‘Desolate’: farmers in NSW’s west battle drought as east coast mops up after floods

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Farmers in New South Wales Face Severe Drought Amidst Flooding on East Coast"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.9
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Farmers in southwestern New South Wales are facing severe drought conditions, forcing many to make difficult decisions regarding their livestock and crops. Paul Manwaring, a cattle breeder near Cootamundra, illustrates the plight of the region, where sporadic rainfall has not been enough to alleviate the persistent dryness. Despite occasional showers creating temporary patches of growth, much of the land remains desolate, highlighting the stark contrast in conditions even within short distances. The New South Wales drought indicator reflects this dire situation, with large areas of the region marked in orange, signaling imminent drought conditions. As farmers contend with the ramifications of a hot summer and an absent autumn break, they are left to grapple with the reality of dwindling resources and the need to sell off stock or abandon crops altogether. Manwaring has already sold his sheep in anticipation of the ongoing dry spell, and he warns that even if rain does eventually arrive, it will take time for the land to recover and produce adequate feed for livestock.

The broader impact of drought is being felt across southern Australia, coinciding with severe flooding in the eastern regions. The Bureau of Meteorology reports a significant decrease in rainfall across various states, with Tasmania experiencing its driest April in a decade and South Australia suffering economic losses due to the worst harvest in 15 years. Farmers like Cassie Oster, who runs a grazing and cropping operation, express deep concern over the unprecedented nature of this drought, which has forced them to sell off thousands of sheep and abandon crops. The slow onset of drought conditions, exacerbated by high-pressure weather systems, has prompted calls for greater awareness and support from government authorities. In the face of these challenges, mental health issues are emerging as a serious concern among farming communities, as isolation and feelings of neglect can have devastating consequences. Many farmers, while remaining hopeful that rain will eventually return, are acutely aware of the long-term implications of their current decisions on their livelihoods and the future of their operations.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article outlines the stark contrast between the flooding affecting parts of Australia and the severe drought impacting farmers in southern New South Wales (NSW). This juxtaposition highlights the ongoing environmental challenges faced by agricultural communities and the economic implications of such weather extremes.

Impact on Farmers' Livelihoods

The narrative centers around farmer Paul Manwaring, who expresses the frustration of witnessing rain forecasts that fail to materialize. The drought has forced many farmers to make difficult decisions, such as selling livestock and abandoning crops. This situation underscores the broader agricultural crisis, as farmers in the region brace for potentially long-lasting impacts on their incomes and livelihoods.

Geographical Disparities

The article illustrates a geographical dichotomy where while some areas experience catastrophic flooding, others suffer from prolonged drought. This disparity raises questions about climate patterns and the need for adaptive agricultural practices. It highlights the vulnerability of farming communities that rely heavily on weather conditions, emphasizing the unpredictable nature of climate change.

Public Perception and Community Response

The piece aims to evoke empathy towards farmers struggling under drought conditions, while also shedding light on the broader implications of such extreme weather events. It seeks to draw attention to the plight of rural communities and may serve to galvanize public support for agricultural aid and policy changes aimed at addressing these issues.

Transparency and Accountability

While the article does not overtly conceal information, it focuses predominantly on the hardships faced by farmers without delving deeply into the potential responses from government or agricultural organizations. This could suggest an intention to rally support for immediate action without exploring the complexities of policy decisions or resource allocation.

Manipulative Potential

There is a potential for manipulation through the emotive language and imagery used to describe the farmers' challenges. By portraying a sense of despair and urgency, the article may influence public sentiment and policy discussions. However, the factual basis of the farmers' experiences lends credibility to the narrative, reducing the likelihood of significant manipulation.

Comparative Analysis

When examined alongside other news regarding climate events, this article fits into a broader narrative of climate-related challenges that are increasingly affecting various regions globally. The connection to other reports on climate change and its impact on agriculture may enhance its relevance and urgency in the public discourse.

Economic and Political Implications

The coverage of droughts and floods has potential economic ramifications, particularly for agricultural stocks and commodity prices. Stakeholders in the agricultural sector may experience fluctuations in their investments based on the outcomes of these weather events. As governments respond to the crisis, political discussions surrounding climate resilience and agricultural support could intensify.

Community Engagement

The article is likely to resonate more with rural communities and stakeholders in the agricultural sector. It aims to raise awareness among urban populations about the struggles faced by farmers, thereby fostering a sense of solidarity and support for agricultural initiatives.

Market Influence

The news could have implications for specific stocks tied to agriculture, such as those in farming equipment, crop production, and livestock industries. Investors may closely monitor these developments to gauge the economic outlook for the agricultural sector.

Global Context

In terms of global power dynamics, the issues raised in the article relate to broader conversations about climate change and food security. The ongoing challenges faced by farmers in Australia reflect larger trends that may influence international agricultural policies and trade agreements.

The article appears to be credible, providing insights into the real challenges faced by farmers while prompting necessary discussions about climate adaptation and agricultural support. The personal accounts of farmers enhance the authenticity of the narrative, making it a compelling piece that captures the urgency of the situation.

Unanalyzed Article Content

While parts of Australia battle floods, farmers in the south are selling off stock, abandoning crops and pleading for help as drought deepens.

Farmer Paul Manwaring has been living in the shadow of rain.

The cattle breeder has watched for months as promising forecasts disappear, while the occasional shower creates patches of growth on the parched plains around Cootamundra, in south-westernNew South Wales.

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email

“It’s all green where a storm went through, but 200 metres down the road it’s desolate,” Manwaring says.

The region is in the grips of disaster, according to the NSW drought indicator, part of a large area lit up in orange on the map.

Surrounding regions are also drying out, expected to slip into drought by mid-winter.

“[The rain] keeps either going north or south of us and we just keep being in that shadow,” Manwaring says.

After a hot summer, the mild and wet autumn break that farmers typically expect did not come. Scattered rain across parts of the district in recent days arrived too late – producers had already made tough decisions.

Manwaring, who runs a small livestock operation, sold his sheep in spring in anticipation of the dry, figuring that a run of good seasons would turn.

Others have had to pull up their crops, change their planting regimes or sell stock in a busy market, necessary moves that will affect farm incomes for years.

“Even when it does rain, it’s going to take a while to grow feed for all the livestock,” Manwaring says.

Much of southern Australia is in drought at the same timeas the NSW Hunter and mid-north coast regions face a major flood emergency, with five months’ rain falling there in two days.

April rainfall has been well below average across much of Victoria, Tasmania, southern NSW, easternSouth Australia, and the west coast and interior of Western Australia, according to the Bureau of Meteorology’s drought statement.

Tasmania recorded its driest April in a decade, with falls 50% below the 40-year average.

South Australia has also been hit particularly hard, with $2bn wiped from the state’s economy after the worst harvest in 15 years.

Cassie Oster, whose family runs a grazing and cropping operation at Jabuk, about 150km south-east of Adelaide, says producers on the marginal country are always prepared for dry conditions.

But this drought is particularly brutal.

“We are at a point where we’re like ... this is really scary,” Oster says.

“The decisions we’re having to make are things that we’ve never been faced with before.”

The family has sold off more than 1,000 sheep and abandoned several crops.

Those kinds of decisions make it harder for farmers to buy back into the market after the drought breaks, when they are also likely to face higher costs of inputs, machinery and fuel.

Drought conditions have been slowly creeping in since early 2023, mostly in regions with western-facing coastlines.

Dry periods have been historically linked to the El Niño climate pattern, but Australian scientists have identified more nuance in what triggers low rainfall.

Droughts develop when weather systems that lift and carry moisture from the ocean disappear, a recent scientific review found.

Sign up toBreaking News Australia

Get the most important news as it breaks

after newsletter promotion

That has been the case for months across the south, with slow-moving high pressure systems dominating and bringing warm and dry conditions with them.

There has been a long-term shift towards drier conditions in southern Australia, according to the weather bureau’s 2024 climate change report.

As the dry takes hold and forecasts fail to offer any certainty, farming groups have been calling for greater drought awareness and support.

Oster is one of many farmers backing a petition for a formal drought declaration to unlock emergency funds, something the SA government says it cannot do under a federal agreement.

She said the national drought plan, which aims to make farmers financially self-reliant, is all very well in a typical scenario.

Most farmers spend the good years preparing for the bad, but the last few seasons have made that nearly impossible.

“It’s like no other drought we’ve ever seen,” Oster says.

The Victorian Farmers Federation has urged politicians to spend more time in the regions.

“Mental health is a huge concern: when farmers feel isolated, unsupported and forgotten, the consequences can be devastating for individuals and entire communities,” president, Brett Hosking, says.

Eileen Jorgensen, who has spent a lifetime farming in Victoria, has noticed growers becoming more open about the mental toll of drought.

But distressed farmers talking to each other could only help for so long, she says.

“That is probably the darker side of the drought,” Jorgensen says, as looked out the window at her drying paddocks in the Wimmera region, in the state’s west.

The Jorgensens, who grow grain and raise sheep and Clydesdale horses, are able to keep their stock watered by the Wimmera Mallee pipeline that was built after successive droughts in the early 2000s.

But others further south are having to cart water and source increasingly expensive stock feed.

Jorgensen remains pragmatic, having grown up working in her father’s market garden watching bad seasons come and go.

“You just know it’s going to rain eventually,” she says.

“It may not be tomorrow, it may not be next month, but it will rain.”

In Australia, support is available atBeyond Blueon 1300 22 4636,Lifelineon 13 11 14, and atMensLineon 1300 789 978. In the UK, the charityMindis available on 0300 123 3393 andChildlineon 0800 1111. In the US, call or textMental Health Americaat 988 or chat 988lifeline.org.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian