Beastly Britain by Karen R Jones review – how animals shaped British identity

TruthLens AI Suggested Headline:

"Exploring the Cultural Significance of Animals in British Identity"

View Raw Article Source (External Link)
Raw Article Publish Date:
AI Analysis Average Score: 8.1
These scores (0-10 scale) are generated by Truthlens AI's analysis, assessing the article's objectivity, accuracy, and transparency. Higher scores indicate better alignment with journalistic standards. Hover over chart points for metric details.

TruthLens AI Summary

In her insightful book, 'Beastly Britain', Karen R Jones explores the intricate relationships between Britain's human and animal populations, emphasizing how cultural perceptions of animals have evolved over time. Through vivid anecdotes, she illustrates the unique behaviors of various creatures, such as newts, which engage in a peculiar mating ritual that resembles a game of pass-the-parcel. Jones argues that our understanding of animals is deeply intertwined with cultural narratives, shaped by childhood stories and folklore. For instance, the hedgehog, once viewed with suspicion and malice, has undergone a transformation in public perception, largely due to Beatrix Potter's beloved character, Mrs. Tiggy-Winkle. This shift from viewing hedgehogs as pests to endearing symbols of British wildlife demonstrates how literature can profoundly influence societal attitudes towards animals.

Jones further delves into the lives of other animals, revealing surprising truths that contradict common stereotypes. Sheep, often dismissed as simple creatures, are shown to possess remarkable intelligence, capable of recognizing numerous individuals. The book also touches on the fascinating idea that modern pigeons are descendants of ancient dinosaurs, connecting us to a distant past. Additionally, it entertains the notion of mythical creatures still lurking in British waters, such as plesiosaurs, showcasing the blend of scientific inquiry and cultural mythology. Overall, 'Beastly Britain' serves as a compelling reminder of the rich tapestry of life that exists alongside humans, urging readers to reconsider their perceptions of the animal kingdom and the impact of cultural narratives on conservation efforts.

TruthLens AI Analysis

You need to be a member to generate the AI analysis for this article.

Log In to Generate Analysis

Not a member yet? Register for free.

Unanalyzed Article Content

When newts go a-wooing, sometime in the spring, their signature move is the handstand. Girl newts cluster round to watch, while the boy newts flip on to their creepily human hands and shake their tails in the air. The waggiest newt is the winner, although the actual act of love is a strictly no-contact sport. The male deposits a packet of sperm on an underwater leaf for the female to collect and insert into her own reproductive tract. The whole business is best thought of, says Karen R Jones, as a “sexually charged game of pass-the-parcel”.

This kind of anthropomorphising often strikes naturalists as unscientific or even downright distasteful. But Jones is an environmental historian and her methodology allows, indeed impels, her to start from the principle that Britain’s human and animal populations are culturally entwined. Consequently, we cannot “see” a fox, hedgehog or newt without bringing to it a rich stew of presumptions and fantasy, drawn from childhood picturebooks, out-of-date encyclopedias and, in my case, the 1970s TV classic Tales of the Riverbank, in which small critters say funny things in the West Country burr of .

This pre-knowing can have a radical impact on the chances of a particular species flourishing or going under. Take hedgehogs, which, Jones tells us in this beautifully written book, have been in Britain for the last 15m years. They witnessed the extinction of the woolly mammoth and saw the first humans arrive in Europe. It was at this point that they started to pick up a reputation for general malevolence. Bandit-like, hedgehogs were reputed to sneak into human settlements at night and steal poultry eggs (true) and suck the udders of sleeping cows (almost certainly false). Their ability to munch on toxic toads without getting sick (true) and willingness to ferry any witch who had lost her broomstick (surely very uncomfortable) confirmed that hedgehogs had gone over to the dark side. No wonder that killing them counted as a public service: the records of one Cheshire village show 8,585 hedgehogs destroyed over a 35-year period in the late 1600s.

How different from today, when the hedgehog routinely tops those “Britain’s favourite animal” polls. Now we build shelters for them in our gardens and worry about how they will fare when crossing the road. This radical shift of opinion, says Jones, can be traced back to one hugely popular book, Beatrix Potter’s The Tale of Mrs Tiggy-Winkle. Mrs Tiggy-Winkle is an industrious washerwoman who keeps her neighbours, including Peter Rabbit and his signature blue coat, spick and span. The influence of Potter’s 1905 classic has been so enduring that, when a charity was set up in 1983 to care for injured hedgehogs, it was obvious what its name should be. These days, Tiggywinkles is the largest wildlife hospital in the world.

Beastly Britain is full of stories like this, which take an everyday animal – newt, hedgehog, pigeon, sheep, flea – and map out both its physical life (a matter of burrows, breeding cycles and flight paths) as well as its cultural traces, which concern legend, loathing and desire. Often these two kinds of knowing collide in startling ways. Take sheep, which are mostly seen as “white noise in the countryside”, bland and bleating and only good for counting yourself to sleep. In fact, Jones reveals, they are crackingly clever, able to recognise the faces of up to 50 of their sheep-friends, not to mention their human guardians.

The revelations keep on coming. For instance, that we are still living among dinosaurs. The next time a pigeon swoops down to steal a chip, take a close look at its scaly, reptilian feet. They are the legacy of the Archaeopteryx, a winged dinosaur the size of a raven, with a bony tail, flight feathers and an ability to glide over short distances. Less persuasive, though even more intriguing, is the possibility that a pod of plesiosaurs still bobs off the Devon and Cornwall coast. How else to account for the string of sightings of a giant grey sea snake, with a long neck, snakey head and vicious tusks? The rational part of us knows that this sea monster is likely to be a basking shark or a giant piece of flotsam. Our dreaming part longs for it to be a remnant from ancient times, what Jones calls a “proximate peculiar”, that refuses to quite come into view.

Beastly Britain by Karen R Jones is published by Yale (£20). To support the Guardian, order your copy atguardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.

Back to Home
Source: The Guardian