South Korea’s female freedivers: TV has made stars of the haenyeo but what is their real story?

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"The Challenges and Cultural Significance of South Korea's Haenyeo Divers"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The haenyeo, or 'women of the sea,' are traditional female divers from Jeju Island, South Korea, who have been practicing their craft since the 17th century. Known for their sustainable fishing methods, these divers dive without breathing apparatus to collect shellfish and seaweed. However, the sustainability of their practices is now under threat, as environmental changes have led to a decline in seaweed, which is crucial for the abalone they harvest. Myeonghyo Go, a haenyeo and environmentalist, emphasizes the need for a new generation of divers to step forward, as the majority of current haenyeo are over 70 years old. Despite their cultural significance and recognition by UNESCO as an Intangible Cultural Heritage, Myeonghyo expresses concerns that media portrayals often overlook the depth of their experiences and struggles, reducing their rich tradition to mere entertainment. She highlights the importance of sharing their authentic stories, which encompass not only their diving practices but also their communal values and ecological awareness.

Amidst the rising fascination with Korean culture, fueled by the popularity of K-dramas and documentaries featuring haenyeo, Myeonghyo aims to harness this interest to promote ocean conservation and education. She envisions establishing a school to train individuals in ocean ecology and citizen science, advocating for a holistic understanding of the relationship between humans and marine life. Myeonghyo's commitment to sustainability is evident in her efforts to document environmental changes through her work with the Paran ocean citizen science center. As she navigates her own familial challenges, particularly the reluctance of her mother to see her continue the haenyeo tradition, Myeonghyo remains steadfast in her mission to protect the ocean and inspire future generations. Through communal practices and responsible harvesting, the haenyeo embody a unique model of coexistence with nature, while also facing the complexities of modern environmental issues and cultural representation.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article sheds light on the cultural significance and contemporary challenges faced by the haenyeo, traditional female divers from Jeju Island in South Korea. It intertwines their historical importance with modern struggles, presenting a nuanced view that contrasts the romanticized portrayals often seen in media, such as television dramas.

Cultural Representation vs. Reality

The piece emphasizes the disparity between the media's representation of haenyeo and their actual circumstances. While they are celebrated for their sustainable practices and recognized by UNESCO, the reality is that their numbers are dwindling, and many are elderly. This reflects a pressing concern for the preservation of their cultural heritage, which is often overshadowed by a simplified narrative that focuses on nostalgia rather than current issues.

Environmental Concerns

Myeonghyo Go, a haenyeo, articulates the environmental challenges that threaten their livelihood, specifically the declining seaweed populations essential for abalone. This highlights an urgent ecological crisis that is not only affecting the haenyeo but also broader marine ecosystems. The article aims to raise awareness of these environmental issues while advocating for a more authentic narrative around the haenyeo's life and work.

Future of the Haenyeo

The article suggests that the fascination with haenyeo, although positive in some respects, may not be conducive to their future. It hints at a need for a new generation of divers to step forward, raising questions about how to encourage younger women to embrace this tradition amidst changing environmental and social landscapes. It subtly critiques the romanticizing of their story and calls for a more comprehensive understanding of their current realities.

Public Perception and Community Support

By sharing Myeonghyo's discomfort with how their stories are told, the article invites readers to reflect on the broader implications of cultural commodification. It appeals to audiences who value environmental sustainability, cultural heritage, and social justice. The narrative is likely to resonate more with communities invested in these themes, such as environmental activists and cultural preservation advocates.

Potential Impacts

The article has the potential to influence public discourse around cultural heritage and environmental policies in South Korea. It may inspire actions to support the haenyeo community, such as programs aimed at training new divers or initiatives focused on marine conservation. Additionally, it could affect tourism strategies in Jeju, as visitors may seek more authentic experiences rather than superficial representations of the haenyeo.

Trustworthiness of the Article

The article appears to be reliable, as it incorporates quotes and perspectives from a haenyeo herself, providing an insider's viewpoint on the challenges faced by this community. The use of factual information regarding their cultural heritage and environmental issues adds to its credibility. However, it also raises questions about what narratives are left out, suggesting a potential bias in focusing on certain aspects of their lives.

In summary, while the article highlights the cultural significance and current challenges of the haenyeo, it also points to the need for a deeper understanding and support for these women in the face of environmental and societal changes.

Unanalyzed Article Content

There is an episode in the Netflix drama When Life Gives You Tangerines where a woman dives into the sea and brings back a catch of abalone (sea snails), which she says will feed her family. The woman is ahaenyeo. Haenyeo, or “women of the sea”, have been recorded as far back as the 17th century and are unique to the island of Jeju inSouth Korea, where they fish sustainably, diving time and again on a single breath to bring back shellfish and seaweed.

