Nature nurture: the Devon estate where rewilding and mental health go hand in hand

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Sharpham Estate's Rewilding Project Links Nature Restoration to Mental Health Support"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.7
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The Sharpham estate in south Devon has undergone a significant transformation from a conventional dairy farm and vineyard into a rewilded landscape, aimed at addressing both environmental degradation and mental health issues. Previously, the estate mirrored traditional English farmland, characterized by manicured fields and limited biodiversity. However, over the past five years, the estate's management has embraced a holistic approach to land use, driven by a vision to restore nature while also providing therapeutic benefits. Julian Carnell, the estate's director, emphasized the importance of integrating mental health support with conservation efforts, recognizing the profound impact that nature can have on human well-being. This shift in focus has not only aimed to revitalize the land but also to create a resource that aids individuals struggling with mental health challenges, particularly in the context of rising stress and anxiety levels in society.

Since the initiation of the rewilding project, the estate has seen a remarkable resurgence of wildlife, with diverse species returning to the area. The introduction of wildflower meadows, the planting of native trees, and the removal of non-native crops have fostered a thriving ecosystem. Surveys indicate a significant increase in butterfly populations, the presence of species like barn owls and ospreys, and the nesting of curlews, demonstrating a successful shift from conventional agriculture to a biodiverse habitat. The estate has also become a space for therapeutic retreats, where individuals, including healthcare professionals, can reconnect with nature and find respite from their daily stresses. As Carnell points out, the interconnectedness of the biodiversity crisis, climate change, and mental health challenges necessitates a comprehensive approach that recognizes the value of natural environments in fostering resilience and improving quality of life. The Sharpham estate thus stands as a model for how rewilding can serve both ecological restoration and mental health support, highlighting a pathway towards a more sustainable future that respects both nature and human well-being.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article presents an intriguing account of the transformation occurring on the Sharpham estate in Devon, highlighting the intersection between mental health and environmental restoration. It tells a broader narrative about the challenges faced by individuals in the modern world and the potential healing power of nature.

Purpose of the Article

The main goal of this article appears to be to raise awareness about the benefits of rewilding as a method to improve mental health. By discussing the conversion of traditional farmland into a more natural landscape, it suggests that reconnecting with nature can help address mental health issues that are increasingly prevalent in society. The article emphasizes a holistic approach that blends mental health support with environmental conservation.

Public Perception

This narrative aims to create a positive perception of rewilding initiatives, framing them as not only ecologically beneficial but also essential for mental well-being. By connecting these two seemingly disparate issues, the article seeks to inspire a sense of urgency and action among readers, potentially encouraging community support for similar projects.

Transparency and Hidden Agendas

There does not appear to be any obvious intention to hide or obscure information in this article. However, its focus on the positive aspects of rewilding might downplay potential challenges or opposition to such initiatives, such as the economic implications for traditional farmers or landowners. The narrative leans toward promoting a progressive vision of land use, which might alienate those who resist such changes.

Manipulative Elements

The article employs emotionally charged language that may resonate deeply with readers facing mental health challenges. While this technique can be powerful in garnering empathy and support, it could also be viewed as manipulative if it oversimplifies the complexities of mental health issues or rewilding efforts.

Validity of the Claims

The claims made in the article are grounded in a growing body of research that links nature exposure to improved mental health outcomes. However, the article could benefit from more statistical data or expert opinions to bolster its assertions. The narrative is credible, but a more nuanced discussion of the challenges of integrating mental health care with environmental initiatives would enhance its reliability.

Societal Implications

This article could influence public discourse on mental health and environmental policy, encouraging local governments and organizations to invest in similar projects. The connection between nature and mental well-being may lead to a shift in how mental health resources are allocated, potentially impacting funding for both sectors.

Target Audiences

The article seems to appeal to individuals interested in mental health, environmental conservation, and holistic wellness approaches. It may resonate particularly with communities that are already engaged in or supportive of progressive environmental initiatives and mental health awareness.

Market Impact

While the article does not directly address financial markets, it could have indirect implications for companies involved in mental health services, eco-tourism, and conservation efforts. Increased attention to the mental health benefits of nature could lead to a rise in investments in these sectors.

Geopolitical Relevance

Although the article does not explicitly address global power dynamics, it reflects a broader trend in the UK and beyond towards valuing sustainability and mental health. This trend is increasingly relevant in today’s socio-political climate, where such issues are garnering more attention from policymakers.

Artificial Intelligence Influence

There is no clear indication that AI was used in the writing of this article. However, if AI had played a role, it might have influenced narrative style or data presentation. AI models could potentially assist in analyzing trends in mental health and environmental data, but there is no direct evidence of this in the article.

The overall reliability of this article is sound, supported by an emerging consensus on the benefits of nature for mental health, although a more thorough exploration of counterarguments could enhance its credibility.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Two landscapes separated by a wide sweep of river tell a story of change. On one side is traditional farmland, close-cropped grazing, uniform grasses, neatly tended hedges and a sparsity of trees, a farmscape ubiquitous across England. On the riverbank opposite, rougher, less uniform grasses grow unevenly between trees, thistle and brambles, in a chaos of natural disorder swaying in the breeze towards the reedbeds below.

The land on theSharphamestate side of the River Dart used to be a mirror of the traditional farmscape on the opposite bank. It hosted a non-organic dairy farm and a vineyard, within a tightly controlled 18th-century heritage landscape of deforested parkland.

But five years ago the managers of the trust began a process of nature restoration within the 223-hectare (550-acre) site in southDevon, with a vision of tackling the twin crises of the 21st century: a rise in people suffering from mental health conditions and a catastrophic loss of the natural world.

Sharpham, an estate created by a naval sea captain made wealthy from a plunder of Spanish treasure, had for years hosted Buddhist-inspired retreats, where people came to seek help with mental resilience, cope with trauma and feel grief. But after taking over as director of the estate, Julian Carnell, a teacher and conservationist, looked at the landscape and felt a conflict.

“I was conscious that people were coming on mindful retreat here, but there was a disconnection with how we were managing the land,” said Carnell. “I wanted to do something a bit more holistic with the land and combine really our mental health work with our conservation.

“Policymakers tend to see nature as a headache, something to get their way around. But alot of people are struggling in their own lives, whether it is the cost of living crisis or stress, or mental health – there are 8.7 million people on antidepressants, and huge waiting lists for counselling. We have turned things round to show that … [nature] is a fantastic resource to support people, and those people then go on to want to care for it.”

To connect with as many people as possible, the nature restoration on the estate, which is run as a social enterprise, was designed with access for people in mind so that the environment could be used as therapy in a seamless way.

In a protected heritage landscape, Carnell and Jack Skuse, his rewilding partner and the director ofAmbios, had to be mindful of the past. “We had to balance the heritage designation with our environmental ambitions, so what we are doing is pushing the envelope a bit,” said Carnell. “We are returning to something more like wooded pastureland.”

They secured a national lottery heritage grant for the nature restoration project and visited theKnepp estate, where Isabella Tree and Charlie Burrell pioneered rewilding, and turned the conventional 1,416-hectare (3,500-acre) farm into a place thrumming with wildlife in barely two decades.

Carnell and Skuse scanned 18th-century maps of the estate, replanted trees in original locations, planted orchards, removed the vineyard and replaced it with a wildflower meadow, opened up viewpoints, improved access and rebuilt a bridge.

“We wanted our story to be about education and outreach,” said Skuse, whose company trains people in nature conservation. “We are living through catastrophic declines in wildlife and something fundamental has to change. We brought schoolchildren in, we brought farmers here and got them talking, to try inspire and reassure them.

“We used this beautiful storytelling landscape and pioneered a change in land use from dairy farm and vineyard, into something that prioritises wildlife and nature recovery.”

Twelve months in, the transformation was already visible. As a thick, uneven sward of vegetation took over the valley, providing structure and cover for wildlife, the land came alive. “You walked through the fields and the small animals like voles and mice were spilling out everywhere, bouncing and popping up and down all over the place. Their population exploded,” Skuse said.

In the second year, the predators came. “We have barn owls foraging every day across the fields, picking out the small animals, kestrels hovering above the ground and diving into long grass, and now breeding on site, which we have never had before.”

There are sightings of ospreys, one of the largest birds of prey in the UK, which is on the at-risk register because of its historical decline and low breeding numbers.

Sign up toDown to Earth

The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential

after newsletter promotion

Today nature restoration spreads across 61 hectares (150 acres), with regular butterfly, bird, vegetation and tree surveys carried out by Skuse and his team. There have been notable wins: a flock of 500 goldfinches, drawn to the food source from the grass and thistles; the appearance of the common whitethroat, which is on the amber list of the birds of conservation concern; stonechats, which are normally coastal, feeding and breeding on site; and curlews nesting. Each year, the surveys show consistent rises in butterflies. “These are big changes to what was otherwise a fairly standard farmland,” said Skuse.

The rewilded landscape is now a source of the therapy offered at Sharpham. “We are here as a mental health charity to connect people to nature,” said Carnell.

Carnell is in touch with NHS professionals to help tackle the crisis in retention of staff in the service. Last year GPs and primary healthcare staff from Brighton and Hove Federation were given the opportunity to attend the nature retreats.

“I cannot tell you the impact, it is extraordinary,” said Dr Rachel Cottam, a GP in Brighton who attended a mindfulness retreat at Sharpham.

“People feel that they are more calm and less stressed, but they also feel it enables them to touch into their original motivation for going into this caring work, which can be so hard, and to find joy again. I am sure it not only improves the way they work but trickles into improved patient care,” she said.

Since the nature restoration project began at Sharpham in 2020, the political narrative has changed. While Labour promised before the election to preserve Britain’s natural beauty and reverse environmental degradation, the rhetoric from Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves now sets nature against growth and the government hashalted environmental grants for farmers.

Meanwhile, the government’sbenefits cutscoincide withmental health waiting lists stretching up to 18 monthsor more.

Carnell believes that Sharpham’s most powerful response over the next five years is to continue to show nature as a powerful restorative and preventive prescription to keep people healthy and resilient.

“If you look at the various crises we face – the biodiversity crisis, the climate crisis, the mental health crisis – we tend to think about them in silos,” said Carnell. “But they are all interrelated, so we need a much more coherent, holistic approach.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian