M&S ‘praying for sun’ but full recovery from cyber-attack unlikely this summer

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Marks & Spencer Faces Long Road to Recovery After Cyber-Attack Disrupts Online Sales"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Marks & Spencer (M&S) is facing significant challenges in recovering from a cyber-attack that disrupted its online services for six weeks. The retailer recently resumed internet orders, allowing customers in England, Scotland, and Wales to access a selection of its fashion items for home delivery. However, shoppers in Northern Ireland are still waiting for their online services to be restored, and M&S is gradually reintroducing click-and-collect and next-day delivery options. Retail analysts highlight the urgency for M&S to boost summer sales as the warm weather approaches, with experts noting that the company has prioritized online fashion sales due to the limited time remaining to sell seasonal stock. Despite the initial excitement from customers about the resumption of online orders, many have expressed disappointment over long wait times for deliveries and limited stock availability, particularly in popular sizes. The cyber-attack has already cost M&S an estimated £300 million in lost profits, with significant losses in online clothing sales during the downtime.

The disruption has not only affected M&S's online operations but has also impacted its physical stores, where customers report difficulties finding desired items. M&S's stores are integral to its online strategy, facilitating two-thirds of online orders through in-store pickups and returns. Analysts emphasize the importance of restoring full services, including the functionality of its distribution centers, to ensure a comprehensive clothing offer is available both online and in-store. With the backdrop of competitors launching summer sales, M&S is under pressure to recoup lost earnings while managing excess stock. The company is cautiously navigating the delicate balance of maintaining pricing strategies while facing a potential need for discounts to clear inventory. As M&S works to rebuild customer trust following the cyber-attack, it remains focused on stabilizing operations, with an eye toward a more normalized situation by the back-to-school season.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article outlines the challenges faced by Marks & Spencer (M&S) following a cyber-attack that disrupted their online services for six weeks. As the summer season approaches, M&S is racing to recover lost sales, particularly in fashion, which is essential for capturing seasonal demand. The piece highlights both the efforts to resume operations and the limitations that still exist, such as stock shortages and delayed deliveries.

Intent Behind the Publication

The primary goal seems to be to inform the public about M&S's recovery efforts and the subsequent challenges stemming from the cyber-attack. It aims to maintain consumer interest and encourage purchases by showcasing the company’s attempts to resume normalcy. This news also serves to portray M&S as a resilient player in the retail market despite recent setbacks.

Public Perception

The article likely aims to foster a sense of empathy and support for M&S among consumers. By mentioning customer excitement followed by disappointment over stock shortages, it creates a narrative of a loyal customer base facing relatable challenges. This could enhance customer loyalty as they relate to the frustrations expressed.

Potential Concealments

While the article focuses on M&S's challenges, it may downplay the broader implications of the cyber-attack on overall business operations and consumer trust. There is no detailed analysis of the financial impact or any mention of steps being taken to prevent future incidents, which could be crucial for a full understanding of the situation.

Credibility Assessment

The article appears credible as it cites reliable sources, including retail analysts and customer testimonials. However, it could be argued that the piece is somewhat biased, emphasizing the positive aspects of M&S's recovery while glossing over the negative consequences of the attack.

Comparative Analysis with Other News

In the context of the retail sector, this article aligns with similar reports discussing the impact of cyber threats on businesses. Such narratives are increasingly common as digital security becomes a critical concern for companies.

Impact on Society and Economy

This news could influence consumer behavior, potentially leading to increased purchases if M&S can successfully manage stock levels. If the company fails to meet demand, it may further damage its reputation, impacting sales and, by extension, the economy.

Target Audience

The article seems to resonate with fashion consumers and loyal M&S shoppers who are keen on seasonal purchases. It appeals to individuals interested in retail trends and digital commerce.

Market Implications

For investors, M&S's recovery efforts may affect stock performance. News of ongoing challenges could lead to volatility in retail stocks, particularly those of other retailers facing similar threats.

Global Context

While this news mainly pertains to the UK retail market, it highlights ongoing issues with cybersecurity, relevant globally as businesses increasingly rely on digital infrastructure.

Role of AI in Article Composition

It's possible that AI tools were used in drafting this article, particularly in organizing information and analyzing customer sentiment. However, the human touch in sourcing quotes and insights helps ground the reporting in real experiences.

Manipulative Elements

The article does not appear overtly manipulative, but its framing could lead to exaggerated optimism about M&S’s recovery, potentially influencing consumer expectations.

This analysis suggests that while the article is generally reliable in portraying M&S's current situation, it selectively emphasizes certain aspects over others, which may lead to a skewed public perception.

Unanalyzed Article Content

The bosses at Marks & Spencer will surely be praying for sun.

As UK temperatures rise over the coming week, M&S will be hoping it prompts shoppers to fill their virtual baskets with shorts, swimwear and sandals to get its summer sales back on track.

After six weeks of costly disruption as theresult of a cyber-attack, the retailer startedtaking internet orders again on Tuesday, making a selection of its fashion ranges available for standard home delivery in England, Scotland and Wales.

However, the partial resumption of online services does not mark the end of the website woes. Shoppers in Northern Ireland were told they would have to wait a little while longer before theycould place orders, while click-and-collect and next-day-delivery services would only become available again in the coming weeks.

Retail analysts were unsurprised that the UK’s biggest clothing retailer had prioritised getting fashion back online before beauty and homeware, given the limited time M&S has to sell seasonal stock.

“They will be praying for a hot summer so people keep buying summer clothes,” said Catherine Shuttleworth, a retail commentator and the chief executive of Savvy Marketing. “Now they have got to get their operation up and running, but things are in the wrong place. I think the challenge is that not a lot is online in the right sizes.”

There was clearly pent-up demand for M&S clothing among loyal customers, judging by excited comments shared on social media and among friends in Whatsapp groups when the retailer announced it had restarted online orders.

However, that delight soon turned to disappointment, as shoppers were informed they would have to wait up to 10 days to receive their order. Others discovered the items they had been coveting were out of stock.

“I attempted to order some jeans last night, but by the time I finished adding things to my basket, my size was gone,” said Kirsten Jones, a customer. “Stock is pretty low, I think I’m just going to wait until business is back to normal.”

M&S has already said its six weeks of lost sales will prove costly – and has estimated it willtake a £300m hit to profits this yearas a result of the cyber-attack. The incident began over the Easter weekend – too late in the year for the retailer to cancel orders for its spring and summer clothing ranges with its suppliers.

M&S could have lost up to £130m in online clothing sales during the period its website was down, according to an estimate by the data firm GlobalData.

Some customers may have heeded the chief executive Stuart Machin’s pleato visit its physical storesduring the online switch-off, but it is unclear how much of the spend shifted to shops or how much was lost to competitors, given that not all customers would have been able to visit a branch or may have found insufficient stock on the shelves.

With its supply chain thrown into disarray by the attack, lack of availability continues to dog M&S in store.

Clare (who did not want to share her last name) was looking through the racks of summery outfits at M&S’s Stratford branch in east London on a weekday morning. Eyeing a new pair of shorts for an upcoming holiday to Mallorca, she said she could not find many in her size.

“I usually browse online, but tend to shop in store if I’m nearby. I’ve not been able to find my size in store for a few weeks, and even now I’m struggling,” she said.

Sign up toBusiness Today

Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning

after newsletter promotion

M&S’s stores play a crucial role in its online operations, and are involved in two-thirds of online orders, through customers either picking up or returning purchases. As a result, getting all services working again is a key milestone for the retailer, according to Clive Black, the head of consumer research at M&S’s broker, Shore Capital.

“They need to get click and collect back up. They need to get [their hi-tech distribution centre] Castle Donington working. They need to get the full assortment online,” said Black. “It may be August before you actually see a normalised M&S clothing offer in store and online.”

Tuesday’s online restart came just as many rival retailers were launching their summer sales, giving shoppers the chance to pick up bargains elsewhere at a time when retail sales and spending data suggests consumers are watching their wallets and cutting back on purchases.

Analysts say M&S will need to hold its nerve to try to recoup some of its lost earnings.

“They will probably try and stay at full price initially, at least, to get that money back. But I’m assuming they have a lot of excess stock, so they will eventually need to start discounting more to get through some of that, as they won’t be able to keep selling more seasonal summer items,” said Pippa Stephens, a senior apparel analyst at GlobalData.

M&S was hit by the cyber-attack just as its bosses wereseeing the fruits of their turnaround plan, having gained market share in both food and clothing last year, while the company’s shares hit an almost nine-year high in April.

It may take the high street stalwart some time to rebuild trust with shoppers after the attack, which involved somepersonal information relating to thousands of customersbeing taken. However, M&S shares are moving upwards again and its clothes arewinning plaudits from fashion commentators.

“I think M&S’s summer was already damaged, and they will want to see the back of it,” said Shuttleworth. “What they are doing now is to get the business right so that back to school means back to normal

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian