Could the right question bring some magic to your meetings? | Emma Beddington

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Exploring the Impact of Engaging Questions on Meeting Productivity"

Could the right question bring some magic to your meetings? | Emma Beddington analysis cover image The Guardian 7.6
Image Source: https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/051da77ff4ca91eb120550b1ace6cd8032bc5023/444_0_6827_5464/master/6827.jpg?width=1200&height=630&quality=85&auto=format&fit=crop&overlay-align=bottom%2Cleft&overlay-width=100p&overlay-base64=L2ltZy9zdGF0aWMvb3ZlcmxheXMvdGctb3BpbmlvbnMucG5n&enable=upscale&s=122a12843d31795848d41560b18a4c21
Original Article Source: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/may/26/could-the-right-question-bring-some-magic-to-your-meetings
View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 7.6
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

Research from the London School of Economics reveals that a significant portion of meetings, over one third, are deemed unproductive. This statistic resonates with many who have experienced the often tedious nature of meetings. Priya Parker, a meeting specialist and author of 'The Art of Gathering,' suggests that injecting a sense of engagement and enjoyment into meetings can be achieved by starting with a 'magical question.' She proposes asking participants about their first concert experience, encouraging personal sharing that can foster connection among team members. Despite initial skepticism regarding the practicality of such an approach, Parker believes that these questions can bring an element of fun to otherwise mundane gatherings.

To explore Parker's idea, the author enlisted her husband to implement the 'magical question' during his team meeting. While the initial reaction from his colleagues was one of surprise, they eventually participated, leading to unexpected and entertaining revelations about their musical pasts. Although the rest of the meeting proceeded in a typical business manner, the husband reported a positive outcome from the session. Parker also offers additional engaging questions on her social media, suggesting a variety of prompts designed to lighten the mood and encourage interaction. In contrast, a humorous take on effective meetings is presented through a cartoon that depicts individuals conducting planks instead of traditional meeting activities, highlighting the need for efficiency and engagement in professional settings.

TruthLens AI Analysis

The article explores the idea of making meetings more engaging and productive by incorporating "magical questions." It discusses the challenge of unproductive meetings, as highlighted by research from the London School of Economics, and offers insights from Priya Parker, a meeting specialist. The suggestion of starting meetings with personal questions aims to foster connection and creativity among participants.

Purpose of the Article

The writer aims to challenge the conventional approach to meetings, which are often seen as tedious and unproductive. By presenting the idea of using engaging questions, the article seeks to promote a more interactive and enjoyable meeting environment. The author’s skepticism towards this approach reflects a broader concern about maximizing efficiency in professional settings.

Perception in the Community

This article may foster a perception that there is a significant need to transform workplace culture to enhance collaboration and communication. It suggests that traditional meeting formats are outdated, thus encouraging professionals to rethink their approach. The emphasis on personal storytelling may also resonate with those who value workplace camaraderie.

Concealment of Information

While the article does not appear to hide specific information, it can be interpreted as downplaying the potential downsides of incorporating personal anecdotes into meetings, such as time consumption and the risk of veering off-topic. This could lead to a misunderstanding of the effectiveness of such strategies if not properly managed.

Manipulative Aspects

The article does not overtly manipulate information but rather promotes a new idea that could be seen as a trend. The casual language and personal anecdotes may evoke a sense of relatability, which could influence readers to adopt these practices without fully considering their implications.

Truthfulness of the Content

The information regarding the unproductivity of meetings is grounded in research, adding credibility. However, the effectiveness of "magical questions" is anecdotal, relying on personal experience rather than empirical evidence, which could impact the perceived reliability of the suggestions.

Underlying Message

The article subtly conveys that improvements in workplace dynamics can be achieved through simple changes in meeting formats. This aligns with contemporary discussions about enhancing employee engagement and well-being, promoting a culture where people feel valued and connected.

Connections to Other News

In the broader context, this article aligns with ongoing discussions about workplace culture, mental health, and productivity. It reflects a growing trend of prioritizing employee experiences and fostering environments that support creativity and collaboration.

Impact on Society and Economy

If widely adopted, the practices suggested could lead to more engaging workplaces, potentially improving job satisfaction and productivity. Improved morale could also have positive effects on economic performance, as employees who feel connected are likely to be more motivated and productive.

Community Support

This article may find support among progressive workplaces, HR professionals, and those advocating for a shift towards more human-centric work environments. It appeals to communities focused on innovation in management practices and workplace culture.

Market Influence

While the article primarily focuses on workplace dynamics, it could indirectly impact sectors related to corporate training, consulting, and employee engagement tools. Companies providing solutions for enhancing workplace culture may benefit from increased interest.

Geopolitical Relevance

There is no direct geopolitical relevance in this article, but it reflects broader societal shifts towards valuing mental health and productivity in the workplace, which can influence global business practices.

Use of AI in Writing

It is unlikely that AI played a significant role in the writing of this article, as it presents a personal narrative and subjective opinions that are characteristic of human authorship. The conversational tone and integration of personal anecdotes suggest a human touch rather than AI-driven content generation.

Manipulation Potential

The article does not exhibit strong manipulative traits, but the framing of personal questions as a solution to meeting woes may lead readers to overlook the complexities involved in effective communication within teams. The aim seems to be encouraging a shift in perspective rather than manipulating facts.

In conclusion, the article presents a thought-provoking perspective on improving meetings through personal engagement, but it is essential to approach such suggestions critically, considering both their potential benefits and drawbacks.

Unanalyzed Article Content

Source URL: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/may/26/could-the-right-question-bring-some-magic-to-your-meetings

Is there enough magic in your meetings? I can hear the hollow laughter from here.Research from the London School of Economicsfound that more than a third of meetings are considered unproductive, which seems awfully low to anyone who has been to a meeting, ever.

“People throw meetings at problems,” Priya Parker, meeting specialist and author ofThe Art of Gathering, lamented on theFixable podcastrecently, before offering her solution. Asked for a quick fix, she suggested kicking off with “a magical question”: one that everyone would be interested in answering and in hearing others answer. Her suggestion: “What was your first ever concert, and who took you?”

I’ve spoken to Parker and found her exceptionally impressive. But this seems like madness. Wouldn’t a round of prolonged reminiscences about first Glastos and bad dates (or in my case, slightly eccentrically, Everything But the Girl in Harrogate with my mum’s colleague’s husband, Andrew) add a minimum of 10 minutes to even the smallest gathering? Aren’t we all just desperate to get it over with?

But with my life mercifully meeting-free these days, perhaps I’m missing the nuances of 2025 meeting etiquette. I enlisted my husband to test this out at his daily team meeting and listened in, clipboard (OK, coffee) in hand. His colleagues seemed a little startled but played along, and the answers were fun: from some very unexpected metalheads to a 15-year-old punk being dragged along to Kool & the Gang to impress a girl. To my ears, the remainder of the meeting sounded exactly like it always does (loudly conducted in what I usually refer to as “business Martian”), but afterwards my spouse claimed it went well.

If you’re tempted, Parker offers other magical question ideas onher Instagram, including “When was the last time you blew up a balloon by yourself? What was the event?” and “What’s the weirdest thing you have ever found in your pocket?” But I reckon the cartoonist Sam Lau had a better idea in her New Yorker cartoon with the taglineHow to run short & effective meetings: it’s three people gathered around a laptop, all doing planks.

Emma Beddington is a Guardian columnist

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian