Malala and Kiran faced violence, threats and shame. Now their fathers want ‘all men to stand with women’

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Fathers Unite for Gender Justice: Ranjit and Yousafzai Advocate for Support Against Violence"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Ranjit, a rice farmer in rural India, embodies a rare form of paternal pride by publicly celebrating the birth of his daughter Kiran, defying societal norms that often stigmatize families with daughters. His unwavering love for Kiran is at the heart of the documentary 'To Kill A Tiger', which chronicles their journey after Kiran was gang-raped at the age of 13. Together, they navigate the challenges of seeking justice against her attackers, facing threats and ostracism from their community. Ranjit credits his wife, Jaganti, and Kiran for providing him the strength to persist, showcasing a father’s commitment to his daughter’s dignity and future despite immense societal pressure to conform to patriarchal expectations. Their story gained international attention during a screening in New York, where they were joined by Ziauddin Yousafzai, Malala’s father, who praised Ranjit as a role model for men everywhere.

The conversation between Ranjit and Yousafzai emphasizes the importance of male allies in the fight against gender-based violence and the need for men to examine how patriarchy affects all genders. Director Nisha Pahuja highlights that the 'Stand With Her' campaign aims to engage men and boys in discussions about the limitations imposed by patriarchal structures. Yousafzai, who has long championed education for girls, draws parallels between Malala and Kiran, underscoring that men must use their privilege to challenge oppressive norms. Both fathers advocate for a cultural shift that begins within families, asserting that real change occurs when men actively support women and girls. This message resonates as they call on all men to stand alongside women in the fight against violence and inequality, recognizing that the institution of family can be a powerful force for change.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article highlights the inspiring stories of two fathers, Ranjit and Ziauddin Yousafzai, who advocate for gender justice in the context of their daughters' experiences with violence and societal challenges. It emphasizes the importance of male allies in the fight against patriarchy and the normalization of supporting women's rights. The narrative aims to foster a sense of solidarity among men to challenge societal norms.

Cultural Context and Significance

The story of Ranjit openly celebrating the birth of his daughter in a patriarchal society is significant. It showcases a shift in cultural attitudes towards gender, suggesting that joy in the birth of a girl should be celebrated rather than met with shame. This defiance against traditional norms is a critical aspect of the article, aiming to inspire other fathers and men to adopt similar attitudes.

Promotion of Gender Justice

The launch of the #StandWithHer campaign serves as a call to action for men and boys to engage in discussions about patriarchy and its impact on both genders. By focusing on the experiences of fathers, the article seeks to create a narrative that encourages men to take an active role in supporting women's rights, thus promoting gender equality.

Social Implications

This article addresses broader societal issues, including violence against women and the stigma surrounding victims. By highlighting these challenges, it aims to raise awareness and encourage community support for survivors of sexual violence. The fathers' stories serve as a vehicle for broader discussions about masculinity, vulnerability, and the role of men in advocating for women's rights.

Manipulative Aspects

While the article's intentions appear noble, there may be an underlying agenda to frame masculinity in a more progressive light. By focusing on positive male figures, it could divert attention from the systemic issues of patriarchy that continue to exist. However, the narrative does not seem overtly manipulative but rather aims to shift perspectives.

Connection to Current Events

The themes resonate with ongoing global conversations about gender equality and the need for male engagement in these discussions. The article aligns with current movements advocating for women's rights, suggesting that it is timely and relevant within today's societal discourse.

Reliability of the Information

The article seems credible, drawing on personal stories and a specific campaign that has been launched. It provides a human face to the issue of gender violence and the importance of male allies, making it relatable and impactful. However, as with any single narrative, it is essential to consider it within the larger context of the ongoing struggle for gender equality.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The day Ranjit’s daughter was born, he distributed sweets to the entire village – not just because he was thrilled to be a father for the first time, but because he was father to a girl. “God heard my heart and granted my wish,” he says. His devotion to baby Kiran* was immediate and unshakeable. He would rush home from his work in the fields to spend time caring for her.

Millions of fathers around the world will relate to the joy Ranjit felt, but in deeply patriarchal ruralIndiapublicly celebrating the arrival of a girl is an unusual, even defiant, act.

Ranjit’s love for and faith in Kiran is captured in the filmTo Kill A Tiger, which follows the poor rice farmer as he pursues justice for his daughter after she was gang-raped aged 13. Kiran is determined to see her attackers in court and Ranjit is determined to support her.

Quietly but doggedly, he refuses to give up even in the face of threats and ostracism from his community. He credits Kiran and his wife, Jaganti, for giving him the strength to keep going.

After ascreening of the filmthis year in New York, Ranjit and Kiran were joined by another supporter of an extraordinary daughter:Ziauddin Yousafzai, better known as Malala’s father. The screening was used to launch#StandWithHer, a global gender-justice campaign to support survivors of sexual violence.

At the time, Yousafzai spoke of Ranjit as “a man all men should be proud of – the father all fathers should look up to”.

On Sunday,a short filmwill be released of the two men in conversation, discussing fatherhood, courage and their commitment to seeing their daughters become independent young women despite the social and political barriers they face.

Nisha Pahuja, To Kill A Tiger’s director and founder of #StandWithHer, says the film marks the start of a wider drive to invite men and boys to discuss the ways patriarchy limits both sexes.

“Power comes at a cost – not just to women and girls, but also, to men and boys,” says Pahuja. “There is of course no denying the obvious, material benefits of this power imbalance or the violence it has permitted, but there’s also no denying the suffering of men and boys.

“It’s so clear today that men and boys are struggling to define themselves. I do feel Zia and Ranjit are powerful, unapologetic role models here.”

Yousafzai describes how Malala was named after a 19th-century Afghan heroine “because there was power in this name”. He says he knew it would suit her. “In my mind, I associated a girl with strength, and I thought if I had a daughter she will be strong; she will have her own voice and she will be known by her name.”

Yousafzai was adamant his daughter would be educated – something his own mother and five sisters had been denied. “Education was the front door and it had to stay open,” he tells Ranjit.

He recalls how he used to invite Malala to join discussions and debates with friends at home because he recognised that she had a great mind and always had something to contribute. Malala, he says, was not just a daughter but a “comrade and a friend”, so when, in 2012, she wasshot in the head by the Taliban for standing up for her right to go to school, losing her was unthinkable.

When she survived the attack and became a global advocate for education, Yousafzai campaigned alongside her. They are “one soul in two bodies”, he says. His nickname for her, Jaani, means soulmate.

After Kiran was assaulted, Ranjit was expected to marry her off to one of her attackers – a common response to sexual violence that insists women and girls can only rid themselves of shame by becoming wives. Ranjit and Kiran refused to accept that shame and instead placed it squarely on the perpetrators. “A real, caring father puts his daughter first,” he says.

Yousafzai says he sees Malala in Kiran. “It is as if Malala appears in front of me. Her voice will be a step against extremism, a step against violence; it already is.”

The campaign, he adds, will spread the message that men should be allies, using their privilege to challenge long-held beliefs. “Every father, every brother: all men must stand with women.”

Resistance and change start at home, he says. “This institution of the family is an agent of change, an informal one … there’s no force more powerful than the family.”

Ranjit agrees. “We can convince men; it needs to enter their minds. As more and more people come together, I feel it will definitely have an impact on men and boys.”

  • Kiran is a pseudonym
Back to Home
Source: The Guardian