Fifty years since the sky fell: how the Vietnam war changed Australia

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Reflecting on the Vietnam War: 50 Years Since the Fall of Saigon and Its Impact on Australia"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.9
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The fall of Saigon, which marked the end of the Vietnam War 50 years ago, is a moment of deep reflection for many, including Thi Xa Nguyen, who recalls the chaos and heartbreak of that time. Living in Vũng Tàu, she was separated from her mother, who embarked on a long journey to find out if her daughters were alive amidst the turmoil. The date is known by various names: 'giải phóng' or liberation for some, while others refer to it as the fall of Saigon, or 'ngày vong quốc,' the day the country was lost. As Vietnam prepares to commemorate this significant anniversary with Reunification Day, the memories for those who lived through the war are complex. Film-maker Mai Huyen Chi reflects on her family's divided history, illustrating how the legacy of the war continues to resonate differently across generations. While the country has transformed from poverty to a rising economy, younger generations seem less engaged with the historical significance of Liberation Day, as they grow up in a prosperous Vietnam shaped by their parents' sacrifices.

In Australia, the perspective on the Vietnam War and its aftermath is notably different. The Australian military had withdrawn by 1971, leaving behind a complex legacy for veterans and refugees alike. Veteran Tony Mullavey recalls the experience of being conscripted and the challenges faced by returning soldiers, who often struggled for recognition upon their return. The war also led to a significant influx of Vietnamese refugees, with Australia emerging as a key destination for those escaping the conflict. Prime Minister Gough Whitlam's government initially hesitated to accept these refugees, but under Malcolm Fraser's leadership, Australia welcomed a substantial number, becoming one of the leading nations for refugee resettlement. Thi Xa Nguyen's own harrowing journey as a refugee encapsulates the challenges faced by many who fled Vietnam, ultimately leading to a new life in Australia. Today, the Vietnamese community thrives, contributing richly to Australian culture while grappling with the memories of their past and the sacrifices made by their families.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article reflects on the 50th anniversary of the fall of Saigon, examining its impact on both Vietnam and Australia. Through personal narratives and historical context, it aims to evoke a sense of nostalgia and contemplation about the long-lasting consequences of the Vietnam War.

Cultural Reflection and Historical Nostalgia

The article highlights how different communities perceive the end of the Vietnam War, showing the complexity of memory and identity. By featuring voices like Thi Xa Nguyen and Mai Huyen Chi, it emphasizes the multifaceted nature of historical events, which are often interpreted differently depending on personal and familial histories. This approach may foster a collective reflection on national identity and the implications of past conflicts.

Socio-Political Implications

The discussion of Vietnam's rapid development since the war serves as a backdrop for understanding the socio-political landscape today. By framing the end of the war as a turning point, the article raises questions about how historical narratives influence current political sentiments and policies in both Vietnam and Australia. The mention of socialist values and national symbols on Reunification Day implies a critique of colonial histories and an assertion of national pride, which could resonate with particular political factions in Australia.

Potential Omissions and Biases

While the article provides insights into the impacts of the Vietnam War, it may not fully address the ongoing consequences and lingering tensions related to the war. The focus on nostalgia could overshadow discussions about the challenges faced by Vietnamese communities, both domestically and among the diaspora. This selective emphasis might lead readers to overlook the complexities of post-war recovery and international relations.

Manipulative Elements and Language Use

The article does not appear overtly manipulative but uses emotional language to connect readers with the personal stories shared. By evoking feelings of loss and nostalgia, it encourages readers to reflect on their own views about war and its consequences. However, the framing of certain narratives might inadvertently guide readers towards a specific interpretation of Vietnam's history.

Trustworthiness and Reliability

Overall, the article presents a historically grounded narrative supported by personal accounts, which lend credibility. The diverse perspectives included contribute to a richer understanding of the event, though it is essential to remain aware of the potential for bias in personal storytelling. The reliability of the article hinges on its ability to incorporate a range of voices and perspectives without oversimplifying the complexities of the Vietnam War's legacy.

Unanalyzed Article Content

“It’s like the world collapsed,” says Thi Xa Nguyen, looking back 50 years to the fall of Saigon.

She was living in the coastal town of Vũng Tàu where the soldiers of the southern Army of the Republic ofVietnamhad retreated.

A 12-hour walk away in Long Thanh, Nguyen’s mother waited. There was only one way to know if her daughters were alive as their motherland fell – so she started walking.

Like the war itself, the date that commemorates its ending has lots of names. To millions of Vietnamese people today, it isgiải phóng– the liberation, but for many it is the fall of Saigon orngày vong quốc– the day the country was lost.

Nguyen says it was the day ofsụp trời– the sky falling.

Wednesday marks 50 years since the northern People’s Army of Vietnam captured Saigon, the capital of the southern Republic of Vietnam, ending a war that had raged on for nearly two decades, taking more than one million lives and leaving hundreds and thousands displaced.

In Vietnam, there will be a sense of nostalgia in the air. It’ll be Reunification Day and every year the streets are emblazoned with national symbols: a golden star on a red flag and phrases expounding socialist values. Film-maker Mai Huyen Chi, speaking to the Guardian from Da Nang, had family on both sides of the war – remembering 1975 is not as straightforward.

Sign up for a weekly email featuring our best reads

While her mother’s family were ordinary citizens of south Vietnam, Mai’s grandfather was a war hero, fighting against both the French and Americans in the consecutive Indochina wars. She says he fought for “dignity, self-respect (and) because the French were ruling a country that didn’t belong to them … it made sense for the Vietnamese that we should run our own country.”

Since the conclusion of theVietnam war– or American war as Mai and many Vietnamese call it – the country has developed at a breakneck pace. In a single generation, the nation has emerged from devastating poverty to become one of the rising middle-income economies of the region.

But Mai feels like Liberation Day in Vietnam will just be another public holiday.

“I don’t know if they even care,” Mai wonders about today’s young Vietnamese. She believes that in the age of social media, people only ever lived in prospering and independent Vietnam do not have the bandwidth to engage in history.

In Australia, the mood is very different. By the time northern troops had entered Saigon, most Australians had already left Vietnam, save for embassy staff and journalist Neil Davis, who scooped an exclusive film of tanks smashing through the gates of the southern president’s palace.

Australian forces, about 50,000 servicepersonnel, had been withdrawn by 1971.

“All Ho Chi Minh wanted was his country,” says a Vietnam war veteran, Tony Mullavey. “Someone put a bloody line through it, and there was north and south.”

It’s a perspective that Mullavey has developed with age, but at the time, he says, “we were doing our duty … it was for the good of Australia”.

He was conscripted to fight in Vietnam a few months before he turned 20. He recalls his training, being taught that the enemy wore black pyjamas and conical hats, and then arriving in Vietnam to see ordinary civilians in black pyjamas and wearing conical hats. It was there, he says, that they all grew up and experienced something many back home wouldn’t understand.

“Vietnam wasn’t considered a war,” Mullavey says. Despite the lethal combat, there was no formal declaration of war on the northern Democratic Republic of Vietnam. Organisations like RSL NSW would ostracise service personnel who returned from Vietnam. It would be a fight to get veterans the recognition they were due fighting for Australia. “Today, the younger veterans can thank us.”

It was that struggle that established organisations, like the Vietnam Veterans Association, that ensured those who fought in Vietnam got their due benefits and recognition. They also opened benefits to the refugee veterans of the southern Republic of Vietnam army – making Australia one of the only countries in the world to do so. But for Mullavey and his brothers in arms, the association and its outposts has been a vital source of human connection.

Perhaps the most visible way the Vietnam war changed Australia was through the thousands of Vietnamese refugees it accepted.

Sign up toFive Great Reads

Each week our editors select five of the most interesting, entertaining and thoughtful reads published by Guardian Australia and our international colleagues. Sign up to receive it in your inbox every Saturday morning

after newsletter promotion

The prime minister of the time, Gough Whitlam, had made overtures towards a multicultural Australia. His government declared the end of the White Australia policy and in the same year that Saigon fell, the Whitlam government passed the Racial Discrimination Act 1975.

Despite that, Whitlam had been apprehensive to accept Vietnamese refugees from the fallen south – many of whom would face reprisal for working with foreign forces like Australia.

Whitlam’s government saw southern refugees as anti-communist and potentially anti-Labor. Labor senator and repatriation minister, John Wheeldon, once said: “What did we see in the dying hours of the so-called Saigon government? What did we see of these heroic defenders of democracy? We saw them doing the scoot as fast as their legs could carry them.”

It wouldn’t be until 1976 – and a change in government – that Vietnamese refugees started arriving. Under the leadership of Malcolm Fraser, Australia came to accept the most refugees per capita of any country.

In 1981, Thi Xa Nguyen got her chance to seek asylum. Her husband had survived arrest and re-education to save enough money and petrol to leave Vietnam by boat. They sedated their daughters and boarded what essentially was a riverboat. It was a voyage of seven days before they arrived in Indonesia.

By 1982, Thi and her family had been resettled in Melbourne. It was a journey often recalled in dreams, but it all came flooding back vividly at her daughter Tammy’s wedding.

“I got married in Fiji,” says Tammy, who is the chief executive of the Vietnamese Museum Australia. “The ferry that we took was very unfortunate because … the weather was really terrible … and it was so traumatic for her. It just reminded her of the escape from Vietnam.”

“It was actually really challenging,” Tammy says. She’s part of what the community calls the 1.5 generation, a cohort of refugees who arrived in Australia as children and grew up in a land drastically different from the one they were born in. To this day, she remembers how hard it was to grow up as a minority. “If in your formative years you don’t fit in somewhere, who do you fit in with?”

Tammy remembers from her work social worker when her community was overrepresented in prisons in Melbourne. “It was pretty diabolical … If you’re a displaced person and your parents are busy setting up a new life, they’re busy working and don’t have time, you’re going to hang out with other kids … who feel ostracised by western society.”

“We were normal kids growing up who got into a whole lot of issues: drugs, teen pregnancy, crime.”

Today Vietnamese is the fourth most spoken language in Australia , and more than 300,000 Australians have Vietnamese ancestry. Vietnamese staples like banh mi and pho have entered the culinary lexicon (and standard dictionary) of the country.

Thi says despite the pain she endured and the nation that she lost, becoming an Australian has been “like a dream come true”.

“That’s what we were raised with. Gratitude for being in this country,” Tammy says. “We have a good life off the back of the sacrifice that my parents made. I wouldn’t have this life if they weren’t brave enough to get on that boat.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian