Independent and organicfarmerssay chaos created by theTrump administration’s cuts have hurt their businesses, even as the US health secretary,Robert F Kennedy Jr, praises small farms and regenerative agriculture.
The split-screen for small and organic farms – which one described as “talking out of both sides of their mouth” – comes on the heels of the release of the“Maha” report. The White House document mentions farms, farmers and farming 21 times, and argues conventional agriculture has led to more ultra-processed foods.
“Reading that report it’s like a small-scale organic farmers dream,” said Seth Kroeck, the owner of Crystal Spring Farm, as he slammed the door on his 1993 F350 truck. He talked about the report from his 331-acre organic farm in Brunswick, Maine. “But then at the same time, [secretary of agriculture] Brooke Rollins’s name is on this – she’s proposing to cut two-thirds of the agriculture budget.”
Kroeck just finished planting 2,500 Brussels sprouts and one-tenth of an acre of specialty peppers. He still needed to fix a flat on a piece of farm equipment that day. He said small-scale farmers have promoted local, organic and whole foods for decades.
While Kroeck is presumably the kind of farmer Kennedy would laud, all Kroeck finds is frustration with the administration, and actions that will “undoubtedly” make food more expensive.
“We’re dealing with two personalities with our government,” said Kroeck.
As conventional farmersdecrythe Maha report’s criticism of agricultural chemicals such as atrazine and glyphosate (the active ingredient in RoundUp), someorganic and independent farmershave found that the meager government support they depend on have been upended by an administration that claims it wants to support them.
“Farmers are the backbone of America – and the most innovative and productive in the world,” the report, led by Kennedy, argued. “We continue to feed the world as the largest food exporter. The greatest step the United States can take to reverse childhood chronic disease is to put whole foods produced by American farmers and ranchers at the center of healthcare.”
But by March, the administration had already cut a total of $1bn in programs that supported small farms that grow locally produced fruits and vegetables. For instance, they cut aprogramthat helped tribal food banks provide healthy food and ended a$660m programthat broughtfresh local foods to school cafeterias. In just one example of impact, the cut quickly endedfruit and vegetablesnacks in New York City schools.
“This is a huge deal for small farmers,” Ellee Igoe told theNew Ledepublication in March. Igoe is a co-owner ofSolidarity Farmin southern California. “We’re growing healthy food and providing it to local communities. And they are cancelling contracts without real reason. Out here, it feels like it is very politically motivated.”
In just one example of direct impact to Kroeck, the Trump administration fired most of the staffers at Kroeck’s local Natural Resources Conservation Service(NRCS) office, an arm of the US Department of Agriculture that provides technical assistance to farmers, including on-site visits. The staff shrank from six to one – only the director remains.
“In my book, she’s a super woman, but how long is that going to last?” said Kroeck. “And what farmer is going to want to take on new contracts when it’s going to take her months and months and months just to return a call?”
Kroeck also criticized the Maha report for including apparentlyinvented scientific references.
“The citations in the report seem to be made up by ChatGPT – this is crazy,” said Kroeck, who said he’s not a cheerleader for occupants of ivory towers, but “we do have to have some standards.”
Groups such as theOrganic Trade Associationhave largely echoed Kroeck’s sentiments, noting that this is what the organic movement has been saying all along and they need money.
“We’ve long known that health begins on the farm and encourage the administration to invest in meaningful policies that expand access to organic for consumers,” said co-CEO Matthew Dillon in a statement to the Guardian.
While some organic farmers say their relationship with the government has always been tenuous, small farmers say chaos has only worsened that relationship. Coastal wild blueberry farmer Nicolas Lindholm said at least a portion of the funding he was expecting for the year – to mulch his blueberries with wood chips – was “dead in the water”.
“My wife and I have an organic wild blueberry farm here on the coast of Maine,” said Lindholm.
“Over the past five months, we had applied for three different funding programs – all different – and finalized them through December and into January – and as of February all three of them were basically frozen.” Like many farmers, Lindholm’s needs were time sensitive: blueberries can only be mulched every two years because of their growing cycle.
In addition to direct cuts by the administration, congressional Republicans proposed cuts to food programs that indirectly benefit farmers. House Republicans passed a bill proposing$300bn in cutsto food stamps, or the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Snap), to fund tax cuts. They have also proposed cuts to a food program that helpsnew mothers and babiesbuy fruits and vegetables.
The panic within conventional agriculture communities has also been pronounced – with pointed criticism of the report coming before it was even published. Corn and soybeans dominate American cash crops, accounting for $131.9bn inreceipts in 2023, versus just $54.8bn in allfruits, vegetables and nuts combined.
“It’s no secret you were involved inpesticide litigationbefore you became secretary,” said Cindy Hyde-Smith, a Republican senator for Mississippi, leading into a question about the need for glyphosate (the active ingredient in RoundUp), and asking if Kennedy could be impartial.
Kennedy, who went on to pledge he would not put “a single farmer” out of business, said: “There’s nobody that has a greater commitment to the American farmer than we do – the Maha movement collapses if we can’t partner with the American farmer.”