A lawyer who led a review into the Criminal Cases Review Commission’s work has said it is “absolutely inevitable” there will be more miscarriages of justice afterPeter Sullivan was released from prisonafter spending 38 years inside for a murder he did not commit.
Sullivan was convicted in 1987 of the murder of 21-year-old Diane Sindall, who was killed as she left work in Bebington, Merseyside. The court of appeal quashed Sullivan’s murder conviction on Tuesday after new evidence showed his DNA was not present in samples preserved from the scene.
Sullivan’s case is thought to be the longest-running miscarriage of justice in British history. Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Chris Henley KC, who led a review into the CCRC’s handling of theAndrew Malkinson miscarriage of justice casesaid: “I think that’s absolutely inevitable. I think the case of Peter Sullivan shows us once again that mistakes will be made.
“And as part of the review process that I undertook, I urged the CCRC to review urgently and fundamentally every single case across their desk where DNA opportunities might arise, where the case was based, like this one was, on circumstantial evidence or even eyewitness evidence, which we know from the case of Andrew Malkinson, can also often be flawed.”
Malkinson was freed in 2023 after his conviction was quashed when DNA evidence exonerated him of the rape for which he hadserved 17 years in prison.
Henley added: “I think that there is a fundamental problem in relation to our appeal system generally, that it just won’t face up to the fact that mistakes can be made. It stubbornly wants to stick to the original flawed conviction.”
Sullivan’s lawyer, Sarah Myatt, told Today he was feeling“very overwhelmed, as you can imagine”. She said: “I think it will take quite some time for him to to readjust, but [he’s] very, very happy.”
She said Sullivan had been on video link from prison when he heard the news his name had been cleared and he would be released from prison. “We were all witness to the moment when he realised that the decision had been made to quash his conviction and that he would be released, and he just broke down. He put his head down on to the table, and he was sobbing, and that was quite poignant to see.”
Myatt has represented Sullivan for more than 20 years, and told Today “we will continue to support him with any compensation claim”. She said the battle to free her client had been a “long process” but the DNA evidence had proved key in strengthening their legal case. “The moment of receiving the news about the DNA evidence was so significant,” she said.
“I will never forget that moment when I had that phone call telling me that the DNA evidence had been obtained and that it was not a match for Peter. That will stay with me for the rest of my career and beyond. So once we had that, we felt that we were in a strong position.”
The case, she said, had “created two victims”. “Diane Sindall, of course, being the victim of a horrific crime,” she said, “and Peter being the victim as somebody who has spent nearly 40 years in prison for a crime that he is not responsible for.”