Labor must protect environment while rewriting laws ‘written to facilitate development’, Larissa Waters says

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Greens Leader Urges Labor to Prioritize Environmental Protection in Law Revisions"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Greens leader Larissa Waters has raised significant concerns regarding the Labor government's plans to rewrite national environmental laws, cautioning that any changes made within an 18-month timeline must not enable continued approvals for coal and gas projects or further habitat destruction. Waters emphasized that the current environmental regulations, which date back to the Howard era, were primarily designed to facilitate development rather than protect the environment. She criticized the lack of climate considerations in these laws, labeling it as 'ridiculous' to have environmental laws that do not explicitly address climate issues. Waters urged Labor to halt new mine approvals, pointing to the extension of Woodside's North West Shelf development as particularly detrimental to environmental progress. She expressed her belief that while the extended timeline might allow for a comprehensive rewrite, it could also serve as a smokescreen for business as usual, allowing destructive projects to proceed while the laws are under review.

In addition to her environmental concerns, Waters noted the need for collaboration with the Greens, who hold a critical balance of power in the Senate, to ensure that any legislative changes prioritize environmental protection. The newly appointed Minister for the Environment, Murray Watt, has asserted that the government's recent electoral victory provides a strong mandate for these reforms, aiming to finalize new nature-positive laws. Meanwhile, the National Farmers’ Federation (NFF) has been engaging with the Greens regarding Labor’s proposed changes to superannuation tax concessions, which they argue could have unintended consequences for family farming businesses. Waters indicated that the Greens are open to negotiating tax changes that promote fairness within the system, and she plans to discuss these matters with Treasurer Jim Chalmers in the coming weeks, highlighting the party's commitment to constructive dialogue while balancing environmental and agricultural interests.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Greens leader Larissa Waterswarns Labor’s rewrite of national environmental laws will not be credible if the government uses its planned 18-month timeline to continue to approve new coal and gas projects or allow continued habitat destruction.

Labor’s proposal to create a federal environment protection agency collapsed in the final months of the last parliament. A deal with the Greens was being negotiated by the then environment minister, Tanya Plibersek, but Anthony Albanesepushed the changes off the agenda, fearing an electoral backlash in Western Australia.

The newly appointed minister, Murray Watt, says Labor’s 3 May victory gives the government a “very clear mandate” to pass the so-called nature positive laws, which he says should be finalised and passed by parliament within 18 months.

That progress will require support from the Greens, which hold the sole balance of power in the Senate.

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email

But Waters said Labor needed to do a “proper job” in redesigning the Howard-era rules and to ensure they were not pushed down the political agenda ahead of the next election.

“They were always written to facilitate development and not to protect the environment. I say that in all honesty,” Waters said. “What they are now very clearly weak on is meeting the challenges that we’re facing.

“They don’t have any reference to climate in them. Now that’s just ridiculous, to have environmental laws that don’t require explicit consideration of the climate.”

Waters called for Labor to stop approvals for new mines, describing the post-election extension ofWoodside’s huge North West Shelf development out to 2070as “a massive, dirty gas bomb”.

“They do need a drastic rewrite. With the 18-month delay that the minister has now said, I take two messages out of that.

“Because I’m an optimist … maybe they can now take the time to do a proper job.

“But the other message I take is that this is not a priority for them. And I’m also worried that in that 18-month delay, that so much destruction will just continue. Things will just get ticked off while they’re reviewing the laws – how convenient – and it’s a smokescreen to just continue on business as usual.”

The Queensland senator, who replaced former Greens leader Adam Bandt, made the comments in an interview for Guardian Australia’sAustralian Politics podcast, released on Friday.

The National Farmers’ Federation (NFF) has been lobbying the Greens on Labor’s plans to make some superannuation tax concessions less generousfor account holders with balances above $3m.

Sign up toBreaking News Australia

Get the most important news as it breaks

after newsletter promotion

The treasurer,Jim Chalmers, says the government is pressing on with the delayed changes and is expected to negotiate with Greens’ treasury spokesperson, Nick McKim.

The NFF chief executive, Troy Williams, recently wrote to Waters warning the proposal risks serious unintended consequences for family farming businesses, which often rely on superannuation for intergenerational succession planning.

“We would plead with you to use upcoming negotiations in the Senate to push for sensible changes to this tax to mitigate the unintended consequences for family-owned farms,” Williams said in a letter provided to Guardian Australia.

“This could include grandfathering existing arrangements, excluding agricultural land from valuations, taxing gains on realisation, and of course indexation.”

The Greens have promised constructive negotiations and expressed concern retirement savings accounts are being used as vehicles for wealth accumulation.

Waters told Guardian Australia the party would consider Labor’s final proposal carefully.

“We will support tax changes that make the tax system fairer and I will be having those discussions with Mr Chalmers as the weeks roll on,” she said.

“I think we’ll keep those discussions private.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian