The ABC breached the Fair Work Act when it removed casual broadcaster Antoinette Lattouf from a Sydney radio program because of a social media post about Gaza, justice Darryl Rangiah has found in a federal court judgment.
Rangiah upheld Lattouf’s claim heard in the federal court in February that she was unlawfully terminated in December 2023 when her on-air shifts were cut short three days into a five-day stint hosting Sydney Mornings.
“The respondent, theAustralian Broadcasting Corporation(the ABC) contravened s772(1) of theFair Work Act 2009(Cth) (the FWA) by terminating the employment of the applicant, Antoinette Lattouf, for reasons including that she held a political opinion opposing the Israeli military campaign in Gaza,” Rangiah wrote in the judgment.
But the court found Lattouf was not terminated because of her race or national extraction.
“The evidence does not support Ms Lattouf’s claims that [David] Anderson, [Ita Buttrose, [Chris] Oliver-Taylor and [Ben] Latimer made or materially contributed to a decision to terminate her employment for reasons that included her race or national extraction.”
The court ordered that the ABC pay Lattouf compensation of $70,000.
The Fair Work Act says an employer may not take adverse action against an employee because of their political opinion or race.
Before the judge read aloud a summary of the judgment, he handed out the full written reasons for his decision to the lawyers involved. There was a frantic flurry of papers being turned as the lawyers flipped through to find out if their side had won the day, even as Justice Darryl Rangiah was still describing the context of the case.
After 10 seconds of reading, one of Lattouf’s barristers, Philip Boncardo, turned to Lattouf behind him and nodded - she had won. She turned incredulous to lawyer Josh Bornstein, sitting next to her, who confirmed the news and Lattouf turned to her husband, sitting in the gallery behind her and mouth: “We won.”
Lattouf hugged the lawyers sitting beside her, then bowed her head and cried, as Rangiah continued laying out the history of the events at the heart of the case.
Lattouf was removed after she shared an Instagram post from Human Rights Watch that said Israel had used starvation as a “weapon of war” in Gaza.
Sign up toBreaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Her case argued that she was the subject of a pro-Israel lobbying campaign, the purpose of which was to remove her from air because of her social media support of Palestinian human rights.
Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email
However, the ABC said she was removed for not following a “direction” not to post about the war while working for the ABC.
Justice Rangiah found Lattouf was “merely provided with advice that it would be best not to post anything controversial about the war” and was not given a direction not to post.
More details to follow