Yet the scene, set in the 1960s, simply wouldn’t happen today, says Myeonghyo Go, a haenyeo who lives in the village of Iho-dong on Jeju. “The seaweeds here are disappearing, and seaweed is the food for abalone. Because we don’t have the seaweeds, we don’t have abalone,” she says.

Myeonghyo is not only a haenyeo, she is a citizen scientist and environmentalist. In her 40s, she represents the new generation of Korea’s traditional divers and her mission is to change the way the women are seen by the outside world.

Haenyeo are one of the country’s most famous cultural exports, with Unesco officially inscribing their work on the representative list of theIntangible Cultural Heritage of Humanitybecause of their focus on sustainability. Yet their future is at a crossroads. Most of them now are over 70, so the national government and the Jeju authorities are keen for a new generation to come forward.

When the provincial government (Jeju is a self-governing province within Korea) made its application to Unescoit described how the haenyeo represent“the island’s character and people’s spirit”, yet Myeonghyo feels the resulting fascination with the haenyeo has not always been beneficial to the women’s future.

“I feel uncomfortable when stories about the haenyeo are shared,” she says. “They [those who are telling the stories] take everything that is really important out and only show certain aspects of our lives.”

She adds: “There is a famous haenyeo choir and if there’s an official event they are often invited to sing nice songs. But the haenyeo tradition of singing together started from when things became tiring and difficult [during work]. So our songs are not joyous, per se, and what you are seeing is not really authentic.”

The fascination with the haenyeo has peaked in the past few years as part ofthe frenzy over Korean culture, kicked off by the rise of K-pop. In 2022, another K-drama, Our Blues,also followed the lives of the sea women, and last year a documentary,The Last of the Sea Women, generated publicity for Apple TV. This month, the BBC will show the first programme it has made in Korea (in collaboration with broadcaster JTBC),Deep Dive Korea. It follows Korean model and actor Song Ji-hyo as she attempts to become a haenyeo.

Myeonghyo wants to use the popularity of the haenyeo to create a school to educate people about ocean ecology and create a team of citizen scientists.

“When I feel we [the haenyeo] are being used, it used to make me feel quite lonely,” she says. “Then I started to change my mind and think, can I use this interest to tell the real story instead? For me, that is a story that draws on a long tradition of protecting the weak, both in our community and in the natural world.”

She says that the haenyeo have a tradition calledhalmeoni bada, which translates as Grandma ocean. It is a designated area of shallow water where the oldest haenyeo go and catch. “So we have this way of caring for elderly people and the weak,” she says. “And then we have communal diving days once or twice a month, where whatever we catch we divide equally between all the haenyeo, regardless of age or experience.”

The haenyeo also work with the ocean when they fish, so they don’t dive during a shellfish’s breeding season, for example, but harvest seaweed instead. They also avoid catching conch if they are smaller than 7cm to give the species a chance to reproduce before being harvested.

“We survive on collecting and selling the seafood, but we are also protecting them,” she says. “We show how humans and nature can coexist.”

Myeonghyo volunteers with theParan ocean citizen science centre, a relatively new local NGO that employs citizen science to document the changes in the seas around Jeju and uses the information to lobby the government for enhanced marine protection.

She needed to be taught to dive with scuba gear to document the ocean flora, and since doing so says she has noticed large, hard corals appearing alongside Jeju’s traditional soft corals. These are more typically found in tropical waters and have only started appearing in such numbers in the past five years when the water temperature around the south side of Jeju has risen markedly,reaching a new record high last year,according to data from the National Institute of Fisheries Science. The same area has also experienced a sharp decline in seaweed, outbreaks of jellyfish and green algae, and the melting of soft corals.

Sanghoon Yoon, an adviser at Paran, whose mother was a haenyeo, says the older generation are not always keen to raise their voices about the environment. “Yet the ocean is changing rapidly and they are the first ones to witness those changes and so when we go and talk to them on a one-to-one basis, they start to open their hearts more. My hope is that the younger generation will lead on this change in what the haenyeo stand for.”

Before she can start on the rest of the world, however, Myeonghyo has a challenge to tackle closer to home – her mum.

Sixty-nine-year-old Chunsuk Son became a haenyeo at 17, following in the footsteps of her mother, but she doesn’t see why her daughter has to do the same.

“When I educated her, I wanted her to have a proper job like joining the civil service,” she says. “We older women don’t want our daughters to be haenyeo,but Myeonghyo keeps saying that she wants to be one in order to protect the ocean and to help to make where we live a better place. I know she has a different aim [as a haenyeo] and a different direction. In any case, she doesn’t listen to me.”

Additional reporting byEunhae Grace Jung

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian