I was sufficiently vaccinated against measles in childhood – or so I thought

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Concerns Rise Over Measles Immunity Among Older Adults Amid Vaccination Requirements"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.8
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

When enrolling in graduate school at the age of 53, the author, an older adult, faced a surprising requirement: an immunization certificate for measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccines. Although she had documentation of her vaccinations from her mother, her primary care physician informed her that these records were not official, leading to the necessity of a titer test. This test revealed that while she had sufficient immunity to rubella, her levels of mumps and measles antibodies were alarmingly low, prompting the need for an additional MMR vaccine before attending classes. The incident raised concerns about the adequacy of vaccinations administered decades ago, especially in light of recent measles outbreaks across the United States, with 607 cases reported by early April 2025. Dr. Scott Roberts, an infectious disease specialist, highlighted that individuals vaccinated between 1963 and 1967 might be at risk due to the use of an inactivated measles vaccine during that period, which was less effective and discontinued after 1967. The author’s vaccination records indicated she had received the less effective vaccine, potentially explaining her low antibody levels.

The article further explores the implications of low titer results and the importance of adults confirming their immunity, especially given the changing landscape of vaccination rates among school children. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) currently recommends two doses of the MMR vaccine for children, and for adults, one or two doses depending on their risk factors, such as those in higher education or healthcare settings. Experts like Dr. Aniruddha Hazra emphasize that even if a titer test shows low antibodies, individuals may still possess memory cells capable of responding to the virus. Dr. Robert Bednarczyk points out that while vaccination rates have declined, particularly since the 2019-20 school year, all adults should consider receiving two live doses of the vaccine, except for those born before 1957, who are assumed to have lifelong immunity due to prior exposure. The article concludes by urging adults unsure of their vaccination status to consult healthcare providers about the MMR vaccine or titer testing to ensure community protection against measles outbreaks.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The narrative explores the experience of an individual reflecting on their vaccination status when returning to education later in life. It highlights the unexpected revelation that their childhood vaccinations might not have provided adequate immunity against measles, which raises concerns in the context of rising measles outbreaks.

Public Health Awareness

The article serves to raise awareness about vaccination records and the importance of a proper immunization status, particularly for older adults. It emphasizes that those vaccinated with the inactivated measles vaccine during the 1960s may be at increased risk of insufficient immunity. This is crucial information as it touches on public health, especially in light of recent outbreaks, encouraging readers to consider their vaccination history.

Concerns About Immunity

The personal anecdote raises questions about the reliability of past vaccinations and their long-term efficacy. It informs readers that even if they believe they are vaccinated, their immunity might not be as strong as presumed, which could lead to vulnerability in the face of outbreaks. This revelation can instill a sense of urgency among older adults to verify their immunization status, potentially leading to an increase in vaccinations.

Potential Hidden Messages

While the article primarily focuses on personal experience and public health, it could be seen as subtly promoting a narrative that emphasizes the necessity of updated vaccinations and medical testing. By detailing the low antibody levels and the need for a titer test, the article may encourage readers to engage more with healthcare services, possibly leading to increased healthcare spending or a push for policy changes regarding vaccination records.

Manipulative Elements

There are elements that could be interpreted as manipulative, such as focusing on the personal story of the writer to evoke an emotional response. The anecdote might lead readers to feel a sense of fear or concern regarding their own vaccination status. The language used is accessible and relatable, which may enhance the emotional impact of the narrative.

Trustworthiness of Information

The article appears credible as it references medical professionals and organizations like the CDC to support its claims. However, the personal nature of the story could lead to biases, as it is one individual’s experience rather than a comprehensive study or report on vaccination efficacy.

Broader Implications

This narrative could have significant implications for public health policy, encouraging greater scrutiny of vaccination laws and practices. It may also influence older adults to seek re-vaccination, which could affect healthcare systems and insurance coverage related to vaccinations.

Target Audience

The article likely appeals to older adults, individuals concerned about public health, and parents who may have similar experiences with vaccination records. It seeks to resonate with a demographic that values health security and is wary of current health risks.

Market Impact

In a broader context, this article could influence pharmaceutical stocks related to vaccines, as increased awareness may lead to higher demand for vaccinations. The focus on the necessity of vaccinations could boost companies involved in vaccine production or administration.

Geopolitical Relevance

While the article is primarily focused on a personal and health-related issue, it reflects larger trends in public health that can have geopolitical implications, especially if vaccine hesitancy influences disease spread across borders.

Artificial Intelligence Usage

There is no clear indication from the text that artificial intelligence was used in its creation; however, AI could have been employed in analyzing vaccination data or trends mentioned. Any AI intervention in the writing process would likely aim to enhance clarity and accessibility, ensuring the message resonates with a broader audience.

The article provides a personal account that serves to alert readers to potential gaps in their own vaccination history while emphasizing the importance of public health measures. Its blend of personal narrative and factual medical information creates a compelling discussion on a critical health topic.

Unanalyzed Article Content

When I enrolled in graduate school at the age of 53, I knew I would probably be the oldest student in class. But I was stumped by one of the admission requirements – an immunization certificate for the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) and tetanus vaccines, verified by a doctor.

Fortunately, I had my mother’s handwritten documentation of my vaccines and took this to my primary care physician. “Beautiful,” she said, admiring the yellowed paperwork, which noted one measles vaccine when I was 13 months, the other at 10 years. “But these aren’t official records, so you need a titer test.” Awhat?

Titer tests, my doctor explained, measure antibody levels in the blood. The results threw me for a loop. My immunity to rubella was sufficient, but mumps and measles antibodies were too low, and I needed anMMRvaccine before stepping foot on campus.

It was a simple fix, but the incident lingered in my mind. Why were my titers low for measles antibodies despite two rounds of the vaccine? Withrecord outbreaks this year– 607 in the US as of 3 April 2025 – I wondered if older adults should be concerned.

According to Dr Scott Roberts, a Yale Medicine infectious disease specialist, adults who were immunized against measles between 1963 and 1967 – as I was – are at risk. During that period, said Roberts, children received either an inactivated measles vaccine or a live one. The inactivated version was less effective; it was discontinued in 1967.

According tothe Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly 1 million people in the US received the inactivated vaccine between 1963 and 1967. (It was tested in clinical trials in the UK but never put into widespread use.) Per my mother’s records, my second measles vaccine was live, but the first one, administered at the end of 1967, was not, which could explain the low titers test.

If you know you received the inactivated vaccine, said Dr Aniruddha Hazra, a UChicago Medicine infectious disease expert, or don’t know which one you got in the 1960s, “get the MMR vaccine again. There is no harm in getting the shot even if you are fully immunized.”

Adults can confirm immunity with a titer test, like I did, but the test can cost more than the MMR vaccine. “If you would rather get the titers checked first,” said Hazra, “that’s a conversation to have with your healthcare provider.”

But a low titer test doesn’t necessarily mean you’re susceptible to infection. Dr Robert Bednarczyk, an associate professor of global health and epidemiology at Emory University’s Rollins School of PublicHealth, explained that even if vaccinated individuals don’t have detectable circulating antibodies, they probably have memory cells in their immune system ready to produce more antibodies against the virus.

Before the measles vaccine was introduced in 1963, measles was a major cause of death in children under five. Infection could lead to hearing loss, deafness or debilitating neurological side effects. What is the current recommendation for adults born before the vaccine?

“Anyone born before 1957 was exposed to measles,” said Hazra. “Based on that, the CDC and ACIP [Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices] said we can assume you were exposed or acquired measles, and measles immunity is lifelong.” This means no additional vaccine is recommended for this age group.

If you’re wondering how many shots you should have had, the answer is slightly muddy.

Until 1989, the CDC recommended only one dose of the MMR vaccine for children. Thereafter, a second MMR dose was recommended to help “increase the immune response in the small number of people who didn’t fully respond to the first dose”, said Bednarczyk.

The CDC currently recommends two doses of the measles vaccine for children and “one or two” doses for adults, reserving the two-dose recommendation for adults identified as high-risk, such as those in higher learning and healthcare settings, or who are traveling internationally.

“One dose is very effective at preventing measles,” said Bednarczyk. “This is important, because many people born before the mid or late 1980s likely only received one dose of the MMR vaccine.” But, he added, people vaccinated prior to the two-dose recommendation benefited from high MMR vaccine uptake, which greatly reduced the risk of large measles outbreaks.

The vaccination landscape has changed in recent years. Since the 2019-20 school year, vaccination rates amongst school children – targeted for 95% – have fallen dramatically. According to KFF, a non-profit health policy organization, only11 US statesreported vaccination rates of 95% or higher in the 2023-24 school year. Previous vaccination recommendations took into account the fact that measles had been eradicated in the US, said Hazra. “All adults living in the US should be considered high-risk” right now, he says, and should receive two live doses at some point in their life, except for adults born before 1957.

Sign up toWell Actually

Practical advice, expert insights and answers to your questions about how to live a good life

after newsletter promotion

Dr David Nguyen, an internal medicine and pediatric infectious disease specialist at Rush University System for Health, has a similar take. “If an adult received only one MMR vaccine before the recommendation for two doses was made, they should consider getting a second dose.”

In the absence of a formal CDC guideline for all adults, one thing is clear: two live vaccines confer lifetime immunity. “There is also no value in getting more than two,” said Hazra. If you know you were vaccinated with the two doses of the live vaccine, he says, there is no recommendation for another dose, even in an outbreak or traveling internationally.

Last month,Robert F Kennedy Jr, the US health secretary, remarkedin an interviewthat immunity from the MMR vaccine “wanes 4.5% a year” and that “older people are essentially unvaccinated”.

“That is factually incorrect,” said Hazra. “If it was true, we would be seeing more measles in people with histories of vaccination.” Hazra stresses the importance of including older adults in the discussion about measles protection; they’re more vulnerable to possible complications from measles infections, which include pneumonia. But all the experts I spoke to warn against widespread misinformation about the measles vaccine. “Levels of antibodies against the measles virus may decline over time,” adds Bednarcdzyk. “But in the cases we’ve seen so far in 2025, only 3% of the cases had documented history of measles vaccine receipt.”

Bednarczyk cites “no big differences for adults compared to children” and that side effects usually clear up in a few days. “A lot of these live vaccines elicit a greater immune response for 24-48 hours,” adds Hazra. “The body is mounting an immune response and creating a lot of energy to do so.”

The most common side effects are fever, soreness and swelling at the site of the injection, headache, muscle aches, tiredness or a mild rash. “In some very rare cases,” said Bednarczyk, “there may be a short-term drop in blood platelet levels after vaccination, which can also happen if you are infected with measles virus.”

A person infected with measles spreads the disease to an average of 18 new cases in unvaccinated individuals, said Bednarczyk, making measles one of the most infectious diseases out there. (By comparison, individuals with seasonal influenza usually infect about two other people.) “Airborne pathogens hang around for two hours,” added Hazra. “It can infect so many people because of this.”

The MMR vaccination is significantly safer than acquiring natural immunity via infection. “Having the measles disease runs the risk of complications later on,” said Nguyen. These include subsequent measles infections from “immune amnesia” and serious complications from measles-related encephalitis.

Anyone who is unsure about their vaccination status should speak to their healthcare provider about an MMR or titer test. A high level of immunity across the US will help protect everyone.

Jean Iversenis a Chicago-based writer and developmental editor

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian