Outrage as DHS moves to restrict lawmaker visits to detention centers

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"DHS Requires 72-Hour Notice for Lawmaker Visits to Detention Centers"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.2
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has issued new guidance requiring lawmakers to provide 72 hours' notice prior to visiting detention centers. This move follows a series of contentious visits by Democratic lawmakers to these facilities amidst heightened scrutiny of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) actions during the Trump administration. Recent visits have resulted in lawmakers being turned away or even arrested, prompting significant backlash against ICE's management of these visits. While lawmakers are allowed to inspect DHS facilities used for detaining individuals, the new directive alters previous language which had assured compliance with oversight visits. The updated guidance states that while ICE will make every effort to comply with the law, various operational conditions may affect the timing of entry into the facilities, creating concerns about transparency and accountability in immigration enforcement practices.

In response to the updated guidance, Democratic lawmakers have vocally criticized the DHS's actions. Bennie Thompson, a Mississippi representative and ranking member of the House Committee on Homeland Security, condemned the policy as an unconstitutional attempt to obstruct congressional oversight of ICE facilities. He asserted that these changes are a smokescreen to deny access to ICE offices that are detaining migrants and, at times, U.S. citizens. Recent incidents involving lawmakers, such as the arrest of New Jersey representative LaMonica McIver during a facility visit and the forceful removal of California senator Alex Padilla at a press conference, have intensified outrage among Democratic lawmakers. These events highlight the broader implications of the DHS's new guidance on congressional oversight and the ongoing tension surrounding immigration enforcement in the United States. Lawmakers are increasingly asserting their right to conduct oversight, emphasizing the need for transparency in facilities funded by taxpayer dollars, while the DHS's new restrictions raise alarms about accountability in immigration policy enforcement.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The US Department of Homeland Security is now requiring lawmakers to provide 72 hours of notice before visiting detention centers, according to new guidance.

The guidance comes after a slew of tense visits from Democratic lawmakers to detention centers amid Donald Trump’s crackdowns in immigrant communities across the country. Many Democratic lawmakers in recent weeks have either been turned away, arrested or manhandled by law enforcement officers at the facilities, leading to public condemnation towards Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s (Ice) handling of such visits.

Lawmakers are allowed to access DHS facilities “used to detain or otherwise house aliens” for inspections and are not required “to provide prior notice of the intent to enter a facility”,according tothe 2024 Federal Appropriations Act.

Previous language surrounding lawmaker visits to such facilities said that “Ice will comply with the law and accommodate members seeking to visit/tour an Ice detention facility for the purpose of conducting oversight,” CNNreported.

However, in the new guidance, the DHS updated the language to say that Ice “will make every effort to comply with the law” but “exigent circumstances (e.g,m operational conditions, security posture, etc.) may impact the time of entry into the facility”.

The new guidance also attempts to distinguish Ice field offices from Ice detention facilities, noting that since “Ice field offices are not detention facilities” they do not fall under the visitation requirements laid out in the Appropriations Act.

The Guardian has contacted Ice for comment.

In response to the updated guidance, Mississippi’s Democratic representative and the ranking member of the House committee on homeland security, Bennie Thompson, condemned what he called the attempt by the homeland security secretary, Kristi Noem, to “block oversight on Ice”.

“Kristi Noem’s new policy to block congressional oversight of Ice facilities is not only unprecedented, it is an affront to the constitution and federal law. Noem is now not only attempting to restrict when members can visit, but completely blocking access to Ice field offices – even if members schedule visits in advance,” Thompsonsaid.

“This unlawful policy is a smokescreen to deny member visits to Ice offices across the country, which are holding migrants – and sometimes even US citizens – for days at a time. They are therefore detention facilities and are subject to oversight and inspection at any time. DHS pretending otherwise is simply their latest lie.”

Last month, the New Jersey representative LaMonica McIver waschargedwith assaulting federal agents during a visit to a detention facility in Newark alongside two Democratic members of the state’s congressional delegation. McIvercalledthe charges against her “purely political … and are meant to criminalize and deter legislative oversight”.

New Jersey’s governor, Phil Murphy, also condemned the charges, saying it was “outrageous for a congresswoman to be criminally charged for exercising her lawful duty to visit a detention site in her own district”.

On the day of McIver’s visit, law enforcement alsoarrestedthe mayor of Newark, Ras Baraka, who they charged with trespassing as he attempted to join McIver’s delegation visit. The charges against Baraka were later dropped and Baraka has sincefiled a lawsuitagainst the state’s top federal prosecutor over his arrest.

Bonnie Watson Coleman, another New Jersey representative who was part of McIver’s visit, rejected the DHS’s claims that the lawmakers assaulted law enforcement officers.

“The idea that I could ‘body slam’ anyone, let alone an ICE agent, is absurd,” the 80-year old representativesaidon X last month, adding: “We have an obligation to perform oversight at facilities paid for with taxpayer dollars.”

Earlier this month, law enforcement officers forced the California senator Alex Padilla on to the ground as he attempted to ask a question to Noem during a press conference in Los Angeles.

Despite repeatedly identifying himself, Padilla washandcuffedand forced into the hallway before law enforcement officers shoved the two-term US senator chest-first on to the floor. Following the incident which triggered widespreadoutrageacross both Democratic and Republican lawmakers, Noem said she did not recognize the two-term senator and claimed that he did not request a meeting with her. The two then reportedly met for 15 minutes after the incident.

On Tuesday, the Illinois representatives Raja Krishnamoorthi and Jonathan Jackson were denied entry during their attempted visit to an Ice facility in Chicago.

Posting on X, Krishnamoorthiwrote: “Families are worried about their loved ones who have been detained here. Immigrants throughout Illinois are living in fear. So @rep_jackson and I went to the facility today to try to get some answers. But shortly after we arrived, Ice called CPD, accused us of trespassing, and told us to leave the premises. Ice is trying to prevent us from doing our congressional oversight duties.”

That same day, the New York City comptroller and mayoral candidate, Brad Lander, was forcibly arrested by multiple federal agents and detained for hours as he tried to accompany a Spanish-speaking immigrant out of a courtroom. The DHS claimed Lander “was arrested for assaulting law enforcement and impeding a federal officer”, an accusation Lander denies.

Following his release, New York’s governor, Kathy Hochul,calledhis arrest “bullshit” and said that the charges against Lander had been dropped.

A day later, the New York representatives Dan Goldman and Jerry Nadler were refused entry into Ice detention facilities in Manhattan’s 26 Federal Plaza, despite requesting a visit in advance via letter, the Cityreports.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian