Life Is Beautiful review – poignantly upbeat journal of a Gazan exile stranded in Norway

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Documentary Highlights Exile Experience of Palestinian Filmmaker in Norway"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.4
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In the documentary 'Life Is Beautiful,' filmmaker Mohamed Jabaly shares his poignant experience of exile after becoming stranded in Norway while attending the Tromsø film festival. Originally from Gaza City, Jabaly arrived in Norway with his acclaimed documentary 'Ambulance,' which chronicles his time volunteering with an ambulance crew during the 2014 Gaza conflict. However, when the Rafah crossing, Gaza's sole exit point, was closed by Israel, Jabaly found himself unable to return home. This film captures not only his personal struggles but also the warmth of the community in Tromsø, where festival directors Hermann Greuel and Martha Otte become his surrogate family, offering support and camaraderie amidst his challenging circumstances. Jabaly's narrative is filled with youthful optimism, yet it is underscored by the stark reality of his statelessness, which complicates his attempts to secure a visa extension. The film presents a unique perspective on the experience of exile and the emotional turmoil it can bring, reflecting Jabaly's enduring spirit even as bureaucratic hurdles threaten his stay.

The film's title, 'Life Is Beautiful,' resonates with the themes of resilience and hope, although it inadvertently echoes the famous film of the same name by Roberto Benigni, which dealt with the Holocaust. Jabaly's documentary, however, is more of a personal and open exploration of what it means to be an exile, devoid of the dark humor of Benigni's narrative. The original Arabic title, 'al haya helwa,' translates to a cheerful expression from a friend, symbolizing the joy and beauty that can be found even in difficult situations. Despite the serious backdrop of current events in Gaza, Jabaly's work serves as a reminder of the human capacity for optimism and connection, making 'Life Is Beautiful' a significant and relatable cine-essay that sheds light on the complexities of identity, belonging, and the immigrant experience in today's world.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Here is a tale from pre-7 October Gaza, on whose optimist energy subsequent events now cast a gloomy shadow. Almost 10 years ago, young Palestinian film-maker Mohamed Jabaly came from Gaza City to the Tromsø film festival in northern Norway with hismuch admired documentary Ambulance,about his time volunteering with an ambulance crew in Gaza in 2014. But the Rafah crossing with Egypt, Gaza’s only entry and exit point, was closed by Israel while Jabaly was away and he found himself stranded in the city. He used the time to shoot this documentary about his exile and about the Norwegian lens through which he poignantly views his beloved homeland.

Jabaly’s friends and admirers in Tromsø rallied round and became his surrogate family, chiefly the heroically good-natured festival directors Hermann Greuel and Martha Otte. But when Jabaly applies for new visa to extend his stay, the online entry form refuses to accept “Palestinian” as his nationality and recognises him merely as “stateless”, which may well be a factor in causing his application to be refused. He can’t go … he can’t stay … time is running out … but Jabaly’s boyish, innocent enthusiasm seems inexhaustible (though there are moments when the same can’t exactly be said for Greuel, who sometimes comes across as Jabaly’s grumpy dad.)

It’s an eye-opening and very approachable cine-essay about the real experience of exile. But a word about the title: the original Arabic is “al haya helwa”, which is what one of Jabaly’s friends cheerfully says to him on the phone. The echo of Roberto Benigni’s famous second world war Nazi death camp tragicomedy of the same title is, I think, accidental, though it brings us inadvertently and indirectly close to the worrying and problematic Israel-equals-Nazis jibe. But the film itself is too ingenuous and open for that.

Life Is Beautiful is on True Story from 4 July.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian