With a reduced slate of action and few transfers of note this week in themen’sorwomen’sgame (unless you count Mainz signing forward and renowned Gwen Stefani fan Benedict Hollerbach), and still no word on Arne Slot’s new residency in Ibiza, Football Daily was fast running out of content for Tuesday’s missive. So thank goodness for the open letter from York City owner Julie-Anne Uggla addressed to the National League and the Football League, regarding the “structurally unjust” promotion system in the fifth tier of English football, which sees just the regular season winners (this season: Barnet) and one playoff winner go up from six teams, who finished second to seventh. Hurray!
Uggla is a supporter of the 3UP campaign, which proposes that there should be three (not two) teams promoted from the National League, adopting a similar system to the rest of the Football League. In the Championship, League One and League Two, at least two teams are promoted automatically (three in League Two!), with an additional team going up via the playoffs. It might surprise you to learn that York finished second in the National League, and failed to make the playoff final. Instead, Oldham Athletic, the feeder club of Football Daily’s five-a-side team Old and Unathletic, returned to the EFL afterbeating Southend in the playoff final. For reference, Oldham and Southend finished 23 and 28 points behind York in the regular season, respectively.
“Such a glaring imbalance not only undermines sporting merit but erodes the very foundations of fair competition,” fumed Uggla. “To dominate a league campaign so comprehensively (Barnet the only exception), only to be forced into a playoff lottery, is structurally unjust. It penalises excellence and rewards clubs with fewer points in a way no professional league system should condone. I urge both governing bodies to urgently consider transitional reform, whether via immediate review, temporary relief measures, or an accelerated implementation of the ‘3UP’ model,” she continued. “At the very least, this season’s outcome should provoke an honest re-evaluation of what fairness in football truly means.”
Uggla certainly has a valid point and the principle of fighting for “fairness” on behalf of all football teams in the National League is a noble one, even if it is slightly soured by the fact that York, having finished second, would have been the key beneficiaries of a change. It might have been stronger for someone without a vested interest to lead the charge here, seeing as York started this season knowing full well what the format and rules were and only initially signed up to the ‘3UP’ model in February, when they were unexpectedly in a three-horse race for the title. Uggla, who bought York in 2023, might also be unaware that the club have benefited from odd football rules of the past: City escaped dropping out of the Football League (the old Third Division) in 1977-78 season when relegation back then was decided not by league placing but bya votewhere existing member clubs would just decide which one of the bottom teams would keep their place. Automatic relegation/promotion to/from the fifth tier did not exist at all until 1987, and the second playoff place was only introduced in 2003. All of that aside, Uggla is speaking sense. It is a little silly that York, who finished second on 96 points, were not promoted. But football is a bit silly, and had City instead finished seventh, would Uggla have been so vocal in fighting the good fight? I guess we’ll never know.
Join Yara El-Shaboury from 6pm BST for minute-by-minute coverage of Spain 3-1 England in the Women’s Nations League.
“Of course that reaches you, but we don’t care … actually, in fact, I would say thanks to them because it can be extra motivation, petrol to fuel you. And we won. Let them talk and do all the memes they want now” – Pedro Porrogets his chat on with Sid Loweabout Tottenham’s Bigger Vase triumph, the “Spursy” tag and Ange Postecoglou’s future in N17.
If you do have any, please send letters tothe.boss@theguardian.com.Today’s winner of our prizeless letter o’ the day is … John Jones. Terms and conditions for our competitions, when we run them, can be viewedhere.
It’s a Football Weeklyend-of-season mailbag special.
Here’s David Squires on …the PSG fairytale.
This is an extract from our daily football email … Football Daily. To get the full version,just visit this page and follow the instructions.