NSW nurse who triaged Pippa White before septic shock death tells inquest girl ‘didn’t meet criteria’ for rapid response

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Inquest Reveals Care Gaps in Death of Two-Year-Old from Septic Shock in NSW"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.9
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The inquest into the tragic death of two-year-old Pippa Mae White in New South Wales has revealed critical insights into the medical response she received prior to her passing from septic shock. During the proceedings, registered nurse Nikota Potter Bancroft testified about her assessment of Pippa when she was brought to the Cowra emergency department on June 12, 2022. Despite recording Pippa's heart rate at a concerning 171 beats per minute, which is classified as a 'red zone' observation for potential sepsis, Potter Bancroft stated she did not believe Pippa met the criteria for activating the rapid paediatric sepsis pathway. This pathway outlines that children displaying such alarming signs should receive immediate treatment within an hour. Potter Bancroft acknowledged her familiarity with the pathway from her training, yet she emphasized that she did not have access to the document at the time of Pippa's assessment, leading her to conclude that a rapid response was unwarranted.

The inquest further explored the circumstances surrounding Pippa's medical care, highlighting a series of concerning delays and misjudgments. Pippa's mother, Annah, brought her to the emergency room amidst a full hospital and while staff were preparing to admit another critically ill child. The inquest revealed that a blood test was not conducted until 4 am on June 13, after Pippa had been transferred to Orange hospital, where it was finally discovered that she had a serious bacterial infection. Following this diagnosis, Pippa was given antibiotics and underwent an urgent chest X-ray that revealed pneumonia severely affecting her lung. Tragically, she succumbed to her condition later that day. Her father, Brock White, poignantly expressed the profound loss the family experienced, stating that his daughter's death had extinguished a unique joy in their lives. The inquest is ongoing, with the coroner examining whether Pippa's death could have been prevented and assessing the adequacy of the care she received during her critical hours in the hospital.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article presents a troubling account of a tragic incident involving the death of a two-year-old girl, Pippa Mae White, due to septic shock. The inquest reveals serious lapses in the medical response she received, raising questions about the standards of care in emergency situations, especially concerning pediatric patients. The testimony from the nurse who triaged Pippa suggests a critical failure in recognizing and responding to warning signs of sepsis, which may have contributed to her death.

Implications of Medical Protocols

The nurse's admission that she was aware of the pediatric sepsis pathway but did not utilize it due to a perceived lack of criteria met raises significant concerns. The high heart rate recorded could have warranted immediate action, yet the nurse believed Pippa did not fit the necessary criteria for a rapid response. This discrepancy highlights potential issues in the training and implementation of medical protocols in emergency departments, particularly in rural areas where resources and access to guidelines may be limited.

Public Perception and Accountability

The inquest could foster a public outcry regarding the adequacy of medical care and the accountability of healthcare professionals in critical situations. The community may perceive this incident as indicative of broader systemic failures within the healthcare system, particularly in rural settings where medical staff may not have the same level of support or resources as those in urban areas.

Hidden Narratives and Transparency

There may be underlying motives to present this case in a certain light, particularly to highlight deficiencies in emergency care protocols. The details shared could be seen as an attempt to push for reforms in medical training and procedures, ensuring that healthcare workers are better equipped to handle similar situations in the future. However, it also raises concerns about transparency and whether all factors surrounding the case are being disclosed.

Trust in Healthcare Systems

The coverage of this incident could lead to erosion of trust in healthcare systems, particularly in regions where families may already feel underserved. As the inquest progresses, it may prompt individuals to question the reliability and competency of medical professionals, which could have long-term implications on how communities engage with healthcare services.

Community Support and Advocacy

This story may resonate more with communities that feel vulnerable within the healthcare system, particularly parents who are anxious about the care their children receive. Advocacy groups focused on child health and safety may find this case a rallying point to push for better training and resources in pediatric care, especially in emergency settings.

Economic and Political Repercussions

Should the inquest reveal significant failings in the healthcare system, it could prompt governmental review and potential policy changes, impacting healthcare funding and resource allocation. Economic implications may arise if there are calls for increased investment in rural healthcare facilities, which could affect local economies and job markets.

The article raises critical questions about the reliability of healthcare responses, the adequacy of training, and the systemic issues that may contribute to tragedies like Pippa's. The emphasis on the nurse's perspective may serve to shift the focus towards improving medical protocols and ensuring better outcomes for vulnerable patients in the future.

Given the nature of the content and the serious implications of the findings, the article can be considered credible, as it reports on a documented inquest with real testimonies about a tragic and preventable loss of life.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The nurse who triaged a two-year-old girl who died of septic shock in regionalNew South Waleshas told an inquest she doesn’t think she would have activated a rapid paediatric sepsis pathway for her if even if she had access to the document at the time.

Pippa Mae White died on 13 June 2022, two months before her third birthday, after doctors at the hospitals in Cowra and Orange assumed she had an acute viral illness, rather than the bacterial infection that resulted in her death.

A coronial inquest resumed on Monday with evidence from Nikota Potter Bancroft, the registered nurse who triaged Pippa when she was taken to the Cowra emergency department before 2pm on 12 June.

At the time, Potter Bancroft recorded Pippa’s heart rate at a high 171 beats a minute, which the inquest previously heard is considered a “red zone” observation for sepsis.

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email

Under questioning from the counsel assisting the coroner, Jake Harris, Potter Bancroft said she was aware of the paediatric sepsis pathway, a document which instructs that children with any “red zone” observations should be treated within 60 minutes.

The nurse, who had worked in the Cowra emergency department for about 18 months, said she knew about the pathway from her training but did not have access to the document at the hospital.

Potter Bancroft said even if she had been able to reference the pathway she “probably would have looked at it more closely but I still don’t think I would have agreed that she went on it”.

Harris asked: “What do you say to the proposition that you should have placed Pippa on the sepsis pathway and called for a rapid response?”

Potter Bancroft replied: “I think from the assessment I took, she didn’t meet the criteria.”

The inquest heard that Potter Bancroft had described Pippa as “lethargic” in her triage notes.

The nurse said she didn’t “think” this was the same as “decreased alertness, arousal or activity”, which the paediatric sepsis pathway states is a trigger for activating a rapid response when coupled with at least one “red zone” observation.

“Yes, Pippa looked very tired,” Potter Bancroft said. “She was obviously a sick kid who had been sick for days. But she was still completely conscious and alert and able to interact, even if it was negatively.”

She said she thought Pippa’s high heart rate might have been a reflection of her feeling anxious.

“I didn’t call for a rapid response,” she said. “I’m not sure how relevant that is to triage, that particular situation. In Cowra ED we don’t have a separate rapid response team. We don’t have an extra team we can call on.”

Sign up toBreaking News Australia

Get the most important news as it breaks

after newsletter promotion

The inquest heard that Potter Bancroft had worked until 10.30pm on 11 June 2022 and returned to the hospital to begin her next shift at 7am the next morning.

At the time Pippa’s mother, Annah, took the toddler to the ED, the inquest heard, every bed in the hospital was full and staff were preparing to admit another child who was being resuscitated in an ambulance.

The NSW deputy state coroner Joan Baptie is examining whether Pippa’s death was preventable and whether she received appropriate care in Cowra and Orange, and from the Newborn and Paediatric Emergency Transport Service team.

During the first week of hearings last July, the inquest heard that Pippa did not have a blood test until 4am on 13 June, after she was transferred to Orange hospital. It revealed she had a serious infection.

She was administered antibiotics and given an urgent chest X-ray, which showed she had pneumonia that had caused a “complete whiteout” of her left lung. She died that day.

Pippa’s father, Brock, told the inquest on Monday that his daughter’s death meant the loss of a “sparkle from the earth”.

“I walk around in a shell of my former self,” he said. “We want change. This can’t keep happening to other families.”

The inquest continues.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian