Denied citizenship by the country he died for, this Anzac Day Aboriginal war hero Bill Allan is being honoured by France

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Aboriginal War Hero William Allan Honored as Honorary Citizen of France"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Private William Allan Irwin, a Gomeroi man from New South Wales, served valiantly during World War I, ultimately sacrificing his life on August 31, 1918, in the battle of Mont St-Quentin. Despite being posthumously awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal for his bravery in capturing German machine-gun nests, he was never granted citizenship in Australia. His story, however, has gained recognition in France, where he has been posthumously honored as an honorary citizen of the Somme Valley. This recognition comes over a century after his death, highlighting not only his individual bravery but also the contributions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander soldiers who served during the war, many of whom faced systemic discrimination that barred them from enlistment until 1917. Allan's journey to the front lines began after a personal tragedy—his heartbreak over a lost love—and despite efforts from his brother to prevent his enlistment, he joined the Australian Imperial Force in 1916 and faced numerous battles, sustaining injuries before his ultimate sacrifice.

Recently, a 'day of tribute' was held in Allan’s honor, organized by the Somme Valley community. Stéphane Chevin, a representative of the community, emphasized the significance of recognizing Allan's values of bravery and resilience, while also acknowledging the broader Aboriginal history that has often been overlooked. Allan's great-nephew, Peter Milliken, expressed deep gratitude for the French recognition, stating it is a significant honor for a man who had never been a citizen anywhere. This acknowledgment was made possible largely due to the efforts of Joe Flick, a Gomeroi/Yullaroi man, who documented the graves of Aboriginal soldiers in Europe through his project 'Bringing Their Spirits Home'. Milliken plans to pay tribute to his great-uncle in Paris on Anzac Day, hoping one day Allan's remains can be returned to Gomeroi country, reflecting a deep cultural belief in the importance of resting on ancestral land.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article sheds light on the story of Private William Allan Irwin, an Aboriginal war hero who fought valiantly in World War I but was denied citizenship in his own country. His recent honor as an honorary citizen of France highlights issues of recognition and historical injustice faced by Indigenous Australians.

Historical Context and Recognition

Bill Allan's bravery during the battle of Mont St-Quentin is significant not only for its immediate impact but also for what it represents in the broader narrative of Aboriginal contributions to Australia. Despite his heroics, he was posthumously awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal but never recognized as a citizen of Australia due to discriminatory laws of the time. This stark contrast raises questions about the value placed on the lives and contributions of Indigenous Australians throughout history.

Symbolism of Honor from France

The act of honoring Allan by the community in France serves as a compelling reminder of the sacrifices made by soldiers irrespective of their background. It reflects a growing acknowledgment of the injustices faced by Aboriginal soldiers, contrasting with their treatment at home. This honor may also evoke a sense of pride among Aboriginal communities and prompt discussions about national identity and belonging.

Implications for Modern Society

This story may resonate deeply in contemporary Australian society, encouraging conversations around reconciliation and the recognition of Indigenous rights. It highlights the need for ongoing dialogue about the treatment of Aboriginal people and the importance of acknowledging their contributions to the nation. The story has the potential to influence public sentiment and drive political discourse regarding Indigenous affairs.

Potential Economic and Political Impact

While this specific story may not have direct implications for the stock market or economic indicators, it contributes to a broader cultural movement that could influence policies related to Indigenous rights and recognition. This could affect sectors reliant on government funding or public support for Indigenous programs and initiatives.

Community Support and Response

This narrative is likely to resonate with those advocating for Indigenous rights and social justice. It serves as a rallying point for communities seeking acknowledgment of historical injustices and may strengthen solidarity among various advocacy groups.

Global Perspective and Relevance

The article connects to ongoing global discussions about colonial legacies and the treatment of Indigenous populations. The story of Bill Allan can be situated within larger movements advocating for recognition and reparations for historical injustices faced by Indigenous peoples worldwide.

Artificial Intelligence in Reporting

It is possible that AI tools were employed in the writing process, particularly in structuring the narrative or enhancing clarity. However, the emotional depth and historical context suggest a human touch in conveying the significance of Allan's story. If AI influenced this piece, it might have aimed to frame the narrative in a way that elicits empathy and understanding.

In conclusion, the article serves as a poignant reminder of the sacrifices made by Indigenous soldiers and the ongoing struggle for recognition and rights. It effectively highlights a historical injustice while fostering discussions about citizenship and national identity in Australia.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Outside the French town of Péronne on 31 August 1918, Private William Allan Irwin – a Gomeroi man from near Coonabarabran inNew South Wales– was pinned down by German machine-gun fire alongside fellow Australian soldiers from the 33rd infantry battalion.

They had been ordered to wrest control of enemy-held positions in an area known as Road Wood during the battle of Mont St-Quentin.

In the face of heavy fire Allan rushed three machine-gun nests, capturing the weapons and crews.The job not done, he tried to capture a fourth, where he was fatally wounded. He died the next day.

Despite his bravery, for which he was posthumously awarded the distinguished conduct medal, Bill Allan was never recognised as a citizen of his own country.

Now, more than 106 years later, he has been made an honorary citizen of France’s Somme Valley.

Allan was one of about 1,000 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander menwho fought for Australia in the first world war. He joined the army in 1916 when the Defence Act of 1909 barred recruits who were “not substantially of European origin or descent”. (This restriction was lifted in 1917.)

According to at leastone account, it was a broken heart that prompted the 37-year-old to volunteer. He had been working with his brothers, Harry and Jack, as a shearer in towns across NSW including Quirindi, Werris Creek and Moree. In 1915 the woman he hoped to wed married another man.

Harry sought to stop his brother joining the Australian Imperial Force, even riding his horse to Newcastle to try to intervene before the troop ship left Australia in May 1916.

Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter

After four months training in England, Allan landed in the mud and trenches of the western front, taking part in the Battle of Messines, where he was wounded and sent back to England to convalesce. On his return to France he was injured a number of times. His bodywas buried at Daours.

The Somme Valley community of communes, which comprises 33 townships across the region, held a “day of tribute” last week in Allan’s honour.

A representative, Stéphane Chevin, said: “Learning about his life and service inspired us to reflect on the values he embodied – bravery, resilience, and a strong sense of duty.

“This is the very first time that our region has awarded this distinction, by honouring soldier Irwin we are also paying tribute to the Aboriginal community whose history has too often been overlooked.”

Allan’s great-nephew Peter Milliken, who travelled to France for the ceremony, says the recognition “means a hell of a lot”.

“He’s never been a citizen of anywhere and, for the French to do this, it’s a big honour,” he says, adding that theAustralian government “probably should have done this years ago”.

A picture of his great-uncle always had price of place at his nanna’s home in Walhallow, NSW, Milliken says.

“I’m 67 now and this story I’ve probably known since I was three or four years old. My whole family knows about this man and we always have – the story’s been handed down for over 100 years.”

Sign up toAfternoon Update: Election 2025

Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key election campaign stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters

after newsletter promotion

The French recognition of Allan’s service was made possible largely through the work of a Gomeroi/Yullaroi man, Joe Flick, and his project Bringing Their Spirits Home, along with a documentary by the Yuwaalaraay film-maker Dylan Nicholls.

Over a decade Flick documented and photographed the first world war graves of Aboriginal soldiers in the UK, France and Belgium. Nicholls was so moved by Flick’s project that he made the documentary about it.

“It’s so sad that we have so many of our mob over there buried so far away from their traditional country,” he says.

“So I had an idea I wanted to make a documentary about a descendant’s journey of going over to France and visiting their ancestor’s grave and I came across the story of William Allan Irwin DCM.”

All three men travelled to France last year to shoot Bringing His Spirit Home and to walk in the footsteps of Allan, seeing where he fought and fell, and where his body lies.

“I wasn’t the first to go to the gravesite, there’s probably been three or four family members that have been over there before,” Milliken says.

“I was the first to be able to go to the battleground … to walk over that was very emotional.”

OnAnzac DayMilliken will pay tribute to his great-uncle in Paris: “I’ll get to lay a wreath for the old fella … I’m pretty honoured,” he says.

Milliken and the rest of Allan’s extended family hope that one day his body can return home to Gomeroi country.

“He was a great a man, you know, and he really deserved to come home,” Milliken says.

“For Gomeroi people we need to be buried back on country and we’re never at rest until you’re back on your own country – it’s the Aboriginal thoughts and ways.”

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian