‘No one’s buying anything now’: how tariffs are striking a blow to historic Chinatowns

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Tariffs on Chinese Imports Threaten the Viability of Historic Chinatowns"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.8
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The recent increase in tariffs on Chinese imports has severely impacted businesses in historic Chinatowns across the United States, particularly in Los Angeles. Amy Tran, owner of Yue Wa Market, a grocery and herbal medicine shop, has had to raise retail prices due to increased costs from her distributor, which has further strained her already struggling business. Many of her customers, primarily low-income Chinese seniors, now find it increasingly difficult to afford basic goods. Tran has experienced no profit for three years and is contemplating raising prices on her other imported products as well. The tariffs, which have risen to as much as 145%, are part of a broader trade war initiated by the Trump administration, threatening the viability of immigrant-run businesses that rely heavily on these imports. This situation reflects a larger trend affecting Chinatowns nationwide, where shop owners face compounded financial challenges from the pandemic and declining foot traffic due to closures of long-standing establishments.

The implications of these tariffs extend beyond just financial burdens; they threaten the very fabric of Chinatown communities. Robert Lee, who runs a jewelry and antiques shop, noted that the tariffs not only impact his ability to import goods but also reduce demand for his products among customers looking to export antiques back to China. Community experts highlight that Chinatowns serve as essential support systems for low-income families and seniors, providing affordable goods and services. As these businesses falter, the risk of losing cultural heritage and community identity grows. Gentrification and demographic shifts further complicate the landscape, with wealthier residents moving in while traditional businesses struggle to survive. The combination of tariffs, economic downturns, and changing demographics presents a dire outlook for these historic neighborhoods, which are vital to the cultural and economic well-being of their communities.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article reveals the impact of recent tariffs on Chinese imports, particularly on small businesses in historic Chinatowns across the United States. It highlights the struggles faced by immigrant-run shops, emphasizing how these tariffs are pushing many to the brink of financial collapse. This narrative underscores broader economic tensions between the U.S. and China, particularly in the context of small business sustainability.

Economic Strain on Small Businesses

The story of Amy Tran illustrates the direct financial burden imposed by increased tariffs. The increase in wholesale prices forces her to raise retail prices, which alienates her primary customer base of low-income Chinese seniors. This situation reflects a larger trend where immigrant-run businesses, which are often reliant on specific imports, face existential threats due to foreign policy decisions. The article portrays these businesses not just as economic entities but as community hubs that are essential for cultural identity.

Public Sentiment and Community Impact

By focusing on individual stories, the article aims to evoke empathy from readers. It paints a picture of a struggling community, thereby fostering a sense of urgency about the implications of these tariffs. The narrative encourages readers to consider the human aspect of economic policies, suggesting that the current trade war may have far-reaching consequences beyond mere numbers.

Potential Underlying Messages

While the article does not explicitly suggest any hidden agendas, the focus on the struggles of these businesses may serve to critique the broader trade policies of the U.S. government. By highlighting the negative impacts on vulnerable communities, it subtly questions the fairness of these tariffs and their long-term viability. The emphasis on immigrant experiences may also aim to rally support for more favorable trade policies or community aid.

Comparative Context

When compared to other news articles on trade and tariffs, this piece stands out by centering on personal narratives rather than political analysis. This focus on individual impact can resonate more deeply with the audience, drawing attention to the socio-economic repercussions of government decisions. It connects with ongoing discussions about the consequences of the U.S.-China trade relationship, especially in light of the pandemic’s economic fallout.

Broader Economic and Political Implications

The article indicates that the ongoing trade war could exacerbate existing vulnerabilities within small business sectors, potentially leading to increased unemployment and economic instability in these communities. If these businesses continue to falter, it could spark broader discussions about the need for more sustainable and equitable trade practices.

Target Audience

The article appears to target readers who are empathetic towards immigrant communities, likely appealing to those interested in social justice and economic equity. It may also resonate with consumers who value supporting local businesses, particularly those rooted in cultural heritage.

Market Influence and Economic Outlook

This report could potentially influence market perceptions, especially regarding stocks of companies involved in imports and exports. Businesses that depend heavily on Chinese goods might see fluctuations in their stock values as concerns about tariffs grow. Investors may start to evaluate how such economic policies affect profitability and sustainability.

Geopolitical Relevance

In the context of global trade dynamics, the article sheds light on the complexities of U.S.-China relations, particularly during a time of heightened tension. It reflects ongoing themes in international relations, indicating that economic decisions are not only fiscal but also political in nature.

Use of AI in Reporting

It is unlikely that AI played a significant role in the writing of this article, given its focus on human experiences and emotional narratives. However, if AI were involved, it might have been used to analyze data trends or assist in organizing information. The human-centric storytelling suggests a deliberate effort to connect with readers on an emotional level.

In summary, the article is a poignant reflection of the challenges faced by immigrant-run businesses due to external economic pressures. It effectively combines personal narratives with broader economic themes, raising awareness about the impacts of tariffs on vulnerable communities.

Unanalyzed Article Content

On a balmy afternoon last month, Amy Tran unboxed a delivery at Yue Wa Market, a small grocery and herbal medicine shop inLos Angeles’s Chinatown that she opened 17 years ago.

The package contained two dozen units of Shou Wu Chih, a Chinese herbal concoction known to rebuild kidney function and promote hair health. The shipment arrived two weeks after the US implemented newtariffson Chinese imports, so her distributor charged her $115, a $35 markup from her previous order.

Tran said she had no choice but to increase the retail price from $6 to $7. It’s a steep up-charge for her customers, who are primarily Chinese seniors living off food stamps, some barely able to afford to buy a piece of fresh fruit or vegetable.

The tariffs have exacerbated her already dire financial situation. For the past three years, Tran said she had netted no profit, some months not even generating enough sales to cover rent. And she may soon have to raise prices on the dozens of other imported products on her shelves, she said, including an abundance of Asian sauces, dry noodles, ginseng and ointments.

But at 58, she sees few other options. “At my age, it’s hard to find work anywhere else,” Tran said in Mandarin. “I’m just taking it day by day.”

Donald Trump’s bruising trade war with China poses an existential threat to immigrant-run businesses in Los Angeles’ Chinatown – as well as historic Chinatowns across the country, from New York City to San Francisco – many of which rely heavily on Chinese imports that have few alternatives in the US. As duties on Chinese products rose to 145%, longtime shop owners, who sell everything from jade stones to traditional medicine, say they are bracing for a financial fallout that could compound losses they have been accumulating since the early days of the pandemic.

Robert Lee is the third-generation owner of Jin Hing Company, a small jewelry and antiques shop cloistered on Bamboo Lane, a remnant of Old Chinatown. Lee’s father and grandfather opened the shop in 1933, selling imported valuables like jade bracelets and rings, and antiques dating back to the Qing dynasty, such as porcelain snuff bottles and clay teapots.

Jin Hing imports jewelry from a Chinese supplier once a quarter, and Lee said there was enough inventory for the next few months. But if the current tariffs hold until the fall, Lee said he’ll have to start sourcing jewelry elsewhere – which will be more cumbersome and expensive.

“If we didn’t own the building, we’d be in a lot of trouble,” he said.

The tariffs also affect his business on the export end, as US customers often shop for antiques to bring back to China. Since China retaliated with duties of up to 125% on US goods, Lee said demand has dropped.

For Lee, 79, the trade war brought back memories of the store’s earlier years. Before President Richard Nixon’s historic China trip in 1972, tariffs were high and trade between the two countries had been very limited. “We couldn’t get anything from China then,” he said, adding that his father could import only from Hong Kong.

Community-serving businesses like grocery stores and herbal shops are integral to Chinatown, providing basic goods at low prices to its sizable population of families and seniors, said Laureen Hom, the author of The Power of Chinatown, a close study of the politics that shaped the neighborhood in the early 21st century.

“Chinatowns are an ecosystem with a residential, commercial and institutional component that is defined by and serves the Chinese American community,” Hom said. “When one of those components changes, it has a ripple effect on the others.”

The business component has been in decline for much of the past decade, with Chinatown’s last full-service grocery store, Ai Hoa Market, shuttering in 2019 after 30 years in operation. The closure of longtime institutions like Empress Pavilion, a banquet hall that drew mammoth lines for its dim sum, drove down foot traffic, which smaller businesses depended on for survival.

In addition to a loss of heritage and history, Hom said, the diminishing influence of Chinatown further shrinks housing and employment opportunities for working-class Asian immigrants in LA, an increasingly unaffordable city to live in.

“The tariffs add on to the current uncertainties that Chinatown business owners were already facing for several decades,” Hom said, such as “suburban growth, gentrification pressures from downtown and neighboring areas, and the economic downturn and anti-Asian sentiment spurred by the pandemic”.

Some 12,000 people live in LA’s Chinatown, about half of whom are Asian. The median household income isroughly $36,000, less than half the countywide average. The Chinese community, though smaller than some other enclaves around LA like Monterey Park and Alhambra, is disproportionately working class and elderly.

At the same time, Chinatown has undergone significant demographic changes in recent years, said Eugene Moy, a community historian and member of the Chinese historical society of southernCalifornia.

As the neighborhood gentrified, Moy said, more affluent residents have moved in, enticed by market-rate apartments and newer, upscale businesses and restaurants that are largely inaccessible to working-class tenants.

“There will always be lower-income folks whose incomes cannot keep up with this market economic growth,” Moy said.

For Mary Lu Wang, owner of the gift shop Jadetime e-Gifts, these broader demographic changes and continued decline in tourism poses a more immediate threat to her business than the tariffs.

Wang, 74, said she used to order new products every month from her brother’s factory in China, but now does it just once a year due to a lack of business. More than a decade ago, she owned three gift shops in Chinatown.

She said her shop carries traditional gift items that can’t be found at the dozen other gift shops in Chinatown, like the hand-painted oil paper umbrellas, constructed with bamboo and wood, that are manufactured only at her brother’s factory. She sells them at wholesale prices, but still few are buying.

Last Tuesday, Wang made $27 off a couple of umbrellas; the following day, she made $58. A few years ago, she said she often pocketed $400 to $500 a day. If the tariffs stay at their current rate when her inventory runs low, she said she’ll surely have to raise prices – though she’s not losing sleep over it.

“What’s the point of fretting about what might happen in the future?” Wang said in Mandarin. “No one’s buying anything now.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian