Do electric vehicles make people more carsick?

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Studies Explore Motion Sickness in Electric Vehicle Passengers"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 9.0
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

The rising popularity of electric vehicles (EVs) has sparked discussions about their impact on passenger comfort, particularly regarding motion sickness. A noticeable increase in the number of individuals reporting feelings of carsickness while riding in EVs has been documented in various studies and social media anecdotes. Research indicates that this phenomenon may stem from a lack of familiarity with the driving dynamics of electric cars compared to traditional petrol or diesel vehicles. William Emond, a PhD student at the Université de Technologie de Belfort-Montbéliard, explains that the brain relies on prior experiences to anticipate motion forces. In combustion engine cars, the auditory cues, such as engine revs, signal upcoming changes in speed, aiding in the rider's adaptation. Conversely, the absence of such sounds in EVs creates a disconnect, leading to increased feelings of nausea as the brain struggles to process unfamiliar motion cues. Furthermore, specific features of EVs, such as the vibrations from the seats and the lack of engine noise, have been linked to higher incidences of motion sickness, as highlighted by a study that correlates motion sickness severity with these factors.

Another contributing factor to motion sickness in electric vehicles is the regenerative braking technology utilized in these cars. This system allows for gradual deceleration, which can trigger higher levels of motion sickness due to the low-frequency nature of the braking. Studies have shown that the regenerative braking process may confuse the brain's ability to anticipate motion, exacerbating feelings of nausea. The mismatch between sensory signals—such as those from the inner ear and visual inputs—can create a 'neural mismatch' that leads to autonomic reactions associated with motion sickness. As electric vehicle ownership continues to grow, researchers are exploring potential solutions to mitigate this issue. Suggestions include incorporating visual signals and vibrations that could help passengers better anticipate motion changes, thereby reducing the discomfort experienced in electric vehicles. These innovations could be particularly beneficial as the transition to electric mobility accelerates worldwide.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

With electric cars skyrocketing in popularity around the world – in 2024,22% of new car salesworldwide were electric vehicles, compared with 18% in 2023 – a growing body of studies and an increasing number of people have found that they feel more motion sick riding in EVs than in traditional petrol or diesel cars. Anecdotes offeeling sickin the passenger or back seat of electric cars littersocial media, as doquestionsfrom wary prospective buyers.

There is a scientific explanation behind why a person might feel more sick in an EV, though, according to multiple academic studies.

“Greater sickness in EVs can be attributed to a lack of previous experience, as both a driver and as a passenger, where the brain lacks accuracy in estimating the motion forces because it relies on previous experience in other types of cars,” said William Emond, a PhD student researching car sickness at the Université de Technologie de Belfort-Montbéliard in France.

Though EVs are becoming more popular, combustion cars still dominate. Riders have a longer history with gas cars and so have had more time to adapt to their specific cues. If a person has spent most of their life driving a combustion engine car, their brain anticipates acceleration after the rev of the engine, a warning that they are about to experience a change in speed. In a battery-powered car, the electric motor makes no such noises.

In addition to general unfamiliarity, research has found links between specific features common to electric vehicles and motion sickness. One2024 studyconcluded that there were strong correlations between motion sickness severity and the seat vibrations of electric vehicles, while a2020 studyfound that the lack of engine sound in an EV might be a major contributing factor to increased feelings of carsickness.

“If we are accustomed to traveling in non-EVs, we are used to understanding the car’s motion based on signals such as engine revs, engine vibrations, torque, etc. Yet, traveling in an EV for the first time is a new motion environment for the brain, which needs adaptation,” Emond explains.

Additionally, the regenerative braking technology used in EVs – where the motor converts the slowing car’s kinetic energy into electricity that then is stored in the battery – results inlow-frequency deceleration, meaning that the vehicle slows down gradually and steadily, over a relatively longer period, rather than rapidly or in quick pulses. Such low-frequency deceleration tends to be associated withhigher levels of motion sickness.

A2024 studysuggested the feature acted as one of the main triggers of motion sickness in electric vehicles. The study’s authors wrote: “Our results confirmed that higher levels of RB [regenerative braking] can induce MS [motion sickness].”

Motion sickness is thought to be caused by a mismatch between various sensory signals the brain simultaneously receives about the body’s movement. Specifically, it happens when the inner ear, which helps control balance, the eyes, and the body send conflicting information to the brain.

“Better knowledge on self-motion allows us to anticipate motion forces, which is crucial for motion sickness. Yet, when the motion forces as estimated or anticipated by the brain differ from what actually is experienced, then the brain interprets this ‘neural mismatch’ as a situation of conflict,” Emond said. “If this conflict persists over time, it may surpass a threshold for triggering autonomic reactions of the body such as symptoms apparent to ‘motion sickness’.”

Being able to anticipate the movement of a vehicle appears to be integral to the experience of motion sickness, which is why people who are driving a car don’t tend to experience symptoms. They know what is coming.

The interplay between anticipation of motion and actual motion experienced may be why EVs are associated with worse motion sickness, as these vehicles provide fewer clues regarding upcoming movements.

“When discovering a new motion environment, the brain needs to habituate because there is no knowledge of previous experience in such a context. This is, for example, why almost everyone becomes sick in zero-gravity environments,” Emond says.

As EV ownership continues to increase, some researchers are already looking into a solution for the cars’ specific type of nausea. Several research papers have suggested that motion sickness in autonomous EVs could be treated byusing visualsignals, such as interactive screens and ambient lighting, orvibrational cuesto allow a passenger’s brain to anticipate motion changes, alleviating the lurching feeling in the back of an electric taxi.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian