‘Scratch the earth, there’s gold!’: small miners, big firms and armed gangs fight over Peru’s mineral wealth

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Violence Erupts Over Gold Mining in Northern Peru Amid Rising Prices"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In the mountainous region of northern Peru, a violent struggle for gold has intensified as prices surge to unprecedented levels, exceeding $3,000 per ounce. This conflict involves a complex web of criminal gangs, illegal miners, and established mining corporations, particularly the prominent company Poderosa. The situation reached a critical point in May when the bodies of thirteen security workers were discovered, bound and tortured, within a network of tunnels owned by Poderosa. In response to this horrific incident, the Peruvian government declared a month-long ban on gold mining, restricting operations to Poderosa alone while deploying military and police forces to enforce order in the province. However, the ban has not quelled the violence; locals recount a history of brutal confrontations and the forced disappearances of many miners, highlighting the perilous conditions that have emerged in Pataz, a region rich in gold resources but plagued by lawlessness.

The conflict has not only disrupted the mining industry but has also sparked protests among artisanal miners who argue that government actions are infringing on their rights to work. José Torrealva, a leader of the artisanal mining community, passionately defends their role in the local economy, asserting that small miners are essential for the survival of their families. Despite the government's formalization efforts, only a small fraction of miners have successfully registered, leaving many to operate outside the law. The influx of criminal elements during the COVID-19 pandemic has further complicated the landscape, as gangs take advantage of the economic desperation and the rising gold prices. While Poderosa has attempted to enhance security in response to the violence, the pervasive influence of organized crime continues to threaten the lives of miners and their families, leaving a trail of devastation in its wake. The tragic impact of this conflict is felt deeply, as families grapple with loss and uncertainty amid the ongoing struggle for control over Peru's mineral wealth.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The situation in northern Peru regarding gold mining is both alarming and complex, reflecting broader issues of violence, illegal activities, and the struggle for resources. The article sheds light on the escalating conflict among various stakeholders, including small miners, large companies, and armed gangs, all vying for control over lucrative gold deposits.

Conflict and Violence

The discovery of the bodies of 13 security workers serves as a shocking reminder of the brutality underlying this conflict. This incident not only highlights the dangers faced by those involved in mining but also raises questions about the effectiveness of government intervention. The government's response, imposing a ban on gold mining while sending in military personnel, suggests an attempt to regain control but also reflects the severity of the situation. The ongoing violence points to a deeper issue of lawlessness and the presence of organized crime in the region.

Public Perception and Awareness

The framing of this conflict aims to create awareness about the dangers of illegal mining and the involvement of criminal gangs. By detailing the violent confrontations and the horrific fate of individuals caught in the crossfire, the article seeks to evoke a sense of urgency and concern among readers. This can lead to greater public pressure on the government to take more decisive action against such violence.

Potential Omissions

While the article effectively highlights the violence and chaos, it may obscure the motivations and conditions of the small miners who are often portrayed as victims. This could lead to a narrative that simplifies complex socio-economic dynamics, potentially diverting attention from underlying issues such as poverty, lack of regulation, and the influence of larger corporate interests.

Comparative Context

In comparing this article with others on similar topics, there may be recurring themes about resource conflicts and the impact of global commodity prices. Reports from other mining regions often illustrate similar struggles, suggesting a pattern of violence and exploitation in resource-rich areas worldwide. This connection helps to contextualize the situation in Peru within a global framework of resource management and conflict.

Socio-Economic and Political Implications

The article’s revelations could have significant repercussions for local and national politics, potentially influencing policies related to mining regulations and law enforcement. In the short term, the increased visibility of violence may lead to stricter controls on mining activities or, conversely, to a crackdown on illegal mining that could further marginalize small miners.

Target Audience

The narrative likely resonates more with communities concerned about human rights, environmental issues, and economic justice. Activists, environmental organizations, and those interested in the socio-political landscape of Latin America may find this article particularly compelling.

Market Impact

On a broader scale, this news could influence global gold prices and mining stocks, especially those associated with operations in Peru. Investors might react to the instability by reassessing the risks associated with mining ventures in the region, potentially affecting share prices of companies like Poderosa.

Geopolitical Considerations

The conflict over gold in Peru reflects larger trends of resource competition that resonate in today's political climate, especially in the context of climate change and sustainable development debates. This situation may impact international relations, particularly if foreign investments are affected by rising tensions and instability.

Use of AI in Crafting the Article

While it is unclear if AI was specifically used for writing the article, certain elements like data gathering or trend analysis could have been assisted by AI technologies. If AI were involved, it might have influenced the article's tone or focus by emphasizing violent incidents or the economic implications of gold mining.

Overall, the credibility of the article hinges on its detailed account of violent incidents and the socio-economic conditions surrounding mining in Peru. However, the potential lack of nuanced perspectives on all stakeholders involved suggests a need for caution in interpreting the full scope of the situation.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Deep in the mountains of northernPeru, a bloody war is being fought over gold. As its international price sets successive record highs above $3,000 (£2,220) an ounce, criminal gangs, illegal miners and established mining companies battle over the metal.

The conflict is not fought out in the open but in a maze of tunnels that stretch for miles inside the mountains of Pataz, a gold-rich Andean province about 130 miles (200km) inland from Peru’s third city, Trujillo. In early May, the bodies of13 security workers were found shot dead, their hands bound and some showing signs of torture, in one of the tunnels belonging to an artisanal miner linked to the province’s largestmining company, Poderosa.

After the gruesome discovery, the government imposed a month-long ban on goldmining for all but the company andsent hundreds of soldiers and police officersto enforce a state of emergency and a nightly curfew in the province.

Yet, the massacre of the security contractors, who had been hired to expel intruders, was just the most visible example of the brutal violence which, locals say, has left countless dead, many of them forcibly “disappeared” under rocks and rubble in a labyrinth of 450 subterranean tunnels.

Five hundred metres inside one mineshaft, three men armed with military-grade guns emerge from the gloom to speak to the Guardian.

“We are living moments of terror,” says the group’s leader. “Many confrontations; manycompañeros[comrades] gone,” he admits when asked about how many gun battles he had fought as the violence surged in recent years.

The armed gang’s job is to steal mines from small miners or recover mines stolen from their employer and wrest back control, he says. Underground gunfights are inevitable and attacks can come from all sides as armed men known asparquerossteal ore – the gold-bearing rock – by tunnelling in from connecting shafts or invading the mine from other entrances. The gangs burn tyres and pump smoke into the tunnels to drive out miners. Or they attack the security guards, as when the 13 men were killed.

One guard, his face masked by a green mining helmet pulled low over his head, rests his right hand rests on an AR-15 semi-automatic rifle. “We’re a family,” he says, nodding at his companions in rubber boots and bulletproof vests as water drips from the rocky roof of the tunnel.

He does not know much about the international gold price but, as a former soldier, he knows he earns more as a gunman than as a miner – and much more than if he worked back in Trujillo. “We have the training,” he says.

“I do get scared,” he admits, but the monthly wage means he can support his five young children. “It’s all for gold. Pataz has wealth, which generates violence, so they hire us.”

“Your life is worth more than gold,” reads one placard. “Without artisanal mining, many families don’t eat,” reads another. They are being displayed by families in a well-organised protest against the government’s suspension of all but Poderosa’s mining in Pataz.

For more than four decades, Poderosa has leased a mining concession from the government that encompasses much of the province.

Geologically, Pataz is shot through with gold-rich veins of quartz and pyrite in abruptly steep mountains, peppered with hundreds of mineshafts.

“It’s a blessing,” shouts José Torrealva, president of Pataz’s artisanal mining association, in a fiery, crowd-stirring speech to the hundreds of families assembled on the town’s football pitch. “Where you scratch the earth, there’s gold!”

Torrealva, whom prosecutors are investigating for allegedly mining illegally, is a firebrand advocate of what he calls “artisanal” mining. “Who drives the economy in Pataz? We, the small miners, do,” he cries to cheers from the townsfolk.

“They are taking away our fundamental right to work. They are making laws to ‘disappear’ the artisanal miner,” says Torrealva, who owns companies that provide explosives and truck hundreds of tonnes of ore out of Pataz to refineries on the coast.

Only those on a register of informal miners purportedly in the process of formalisation – known by its acronym Reinfo – can sell gold to Poderosa.

In more than a decade, only2% of more than 84,000 miners registeringhave completed the formalisation process, which requires them to pay tax and employ clean mining techniques.

Earlier this month, the government removed1,425 miners in Pataz from the Reinfo registry, meaning they can no longer sell their ore to Poderosa nor operate legally.

Still, mining without a state permit is common. Many miners, such as Brandon Saldaña, 29, resent that his employer is not considered fully legal, even though he pays a team of miners.

“Everybody criminalises us, saying we’re illegal, but it’s not like that. They put everybody in the same bag,” he says as he sits with his fellow miners inside a shaft, smoking and chewing coca leaves laced with lime from a gourd. “Sometimes the informal miner lacks just one document to become formal.”

The bureaucratic process is slow and frustrating. Some of Saldaña’s friends earn more working illegally for one of the many criminal gangs, from local gangstersLa Gran FamiliaandLos Pulposto the VenezuelanTren de Araguathat have taken over mineshafts.

Sign up toGlobal Dispatch

Get a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development team

after newsletter promotion

The invasion of criminals and outsiders started during the Covid-19 pandemic when poverty rocketed, law enforcement was focused on lockdowns and the price of gold surged to more than twice pre-Covid levels.

Delmatia Jaime, 80, wishes her home town, Pataz, could return to its former tranquillity. “Life here has changed completely,” she says. “There is no trust or security. So many people disappear; every day there is death.”

Perched on a mountainside with a white colonial church in its plaza, the narrow streets of this once-typical Andean village are now choked with brand-new 4x4s.

Poderosa, an $8bn mining company, says it had no affiliation with the 13 men killed in April. But the victims worked for R&R, an unregistered company affiliated withLibmar, a firm owned by the miner Nicolás Cueva. His company sold ore to Poderosa, which buys from about 280 registered artisanal miners in the province, processes the gold on site and sells it to Canada, Japan and Switzerland.

Cueva told the local pressthat Libmar spent 80,000to 100,000 soles (£16,000-£20,000) a month on security. He also said his company was providing support to the victims’ families.

Since the incident, Poderosa has hired 1,200 security guards, according to Pablo de la Flor, the company’s corporate affairs manager. “That is two security guards for every miner,” he says. “Despite that, it has been impossible to control this spate of violence.”

The organised crime networks behind the gangs ofparqueros, who steal the ore, have impressive resources, says De la Flor. It’s a “risky investment” requiring heavy machinery, geologists, mining engineers, hitmen and inside information.

“In some cases, they drill tunnels that are 2km long, costing $2,000 to $2,800 a metre, so somebody is financing that operation.”

Hundreds more miners who do not sell to Poderosa fuel a multibillion-dollar illicit trade in gold ore. In the last four years,33,708 trucks loaded with 674,160 tons of ore, worth $3.5bn, left Pataz and passed police checkpoints to any one of four dozen crushing plants in a maze of industrial lots in Trujillo, according to the mining company’s data.

Once crushed, lorries transport it to refineries near Lima. The ingots are then shipped principally to India and the United Arab Emirates – importers with laxer standards of due diligence compared with Canada and Switzerland.

In a statement to the Guardian, Poderosa expressed “sincere condolences to the families” and said to be “in permanent communication with Libmar so that the affected families receive the necessary support”.

But Paty Carranza, 23, the widow of Frank Monzón, one of the 13 murdered men, says she has received nothing from Poderosa. She has been receiving anonymous threatening phone calls urging her to remain silent.

Her three-year-old daughter still does not know her father is never coming home.

“I haven’t found the courage to tell her,” Carranza says. “She keeps asking: ‘Where is Daddy? When is he taking us to the beach?”

Carranza is on the second floor of a half-built breeze-block home in El Porvenir, a tough neighbourhood in Trujillo. Monzón was earning a little more than $1,000 a month, more than he could dream of making in the city, and the money paid for their home to be built. “‘Your hubby has money. You’ll want for nothing,’ he used to joke,” Carranza recalls.

In May, the suspected leader of the attackers, Miguel Antonio Rodríguez Díaz, alias“Cuchillo”, was captured in Colombia. The ex-soldier was jailed for three years on pre-trial detention while prosecutors prepared charges of organised crime, contract killing, aggravated homicide and money laundering.

“I can’t get my head around how [the attackers] could have been so brutal,” says Carranza. Her partner’s body was intact save for a gunshot in the back of the neck, but other bodies at the morgue showed signs of torture: broken jawbones, chests opened up, missing arms, legs, some with a head or testicles missing.

“Many people are dead inside those mines; they go inside and are never seen again,” she says. “They sacrifice people for what? To get more gold? It is as if they need blood; that’s what they did with my husband.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian