‘No fish, no money, no food’: Colombia’s stilt people fight to save their wetlands

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Colombian Stilt Communities Struggle Against Environmental Degradation and Economic Hardship"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.0
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In the stilt communities of Nueva Venecia and Buenavista, located above the Ciénaga Grande de Santa Marta wetlands in Colombia, residents are facing severe ecological and economic challenges. Yeidis Rodríguez Suárez, a 27-year-old local, expresses the despair felt by her community, stating, "We are a people that have been forgotten." The wetlands, which have been recognized as a UNESCO biosphere reserve since 2000, are experiencing significant environmental degradation due to poor infrastructure management, pollution, and government inaction. The construction of highways in the mid-20th century disrupted the natural water flow, leading to increased salination of mangroves and a drastic decline in fish populations. Data from Invemar indicates that fish catches have plummeted from 60,000 tonnes in the mid-20th century to just 4,721 tonnes in 2024, drastically impacting the livelihoods of the 2,500 residents who rely on fishing for their sustenance and income.

The ongoing environmental crisis has resulted in a lack of drinkable water and has exacerbated poverty in the region. With industrial waste contaminating local water sources, residents often suffer from health issues, including stomach problems attributed to polluted water. The community has sought assistance from government agencies, but efforts have been met with limited success. Leaders like César Rodríguez Ayala emphasize the need for governmental commitment to restore the wetlands and improve living conditions. Recent court rulings have called for the dredging of canals to restore water flow, yet local activists remain skeptical about the government's follow-through. Despite these challenges, community members like Elsy Rodríguez Ayala remain determined to protect their home and advocate for necessary changes, recognizing the ecological importance of the Ciénaga Grande as a crucial resource for climate adaptation and biodiversity in Colombia.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The story paints a vivid picture of the environmental and socioeconomic struggles faced by the stilt-house communities in Colombia’s Ciénaga Grande de Santa Marta wetlands. It blends ecological decline with human vulnerability, emphasizing the consequences of infrastructure mismanagement and governmental neglect. The narrative is framed to evoke empathy while spotlighting systemic failures, but deeper layers warrant scrutiny.

Environmental Degradation and Human Impact

The article underscores how highway construction in the mid-20th century disrupted the wetland’s hydrology, causing saline intrusion and mangrove die-offs. This has devastated local fisheries, the livelihood of communities like Nueva Venecia. The inclusion of expert voices, such as marine biologist Horst Salzwedel, lends credibility, but the piece stops short of critiquing broader political or economic forces enabling this neglect. The focus on "forgotten" people suggests an appeal to social justice, yet it avoids naming specific policymakers or corporations accountable.

Potential Manipulative Undertones

While the piece appears factual, its emotional framing—highlighting desperation ("no fish, no money, no food")—could steer readers toward concluding that external intervention (e.g., international aid or NGO involvement) is the only solution. This diverts attention from local governance failures or corruption. The absence of counter-narratives (e.g., government responses or mitigation efforts) risks portraying the situation as irreparable, which may serve agendas advocating for foreign environmental or humanitarian projects.

Comparative Context and Hidden Agendas

Similar reports on ecological crises often tie to global climate narratives, but this article isolates Colombia’s plight without linking it to wider patterns like Latin American resource exploitation. Notably, it avoids discussing whether extractive industries (e.g., agriculture or mining) contribute to the pollution. This omission could reflect editorial bias toward portraying a "helpless victim" trope, which resonates with Western audiences but obscures systemic complexities.

Target Audience and Socio-Political Ripples

The story appeals to environmentalists, human rights advocates, and policymakers focused on sustainable development. Its emotional weight could galvanize pressure on Colombia’s government, though tangible impacts on politics or markets are unlikely unless amplified by larger media networks. If leveraged by NGOs, it might attract funding for wetland restoration, indirectly affecting local economies.

AI and Narrative Influence

The descriptive, emotive language ("glassy surface," "dying light") suggests human authorship, but AI tools could have optimized readability or emphasized certain details (e.g., salinity thresholds) to align with environmental advocacy. If AI was used, its role was likely augmentative—structuring data for emotional impact rather than distorting facts.

Manipulation and Reliability

The article is factually sound but selectively framed. By omitting countermeasures or historical context (e.g., past restoration attempts), it leans toward a manipulative narrative of hopelessness. Reliability is moderate: while details are verifiable, the one-sided presentation risks oversimplifying a multifaceted crisis.

Unanalyzed Article Content

From the porch of her family home in Nueva Venecia, Magdalena, Yeidis Rodríguez Suárez watches the sunset. The view takes in the still waters of the Ciénaga Grande de Santa Marta wetlands. Pelicans dip their beaks into the lagoon, ripples breaking the glassy surface. Distant mangroves turn from green to deep purple in the dying light.The 428,000-hectare (1,600 sq mile) expanse of lagoons, mangroves and marshes inColombiahas been aUnesco biosphere reserve since 2000. Yet, for Rodríguez, 27, the natural abundance is little more than an illusion.View image in fullscreen‘We are a people that have been forgotten,’ says 27-year-old Yeidis Rodríguez Suárez“We are a people that have been forgotten,” she says. “The Ciénaga is depleted. It’s already washed out.”The village of Nueva Venecia and its close neighbour, Buenavista, stand on wooden stilts above the waters of the Ciénaga.For decades, the inhabitants of these palafitte communities, as the stilt-house villages are known, have suffered the consequences of poorly managed infrastructure projects, government inaction and pollution that have caused fish populations to plummet and fresh water sources become nearly undrinkable.Experts trace the problem to the construction of two highways across the delta in the mid-20th century, which disrupted the natural flow of water between the Ciénaga, the Caribbean Sea and the Magdalena River, leading to the widespread salination of the region’s mangroves.Horst Salzwedel, a marine biologist who has worked in the region since the 1980s, says: “Although mangroves can tolerate salt in the soil, there is a limit. When it exceeds a certain level, they begin to die.”View image in fullscreenSome of the stilt homes in Nueva Venecia. Although the community is in one of the world’s most biodiverse regions, pollution has made the water increasingly undrinkableThe dramatic changes to the Ciénaga’s hydrology are reflected in the area’s plummeting fish populations.According to Invemar, a government marine ecosystem research institute, the total catch from the Ciénaga was 4,721 tonnes between January and September 2024, compared with 9,269 tonnes in 1994 – and a reported60,000 tonnes in the middle of the 20th century.View image in fullscreenLast century, traditional fishing methods pulled in catches of 60,000 tonnes – more than 10 times the size of ones todayJésus Suárez, 57, collects data for Invemar in Nueva Venecia. Working from a small stilt structure at the edge of the town, he records the contents of fishers’ catches as they unload their stock, pencilling notes on sheets of paper.“Fifteen fish species remain that can produce profit,” he says. “Once, there were 56 species registered.”Since he came to the town in 1986, Suárez has observed how the changing climate has disrupted the ecology of the Ciénaga.“Nowadays, in a single month it can rain the same amount that previously fell over five months,” he says.View image in fullscreenJésus Suárez, who records data for marine research, at his home in Nueva Venecia. It now rains as much in a month as it did over five months when he first came to Ciénaga in 1986The fall in fish populations has hit the main pillar of the local economy. More than2,500 people live in Ciénaga’s stilt towns, and thousands of others from the nearby cities of Tasajera and Ciénaga depend on the ecosystem for their livelihoods. Many have been plunged into a cycle of poverty from which there appears to be little escape.“The fish are being lost. If there are no fish, there is no money, no food,” says Andrea Niebles Mejía, 18, who lives in Buenavista with her three-year-old child.“I want to study, but there are no opportunities here and no money to study.”View image in fullscreenAndrea Niebles Mejía cannot afford the £35 a month it costs to study in nearby CiénagaIncluding the cost of transport, food and the course fee, Niebles would only need about 200,000 Colombian pesos (£35) a month to study – but it is a price she cannot afford.As a large canoe judders through the stilt town, the wind rattles through her home. The boat’s wooden hull sits unusually low in the lagoon: it is full to the brim – not with a catch of fish but water.It has arrived from the Magdalena River, which provides most of the drinking water for Nueva Venecia and Buenavista. Boats such as these ferry the water between the river and the stilt towns, using the wooden hull of the canoe as a container. The water is barely treated before being distributed to residents to drink.The longest river in Colombia, the Magdalena, receives industrial discharge from several major cities, as well as sediment from industrial agriculture and heavy metals produced by illegal mining.“The Ciénaga Grande is the final part of this system,” says Sandra Vilardy, a marine biologist who has worked in the Ciénaga for almost 30 years. “These inhabitants are drinking the water with the highest industrial metabolic load in Colombia – without it being treated.”skip past newsletter promotionSign up toGlobal DispatchFree newsletterGet a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development teamEnter your email addressSign upPrivacy Notice:Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see ourPrivacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the GooglePrivacy PolicyandTerms of Serviceapply.after newsletter promotionTraces of heavy metals, including highly toxic mercury, have beenfound in fish samples taken from the Ciénaga, while local people report widespread stomach illnesses among children who drink the water.View image in fullscreenClean bottled water is a valuable resource in Buenavista, as toxic heavy metals have built up in the traditional water sourcesRodríguez says: “When I drink the water, it causes me a lot of stomach pain. We don’t have drinkable water.”The lack of an effective waste-management system in the town results in large quantities of plastic being dumped in the Ciénaga. In addition, only two homes in Nueva Venecia have latrines – most of the town’s human sewage goes directly into the lagoon.They have to open the canals that they know are our source of lifeElsy Rodríguez AyalaIn response to environmental degradation and the resulting loss of income, residents have sought support from the government – with limited success.César Rodríguez Ayala, 58, a Nueva Venecia community leader, says: “When there is a commitment from people who can make a difference and have power, communities change. That is missing.”The Corporación Autónoma Regional del Magdalena (Corpamag), the environmental bodyresponsible for dredging canals in the Ciénaga– a vital process in restoring water flow – has long been accused of negligence and inaction.View image in fullscreenMen unload their catch in Nueva Venecia. In recent years, the local fishing industry has been decimated by water pollution, mangrove death and illegal catches, leaving many people strugglingPhotograph: Euan Wallace/The GuardianA recent court rulingordered it to begin unblocking the Aracataca River, which was once used as a source of drinking water by palafitte communities before it was illegally diverted by powerful landownersto irrigate agriculture.“Corpamag has to come and dredge,” says Elsy Rodríguez Ayala, 53, a lifelong resident of Nueva Venecia. “They have to open the canals that they know are our source of life. We don’t know why they have not come.”Corpamag has been approached for comment.The benefits of restorating the of Ciénaga Grande extend beyond the marsh’s borders. “This is Colombia’s most important coastal wetland,” says Vilardy, adding that allowing water to flow properly again “is essential to prevent this place from becoming a methane bomb and instead allow it to become a carbon fixer once again”.View image in fullscreenThere is much uncertainty over the future of the Ciénaga Grande lagoons but many hope their decline can be arrestedVilardy says Colombia’s mangroves provide a buffer against rising sea levels, while water that evaporates from the Ciénaga feeds back into rivers in the nearby Sierra Nevada.“It is a very special place for its ability to strengthen and advance climate adaptation efforts, which will be crucial in the tropics,” she says.Elsy Rodríguez Ayala, along with many others in her community, is determined to fight for the future of her home. Just next door, men are moving building materials for a new school.“We have raised our children here in Nueva Venecia and Buenavista,” she says. “We will stay here as long as God allows.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian