers Ben Hayoun-Stépanian hires to accompany her on an “analogue mission”, a practice run for space travel here on Earth. Her doppelgangers are Lucia, an Armenian, and Myriam, an Algerian. The three women travel to a cave in Spain to take part in a simulation of a space mission. Wearing cumbersome astronaut suits, gripping a rope handrail, they descend into the cave. The whole thing looks terrifying. “I’m so glad you could see that! I genuinely thought that was the most dangerous thing I’ve done in my life.”

The idea behind hiring doppelgangers was partly inspired by Ben Hayoun-Stépanian’s fascination with quantum physics. She is also interested in intergenerational trauma – how emotional pain can be transmitted from parent to child. Ben Hayoun-Stépanian is French, of Armenian and Algerian heritage; both countries have painful colonial histories. Her project resulted in the first academic paper on intergenerational trauma and decolonial futures in space.

Ben Hayoun-Stépanian grew up in Valence in south-eastern France. Her grandfather was a member of the committee of French Armenians who lobbied the French government to formally recognise theArmenian genocide of 1915-16. “I wasmaybe 13 or 14. I remember [the campaign] quite well.” It was only in recent years that she thought of her grandfather as an activist. She wonders if she was politicised by him. Growing up, the family had a textile business and her first degree (among many) was in textile design. She then moved to Tokyo, designing kimonos and making jewellery (a hit with Yakuza gangsters).

In Ben Hayoun-Stépanian’s mind, space exploration forces us to reimagine everything. “It’s queer. It’s decolonial. It’s pluralistic.” We need to let go of the binaries and borders, she says. Since her film premiered at Sundance last year, Donald Trump ordered Nasa to close its diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. “It’s devastating. You can’t just think of people as minorities. Actually, there is a direct value in bringing them into the room because, in space mission design, they bring a different way of functioning and thinking. I am making a case, which is a scientific case, for it.”

Pussy Riot contributed music to the film, and Ben Hayoun-Stépanian is friends with the band’s co-founderNadya Tolokonnikova. They met when they were both speaking at a conference. “These diplomat dudes were running after Nadya, like, ‘Oh my god, we want to take your picture.’ I was sitting next to her in my big black bomber jacket. They all thought I was her security. Nadya is a force to be reckoned with. For me, she is the definition of courage. Me, I risk power structures. I annoy them. But I never get to a point where I’m going to go in jail. I always work with lawyers. I know what I can do, what I cannot do. Nadya has been put in jail. It’s another level. I wouldn’t go that far, you know?”

I ask Ben Hayoun-Stépanian if she gets resistance walking into institutions such as Nasa looking as she does? “Always!” she says cheerily. “There is always a moment where when I arrive in the room and people are like, ‘Whatis this?’” Her look today is head-to-toe snakeskin print, huge hoop earrings and neon green nails. Is she comfortable with conflict? A nod. “There is always conflict, but conflict is part of the process. Conflict is never a state that remains.”

I ask her if there’s anything else I should ask. “I am turning 40 on 27 May. Haha. My mom told me to tell you this.” OK. And what about your next film? “Ha! My next film is even more mad.”

Doppelgängers³ screens on 2 and 7 June at Rich Mix, London, as part of SXSW.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian