Jim Chalmers says media’s ‘rule-in rule-out game’ on tax reform has ‘cancerous effect’ on policy debates

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Jim Chalmers Calls for Ambitious Tax Reform to Enhance Australia's Economic Future"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.4
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In a recent address at the National Press Club in Canberra, Treasurer Jim Chalmers emphasized the need for the Labor government to expand its vision beyond the current election mandate, arguing that the nation's economic future hinges on an ambitious agenda focused on productivity and tax reform. Chalmers announced a three-day reform roundtable scheduled for August 19, aimed at exploring potential common ground in the interest of national economic stability. He pointed out the necessity of reducing the tax burden on Australian workers and preparing for an economic landscape where fossil fuel profits may decline significantly. Chalmers criticized the media's tendency to engage in a 'rule-in rule-out game' regarding tax reform, suggesting that such an approach inhibits sensible discussions about necessary changes to the tax system, which he believes are critical for enhancing productivity and ensuring budget sustainability.

Chalmers articulated that tax reform transcends merely balancing expenditures and revenue collection; it encompasses lifting productivity, increasing work incentives, and establishing a simpler system to finance essential services. He highlighted that the current tax collection rates are lower than during the tenures of former Prime Minister John Howard and Treasurer Peter Costello, indicating that a larger tax base is historically feasible. Additionally, he acknowledged the pressing structural challenges posed by an aging population and the global transition to net-zero emissions, which will likely alter resource revenue streams. Chalmers called for a collective responsibility among political leaders to advocate for meaningful reforms, stating that the calls for economic change often originate from those who resist specific reform initiatives. He urged the media to foster an environment conducive to bold policymaking, warning that the rigid 'rule-in rule-out' mentality can undermine the country's ability to address significant economic challenges effectively.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Jim Chalmers says Labor has a “responsibility” to move beyond its election mandate as he argues the nation’s future prosperity depends on designing an ambitious agenda centred on creating a more productive economy and tax reform.

In a speech at the National Press Club in Canberra, the treasurer said a three-day reform roundtable from 19 August would be “a genuine attempt to find common ground if it exists, in the service of our shared national economic interest”.

Chalmers recognised the need to “lower” the tax burden on Australian workers and said the country needed to prepare for a day when fossil fuel profits were no longer a major source of federal revenue.

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email

As he criticised the “cancerous” effect of the media’s “rule-in rule-out game” when it came to making the case for change, Chalmers said “no sensible progress can be made onproductivity, resilience or budget sustainability without proper consideration of more tax reform”.

“I don’t just accept that, I welcome it.”

He said tax reform was “bigger than just managing the difficult balance between spending and collecting”.

“It’s also about lifting productivity and investment. Lowering the personal tax burden and increasing the rewards from work. Creating a more sustainable, simpler system to fund vital services. And improving intergenerational equity.”

The government was collecting less tax as a share of the economy than under John Howard and Peter Costello, he said, signalling there was historical precedent for a larger tax take.

But he also pointed to a need to address structural challenges such as an ageing population and a future where fossil fuel exports are not as lucrative.

“The global net zero transition will also reshape our revenue from resources,” he said.

“This evolution in our revenue base is one of the reasons tax reform is so crucial to budget sustainability – on top of restraining spending, finding savings and working on longer-term spending pressures.”

Sign up toAfternoon Update

Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters

after newsletter promotion

Experts have long criticised a lack of ambition among political leaders to prosecute sweeping reforms but Chalmers said it was just up to the government of the day to make the case for change, but a “collective responsibility”.

“Reform is not just a test of a treasurer or a cabinet but a test of our country,” he said.

Amidfierce criticismof Labor’s modest changes to concessions on earnings for the biggest superannuation balances, Chalmers accused some of demanding tax reform at one moment, while standing in the way of any steps in that direction.

“Too often, the loudest calls for economic reform in the abstract come from the noisiest opponents of actual reform in the specific,” he said.

Chalmers called out the media’s role in creating an environment “conducive” to brave policymaking, especially the “rule-in-rule-out game”.

“Of course there are things no sensible government will contemplate, but limiting ourselves to ruling things in or out forever has a cancerous effect on policy debates,” he said.

“It can rob an informed and modern country like ours the flexibility and maturity to respond to big challenges.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian