‘Music is never fixed in me’ … cellist Sheku Kanneh-Mason on surviving a ‘volcano of racism’

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Cellist Sheku Kanneh-Mason Discusses Racism and the Power of Music in New Book"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.2
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Sheku Kanneh-Mason, a celebrated young cellist, has made significant strides in the classical music scene at just 26 years old. Known for his performances with prestigious orchestras and as the first Black musician to play at the Duke and Duchess of Sussex's wedding, Kanneh-Mason has also written a debut book titled 'The Power of Music.' In this work, he reflects on his experiences as a Black musician in Britain, including the backlash he faced after expressing his opinion against the inclusion of 'Rule, Britannia!' in the BBC Proms finale. His statement sparked a wave of racist vitriol on social media, which he describes as a 'volcano of racism.' Despite the harsh criticism, he emphasizes that his comment came from a place of honesty and a desire to preserve the integrity of music while confronting its historical context tied to Britain's imperial past.

Kanneh-Mason's upbringing in a musically inclined family has shaped his career, with music being an integral part of his life from a young age. He shares that the dynamic environment at home, filled with musical collaboration among his siblings, fostered his passion for music. However, he also notes the challenges of being one of the few Black children in classical music settings, which sometimes left him feeling uncertain about his place in the industry. He remains optimistic about the future of music, advocating for accessibility and the importance of arts education, particularly in light of the funding cuts affecting his former school. Kanneh-Mason is committed to giving back to the community, supporting youth music projects, and inspiring the next generation of musicians. His artistic journey, characterized by a deep love for the process of creation, reflects his belief in the transformative power of music and its ability to connect people across different backgrounds and experiences.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article provides a deep dive into the experiences of Sheku Kanneh-Mason, a prominent young cellist, as he navigates his career amidst the backdrop of racism and cultural sensitivity in the UK. It highlights both his musical achievements and the backlash he faced after voicing his opinion on a controversial piece of music.

Purpose of the Article

The narrative serves to shed light on the intersection of art and social issues, particularly racism within the classical music scene. By sharing Kanneh-Mason's story, the article seeks to illustrate the challenges faced by Black artists in predominantly white industries and to encourage a broader discussion on race and representation in the arts.

Public Perception

The article aims to foster empathy and raise awareness about the racism that persists in society, particularly in cultural contexts. It attempts to position Kanneh-Mason not only as a musician but also as a voice against racism, thereby influencing public opinion regarding the importance of inclusivity in art.

Potential Concealments

While the article focuses on Kanneh-Mason's experiences, it may downplay the broader systemic issues of racism in the music industry and society at large. By centering on an individual narrative, it risks oversimplifying the complexities of racism and its implications in various fields.

Manipulative Elements

The article contains elements that could be seen as manipulative, particularly in the emotional appeal to the reader's sense of justice and fairness. The portrayal of Kanneh-Mason's experiences could evoke strong feelings, potentially leading readers to align with his perspective without a critical examination of the underlying issues.

Degree of Truthfulness

The content appears to be grounded in reality, as it references actual events and public reactions. However, the framing of the narrative could influence how readers interpret the events, making it essential to consider the article's perspective when evaluating its trustworthiness.

Cultural Messaging

It promotes a message of resilience and the need for change in cultural institutions, encouraging readers to reflect on how art can be a platform for social commentary. This aligns with broader societal movements advocating for racial equality and diversity.

Comparative Context

When compared to other news articles addressing racism, this piece could be seen as part of an increasing trend of highlighting individual stories within the broader societal framework. It reflects a growing recognition of the need for representation and discussion around race in various sectors.

Impact on Society and Economy

The article may contribute to ongoing discussions around diversity in the arts, which could influence policies and funding for cultural institutions. It could also spark conversations about the representation of Black artists in classical music, potentially affecting audience demographics and engagement.

Community Support

Kanneh-Mason's experiences resonate particularly with communities advocating for racial equality and social justice. The article likely appeals to readers who support diversity in the arts and are interested in the personal stories behind public figures.

Market Influence

While the article itself may not have direct implications for stock markets or financial sectors, it contributes to the narrative surrounding diversity in media and the arts, which could influence investment trends in culturally inclusive projects.

Global Relevance

The themes explored in the article are relevant in the context of ongoing global discussions about race, representation, and the impact of colonial histories in various fields. It aligns with contemporary issues regarding how societies reckon with their pasts.

Use of AI in Writing

There is no clear indication that AI was used in crafting the article. However, if AI models had been involved, they might have influenced the tone or structure to emphasize emotional engagement, which is present in the narrative style.

Conclusion on Manipulation

The article could be viewed as manipulative in its language and emotional framing, aiming to provoke a strong reaction from readers about racism and representation. This strategy may serve to rally support for Kanneh-Mason and similar artists, pushing for more significant changes in the industry.

In summary, while the article conveys a compelling narrative and raises important social issues, it is essential to remain critical of its framing and the broader implications of its messaging.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Isaw Sheku Kanneh-Mason’s cello case before I saw him – strapped to his back, making him taller. While we talked, the instrument sat beside us, like a temporarily silent twin. A few weeks before, though, I’d heard it sing in the Barbican, London, as he swept through Shostakovich’s first cello concerto with the Czech Philharmonic,the piece with which he won BBC Young Musiciannine years ago.

It is hard to believe Kanneh-Mason is still only 26: he is touring with some of the best orchestras and conductors in the world, has an MBE, is a visiting professor at the Royal Academy of Music, and, for the two billion people who watched, is the young cellist who played atthe Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s wedding.

He is also the most celebrated young Black musician in Britain, famously one of seven talented musical siblings, and was a hugely popular performer at the Last Night of BBC Proms in 2023. But when he appeared onDesert Island Discslast year, he was asked if he thought Rule, Britannia! ought to be part of the festival finale. Quietly, but without hesitation, Kanneh-Mason said: “No.”

In his debut book,The Power of Music, he recounts what happened next: “My truthful and understated remark … was greeted with an uproarious wave of censure and horror against me in the media, and an unguarded uprising of racist bile on social media.”

He had stumbled on an “ice-hard determination”, he writes – the book is a mix of autobiography and musical manifesto – to preserve a place for a deeply troubling song. Its “vigour and intent were born in Britain’s burgeoning slave trade and at the height of its thundering imperialism”, he writes.

His remark let loose a “volcano of racism”. On social media people called for him to be “tagged, flogged and deported” and to “keep [his] n***er mouth shut”. He finds it, he tells me now, “very scary and sad, how angry and aggressive people can be about attacking groups of people”. The tidal wave of hate, he says, was “disproportionate to the intensity of the comment I made. It just came from the heart. I didn’t want to attack anyone with it.”

All that, directed towards this gentle, unconfrontational young man. How did he and his family cope, I ask. “I spoke to lots of other musicians who reached out,” he says. “I find practising and playing always helpful. If there are things I am struggling with, that’s the one place I can always be. Exploring something wonderful, beautiful and interesting.” Since we spoke, thePromsprogramme for 2025 has been announced. He is not performing, for the first time since 2017 (pure coincidence, say the BBC and his agent).

In The Power of Music, he writes about playing in a way that is so grounded, joyous and straightforward that anyone who has had the good fortune to make music with others – choir, school band, amateur chamber group – will feel his words resonating. In his telling, his upbringing was less of a hothouse environment than one in which music was as much part of life as eating or playing football. He writes of the “energetic conversation and teasing battle” of performing duo sonatas with his eldest sibling, pianist Isata, as if music-making was an extension of the babble round the dinner table. He now flat-shares in London with his brother, violinist Braimah, and their friend Plínio Fernandes, a guitarist – he likes to come home to a busy, sociable household, he says.

Practice wasn’t lonely, even though it was done alone, because they were all doing it. “It wasn’t some big project,” he says of the family’s musicianship. “My parents love music, and they loved learning instruments as children, and so they wanted us to also do that. It became clear very quickly that Isata was very into it and enjoyed it, and then the rest of us kind of followed on from that.” He adds: “My parents also like the idea of learning something that you can do endlessly. You can constantly practise and explore and get more from music. And that’s such a universe to give a child.”

And yet, they were often the only Black children in the room, or concert hall, or masterclass. It could cut both ways, Kanneh-Mason tells me: at times, it made him “very determined to therefore be on that stage”; at other times it made him feel that he wasn’t sure he could. “But my family, and particularly my parents, were very helpful, either talking to us very honestly or shielding us, depending on what was appropriate,” he says. In The Power of Music, he writes: “The dominant image of a classical musician when I grew up did not look like me. It was difficult to find a projection of who I might be if I became a professional cellist, but the people around me simply refused to admit this was a barrier.” Now, his presence helps to change that for others, and he is actively involved in sharing what he has achieved with a younger generation (when we speak, he is about to travel to Antigua, where he and his siblings support a youth music project, and he has justwritten a children’s bookabout an orchestra).

It wasn’t just the family home where music was fostered. I was surprised to learn from the book how important his Nottingham state school was to his and his siblings’ musical formation – after all, he was in London having lessons at the Royal Academy of Music’s Saturday school from a young age. But, he tells me, the school was full of music. He loved playing instruments he wasn’t so advanced on – bass guitar and trumpet – in bands and for shows, and spent time “being part of a bigger musical community, and just sharing ideas … Without that I certainly wouldn’t be the musician I am.”

But after the school was subsumed by a multi-academy trust, and suffered a number of funding cuts, its musical focus dimmed: “I remember the visceral shock when we witnessed a host of music teachers losing their jobs,” he writes. He donated his £3,000 prize money from his BBC Young Musician award to keep the school’s cello lessons going. “It’s completely different now, if I’m honest,” he says. He still has one sister at the school, and visited a couple of years ago. “Everything is reduced. It’s really sad to see. It is unrecognisable. And … it’s very difficult, I think, for it to come back.” He passionately argues the case for the arts being available to everyone but, of Arts Council England’s recent policy decisions, he writes: “The idea ofspreading funding outside Londonis laudable if it leads to extra money” but “ransacking excellence at the centre” seems to “go directly against the arts”.

Despite this, Kanneh-Mason is, he tells me, “optimistic – just because I am an optimistic person”. Luckily, he says, he has tons of energy. There is so much to do, so much to learn. He relishes the fact that music is mutable, changing, liquid in his hands; the Elgar concerto, for example, is “never fixed in me … a restless, churning, growing thing”. He loves to draw and paint, he says, and takes a sketchbook with him on tour, using it “when other people would take out a book”. But when a drawing is done, it’s done, he says. Music is different. “I like the process of building something that you can’t see and you can’t preserve. And so, you have to constantly keep going further, further.” It is an act of love, of love that lasts a lifetime, and of joy.

The Power of Music: How Music Connects Us All, bySheku Kanneh-Mason, is published by Viking on 1 May. Sheku Kanneh-Mason’s new album Shostakovich and Britten is out on Decca Classics on 9 May.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian