Palestine Action documentary makers fear being criminalised under anti-terror laws

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Documentary Makers Express Concerns Over Criminalization Amid Palestine Action Proscription"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The creators of the documentary 'To Kill a War Machine,' which focuses on the actions of the protest group Palestine Action, are expressing concerns about potential criminalization under new anti-terror laws in the UK. The Home Office has announced plans to proscribe Palestine Action, which conducts direct actions against Israeli arms manufacturers, following a high-profile incident where activists vandalized military planes at RAF Brize Norton. If the proscription order is passed by Parliament, it would make it illegal to support or be a member of the group, with severe penalties including up to 14 years in prison. The filmmakers, Hannan Majid and Richard York, have expedited the online release of their film due to these developments, fearing that their distribution efforts might breach counter-terrorism laws. They are now seeking urgent legal guidance to navigate this complex situation.

The documentary, which showcases Palestine Action's activities through real-time footage and interviews with activists, has garnered significant attention since its early release. However, the filmmakers are now grappling with uncertainty regarding the legality of their upcoming screenings across the UK. Majid and York, who have been producing human rights-focused documentaries for over a decade, are worried that this situation could lead to the UK becoming the only country where their film cannot be shown. They have received positive feedback and support on social media, but the pressure to adapt their distribution plans is mounting. Discussions are underway with distributors in both the UK and the US, yet they are aware that international distribution may also be jeopardized if the film is perceived as supportive of a proscribed group. The filmmakers are contemplating whether to withdraw their submissions from various international film festivals, further complicating their efforts to share their work with a global audience.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The makers of an award-winning documentary about Palestine Action say they fear they will be criminalised if they continue distributing the work after the group is banned under anti-terror laws.

The online release ofTo Kill a War Machinewas brought forward to this week after it emerged that the Home Office was going to proscribe the protest group, which takes direct action against Israeli arms companies in the UK.

The home secretary, Yvette Cooper,announced planson Monday days after activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire and spray-painted two military planes red.

A draft of a proscription order against Palestine Action will be presented to parliament on Monday. If passed, the ban would become law, making it illegal to become a member of the group or invite support for it, with penalties of up to 14 years in prison.

Since Tuesday, the documentary about their activities has been downloaded by people all over the world, but its directors have been scrambling to take legal advice and fear they will end up being in breach of counter-terror laws if they continue distributing it.

Showings of the film have been lined up across Britain in the coming days and weeks – from gatherings in homes through to screenings at cinemas – but there are now doubts about what proscription will mean for this too.

Its London-based directors, Hannan Majid and Richard York, said they were concerned that Britain could end up being the only country in the world where people would not be able to see the film.

“We’ve operated around the world and have a lot of experience of regimes telling us what we can and can’t do. We’ve had authorities in Bangladesh telling us we shouldn’t even be editing footage of garment workers and activists advocating for their rights, and we’ve been followed by the police in Cambodia, but we have never encountered anything like this in Britain,” said Majid.

He and York have been working together since 2006 through their production company, Rainbow Collective, on documentaries that focus on human rights and have collaborated with organisations including Amnesty International.

To Kill a War Machine was the product of more than six months of work and was made independently of Palestine Action, while using real-time bodycam and phone footage that the group had put into the public domain.

Activists are shown smashing and occupying weapons factories in the UK and explaining their motivation for actions they view as legitimate to take in the face of alleged war crimes in Gaza. There are interviews with two activists from Palestine Action, Sohail Sultan and Joe Irving, both of whom were acquitted of charges of causing criminal damage.

However, the move to proscribe Palestine Action means there are now question marks over ​the documentary ​a​nd events including a London premiere on 18 July.

“We set out to make this film in a completely legitimate and legal manner, as we have done with other films. It’s been certified by the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) and it is good to go but now we are being advised that the curtailing of Palestine Action could have a major knock-on effect for us as it could become not only illegal for others to voice support for them but also for us, as film-makers, to distribute this film,” said York.

“People are still excited and there has been a tremendous outpouring of support on social media. Hopefully we can still go ahead with much of our plans, but we have had to rush things forward and do the digital release this week rather than waiting for September and try to build on the awards we have already picked up. That all changed on Monday night and there has been a spike as soon as we put it online,” said Majid.

The film-makers are having discussions with distributors in the UK and the US but are alive to the risks.

“On the basis of some of our legal advice, we may not even be able to distribute it in other countries and territories if the film is seen as being somehow in support of a group which is proscribed. We are still hoping to be able to show it in cinemas within the law,” said York.

They are also considering whether they will have to withdraw submissions for a range of international film festivals. It is part of the Zanzibar international film festival this week.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian